A rigorous data-driven approach to the nucleation of defects in metals exploiting the link between kinetic properties and (dis)order parameters
Mattia Perrone, David D. Girardier, Giovanni M. Pavan, Fabio Pietrucci · 2025
Read A rigorous data-driven approach to the nucleation of defects in metals exploiting the link between kinetic properties and (dis)order parameters by Mattia Perrone, David D. Girardier, Giovanni M. Pavan, Fabio Pietrucci (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20211.txt.
Introduction
Mattia Perrone and co-authors present a 2025 study on how defects are born inside metals. A new structure forming inside a uniform one is called nucleation. In metals, the key defects are dislocations, line flaws that rule how the metal bends and carries heat. Simulations can watch atoms move, yet pinning the birth path and its rate stays hard. The tracking gauge a study picks turns out to matter a lot.
A poor gauge bends the rate that the same data seem to give. The team turn that flaw into a tool: a data-driven scheme hunts the best gauge by a variational rule. The best gauge yields a faithful picture of the birth path. Their test case is dislocation birth in a crystal. Sound gauges could sharpen many rate studies in materials science.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mattia Perrone, David D. Girardier, Giovanni M. Pavan, Fabio Pietrucci |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20211
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A rigorous data-driven approach to the nucleation of defects in metals exploiting the link between kinetic properties and (dis)order parameters Mattia Perrone, David D. Girardier, Giovanni M. Pavan, Fabio Pietrucci Abstract Nucleation processes, through which a new structure progressively forms within a pre-existing homogeneous phase, are fundamental in materials science, but are also typically non-trivial to elucidate. Cases in which to nucleate are defects (or disorder) in an initially ordered structure make no exception. A prominent example is the nucleation of dislocations in metals, which critically govern their mechanical, electronic, thermal, and chemical properties. While atomic-level insights can be attained using, e.g. , molecular dynamics simulations, systematically characterizing nucleation mechanisms and accurately quantifying kinetic rates remain challenging tasks. In this work, we demonstrate how the choice of the order parameter used to track the transition has a very strong effect on the accuracy of the kinetic rate predicted from the corresponding free-energy barrier and diffusion coefficient, a fact that has been often overlooked in the past. By exploiting this systematic error to our advantage, we demonstrate that it is possible to rigorously characterize the nucleation process using a data-driven scheme based on a variational principle, leading to optimal order parameters and a faithful mechanistic description. We apply this method to characterize, as a representative case study, the nucleation of dislocations in crystalline f c c fcc copper by analyzing replica molecular dynamics simulations at the elastic-plastic limit. By means of committor analysis and Langevin modeling, our approach allows to systematically rank candidate (dis)order parameters, identify the critical nuclei (transition states), and infer the free-energy landscapes. Given its general foundations, this method can be extended to nucleation phenomena in a broad class of materials. 1 Introduction Dislocations are fundamental family of defects that are key metals, semiconductors, and a variety of other materials. [ 1 ] They correspond to localized regions where atoms deviate from their ideal lattice positions, giving rise to line defects around which atomic planes exhibit discontinuities. [ 2 ] Due to the lattice distortions that they induce, dislocations strongly influence many material properties—most notably mechanical characteristics such as, e.g. , strength, ductility, and plasticity, but also electronic, thermal, and chemical behavior. [ 3 , 4 ] Understanding dislocation dynamics thus carries significant theoretical and practical importance across materials science and engineering. [ 5 , 6 ] The emergence of dislocations in response to applied stress is a nucleation phenomenon. [ 4 ] Such nucleation can occur homogeneously within a defect-free crystal (as observed, e.g. , under nanoindentation or in nanostructured materials [ 7 ] ) or heterogeneously at structural discontinuities such as surfaces or grain boundaries. Phenomenologically, atoms locally displace from their equilibrium positions, gradually aggregating into a critical nucleus of distorted atomic arrangements. This process is orchestrated by a sequence of thermally-induced fluctuations that accumulate within the material up to a critical threshold. [ 8 ] At this critical configuration, the nucleus has an equal probability (50%) of either reverting to the defect-free state or evolving irreversibly into a stable dislocation. This constitutes the transition state, which crossing triggers the motion of an entire plane (dislocation propagation). Such nucleation process has been primarily studied as a function of four key factors, such as chemical composition (single-element metals and alloys), structural characteristics (bulk material, interfaces, and pre-existing defects), applied stress, and temperature. [ 9 , 7 , 10 ] In general, atomistic simulations are a particularly valuable tool for studying this phenomenon, [ 11 ] as they allow complete control over the aforementioned factors. [ 7 , 12 ] In this context, transition state theory (TST)-based methods have been employed to assess the kinetics and thermodynamics of the nucleation phenomena [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] , along with studies aimed at investigating the enthalpic and entropic effects involved in them. [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] Despite being a fundamental problem, the literature lacks studies that address dislocation nucleation in its detailed atomistic mechanism and that identify in a compelling way the transition states and the optimal order parameters to characterize it. In fact, in nucleation, as in thermally-activated phenomena in general, the systematic study and testing of order parameters is crucial because they provide both mechanistic insight and a low-dimensional representation of the transition process, that in turn affects the estimation of free-energy barriers and kinetic rates. [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] The development, comparison, and optimization of candidate order parameters – using advanced techniques based on rigorous statistical mechanics – have thus become a central focus in modern computational physical-chemistry/chemical-physics, with significant progress in the last decades particularly in the study of crystallization processes. [ 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] Nevertheless, despite the interest and considerable efforts in many fields, to the best of our knowledge, relatively little attention has been devoted to the study of dislocations nucleation. As a notable example, an order parameter to monitor the progress of dislocations was introduced in Ref. [ 29 ] , in a study on Ni 3 Al under dynamic and static loading conditions. Such parameter was constructed by tracking atoms with relative displacements exceeding a critical threshold compared to their neighbors, allowing the identification of hot spots, regions of localized atomic displacements that act as precursors to homogeneous dislocation nucleation. This is in line with what has been done recently in similar or other contexts with physics-based or abstract descriptors. [ 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ] Recently, it has been also shown how all such effects can be related to important fluctuations, and how they appear in space and time. [ 36 , 8 ] The hot spots identified in Ref. [ 29 ] , characterized by interatomic displacements approaching half the Shockley partial Burgers vector, were shown to evolve into small dislocation loops that subsequently expanded to form slip planes. Subsequently, Ryu et al. [ 19 ] extended this concept to study dislocation nucleation in copper, examining both homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation under compression across a wide range of applied stresses and temperatures. In that work, the nucleation kinetic rates were computed using Becker-Döring theory [ 37 ] and the free-energy barriers were determined using umbrella sampling techniques and compared with zero-temperature estimates: the obtained results highlighted the importance of considering entropy contributions, which were shown to enhance nucleation rates by orders of magnitude compared to predictions based solely on, e.g. , the activation potential energy ( \Delta U). Building on this scenario, in this work we aim at providing a more advanced description and deeper insight into the degrees of freedom responsible for the homogeneous nucleation of dislocation defects, identifying the transition states (using committor analysis), reconstructing equilibrium free-energy barriers, and estimating the associated kinetic rates based solely from unbiased MD trajectories. We exploit rigorous tools from statistical mechanics and the theory of stochastic processes, specifically maximum-likelihood inference methods applied to Langevin models, complemented by robust diagnostics to validate the optimal models that we identify. [ 38 ] We perform equilibrium MD simulations at constant volume under pre-yield conditions (highlighted by the blue region in Fig. 1 A), ensuring that dislocation