Force chain dynamics in a quasi-static granular pile

Benjamin Allen, Nicholas Hayman · 2025

Read Force chain dynamics in a quasi-static granular pile by Benjamin Allen, Nicholas Hayman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20248.txt.

Introduction

Benjamin Allen and Nicholas Hayman watch force chains shift in a still pile of grains over weeks. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five. Grain piles can fail in sudden slides or creep in slow motion. Past accounts of that risk lean on friction, but the web of contact forces inside a pile is uneven and ever-shifting.

They image forces between clear discs in a flat pile at set gaps over a month. Shifts come in clusters at first, then long quiet spans break the pattern. Local stress grows stronger over time, even as the pile looks settled. Heat shifts may drive some events, while ground shakes show no link. Small inner shifts may prime big slides.

Catalog record

CREATORBenjamin Allen, Nicholas Hayman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20248

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Force chain dynamics in a quasi-static granular pile Benjamin Allen, Nicholas Hayman Abstract In nature, granular materials fail in abrupt avalanches, earthquakes, and other hazardous events, and also creep over time. Proposed failure mechanisms for these systems are broadly framed as friction-limited. However, mechanical descriptions of friction in granular system vary, including those that consider the non-linear, heterogeneous dynamics of grain-contact forces. In order to study granular controls on failure and creep, we imaged contact forces between quasi-2D photoelastic discs at 15-minute intervals in experiments over weeks- to one-month-long observation periods. In the experiments, the particles are distributed in a slope below the angle of repose with a concomitant establishment of the force-chain network approximately along the principal static stress directions. The discrete force-chain shifts are initially described by an age-weakening Weibull distribution in frequency over time, with the most common clusters of events < < 1000 minutes apart, but there are long quiescent periods that are not well described by the distribution. Different surface slopes show the same contact aging rate, but the steeper the slope the more likely there is to be a failure event. The post-settling discrete events accompany a longer term strengthening of the localized stresses. We observe that some events may be related to 2 o C temperature change, but associated ground motions measured by a laboratory-installed seismometer appear to have no correlation with particle displacements or force-chain changes. The sum of all ground motion is four orders of magnitude smaller than the temperature changes, further ruling out mechanical noise as an appreciable cause of events. The results illustrate that local, grain-scale changes in force-chain networks can occur long after a granular pile reaches a mesoscale apparently stable state, sometimes without obvious external forcings or imposed state changes. Such force-chain dynamics may underlie transitions in natural granular systems between large-scale failures and creep events. I Introduction Work at the intersection of geosciences and physics suggests that many hazardous failure events such as landslides, avalanches, and even earthquakes occur as grains become unjammed in complex ways Jerolmack and Daniels 2019 ; Daniels and Hayman 2008 . In the study of natural slope failure and creep, a common framework employs empirical friction laws that describe a quasi-stable regime governed by the effects of fluid pressure and frictional stability Iverson 2005 ; Finnegan and Saffer 2024 . The stability of faults, and their propensity for earthquakes vs. creep, have a long history of characterization via experimentally derived rate-and-state friction laws Dieterich 1972 ; Marone 1998 ; Nie and Barbot 2024 . However, recent experiments further identified smooth, diminishing slip below the static friction threshold Sirorattanakul et al. 2025 . Other experiments report transient motions in passive, sloped granular piles Deshpande et al. 2023 . These behaviors raise the question if there is a new framework needed for describing a broader range of granular behaviors. Granular materials behave in a manner that is not precisely that of a solid, liquid, or gas Jaeger et al. 1996 and granular systems can fail abruptly (i.e. avalanches) but also can deform over time scales longer than most observations periods. Small, slow deformations are broadly called creep . For granular systems, as with other failure phenomena, creep is often considered to arise through grain-scale dynamics Roering et al. 1999 ; Roering et al. 2001 ; Jerolmack and Daniels 2019 ; Sharpe 1938 ; Terzaghi 1950 ; Parizek and Woodruff 1957 ; Allen and Kudrolli 2018 ; Sirorattanakul et al. 2025 . Here, we further restrict our definition of creep to the non-reversible movement of particles below the initiation of rolling-sliding transport. One way to describe granular systems is to consider both the average micromechanics of grain contacts, and the inhomogeneous stress distributions that arise as the system is driven towards a fully constrained particle configuration. Sloping granular piles are an excellent way to probe this contrast between average and inhomogeneous behaviors. At the mesoscale, a slope is considered stable when it exists below an angle of repose which is in turn determined by the geometry and friction of the particles. In nature, steeper slopes are more likely to fail via avalanches and mass wasting, but shallower slopes can also slump, slide and creep Ribiére et al. 2005a ; Ferdowsi et al. 2018 . However, the angle of repose actually has a range of values when the angle is either decreased or increased to attain the repose angle Beakawi Al-Hashemi and Baghabra Al-Amoudi 2018 ; Cheng and Zhao 2017 . Then, as a granular pile approaches a state of rest, the force distribution and particle contact chains will evolve as the system evolves from a fragile state to a fully jammed state Cates et al. 1998 ; Liu and Nagel 2010 ; Bi et al. 2011 ; Behringer et al. 2014 ; Behringer and Chakraborty 2019 . There are a large number of possible jammed states with different particle configurations within a small range of densities, and these states exist well before the system approaches the global equilibrium state. The nature of jamming is such that it creates structure out of a random configuration of particles including arches and pockets where particles can be held without being confined. For example, an interesting byproduct of these configurations is that unconfined particles, or rattlers , are easier to move but are not part of the main force bearing structure, and the kinetic energy of these particles decays slower than that of the bulk Giacco et al. 2017 . Other granular structures form under stress, with and without rattlers, concentrating the particle stresses along a chain of particle which can support small deflection of the forces and arch-like structures Cates et al. 1998 . Granular structures are often described as having an average state, but the mechanics of granular structures is also determined by the fluctuations of a few constituents rather than the mean behavior of all the particles Claudin and Bouchaud 1997 and not all observed behavior can be described by average constitutive relationships. This makes employing granular-physics models for predictive earth-science problems challenging, but also is why there are many still undiscovered local behaviors that could underlie mesoscale behaviors, such as landslides and slope creep. Here, we present the results of experiments that allow the visualization of in situ stresses in a tapered granular pile, with minimal perturbation. Local stress changes and particle motions all happen below the angle of repose, and in some instances long after the pile settles into an apparently stable configuration. In order to investigate these dynamics, we take advantage of the direct imaging of particle forces within birefringent materials under cross-polarized light Daniels and Hayman 2008 ; Daniels et al. 2017 ; Zadeh et al. 2019 . This method has been used to explore cooperativity between particles Thomas et al. 2019 , fault slip Daniels and Hayman 2008 ; Hayman et al. 2010 , avalanches Báres et al. 2017 , impact and penetration experiments Clark et al. 2012 . The resulting polarized light in the photoelastic discs allow for the direct imaging of stress localization in isotropic grain packings by illuminating force chains , the linking of localized stress to form long-range directionally interacting particles. Force-chain changes in a granular

Read the complete text