Implications of shallow-shell models for topographic relaxation on icy satellites

Colin R. Meyer, Aaron G. Stubblefield, Brent M. Minchew, Samuel S. Pegler, Alexander Berne, Jacob J. Buffo, Tara C. Tomlinson · 2025

Read Implications of shallow-shell models for topographic relaxation on icy satellites by Colin R. Meyer, Aaron G. Stubblefield, Brent M. Minchew, Samuel S. Pegler, Alexander Berne, Jacob J. Buffo, Tara C. Tomlinson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-20095.txt.

Introduction

Colin Meyer and co-authors present a 2025 paper on how surface shapes relax on icy moons. Icy satellites carry relief at every scale, from rifts and craters to hemisphere-wide shell thickness swings. How fast bumps flatten depends on ice flow properties, shell thickness, density contrast with a possible ocean, and tidal heating. The authors start from the Stokes equations for slow viscous flow. They write out shallow-shell models, with and without a rigid crust.

A three-dimensional linearized analysis for small bumps recovers the shallow models' timescales. It also covers shells the shallow view cannot. Planetary scientists get checked clocks for reading moon landscapes. A crater's softness becomes a thermometer and thickness gauge for the shell below. Getting the timescales right matters for judging whether oceans persist under the ice today. Model cross-checks guard against shortcuts that bend those judgments.

Catalog record

CREATORColin R. Meyer, Aaron G. Stubblefield, Brent M. Minchew, Samuel S. Pegler, Alexander Berne, Jacob J. Buffo, Tara C. Tomlinson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-20095

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Implications of shallow-shell models for topographic relaxation on icy satellites Colin R. Meyer, Aaron G. Stubblefield, Brent M. Minchew, Samuel S. Pegler, Alexander Berne, Jacob J. Buffo, Tara C. Tomlinson Abstract Icy satellites host topography at many length scales, from rifts and craters on the small end to equatorial-pole shell thickness differences that are comparable to these bodies’ circumference. The rate of topographic evolution depends on the rheology of the ice shell, the difference in density between the shell and potential global subsurface oceans, the ice shell thickness distribution, as well as the rate of tidal heat dissipation in the shell. The current paradigm is that icy satellites should not host stable small-scale topography. This idea comes from previous work using a “shallow”-shell model (i.e. ice shell circumference is much larger than shell thickness) with a rigid outer crust. In this limit, large-scale topography relaxes over a longer time scale than small-scale features. Here we revisit this paradigm and analyze relaxation of topography starting from the Stokes equations for viscous fluid flow. We write out the shallow-shell models (with and without a rigid crust) and compare the resulting time scales to previous work. Using three-dimensional linearized flow for small-amplitude topographic perturbations, we recover the time scales of relaxation from the shallow models as well as shells that are not shallow. For a shell of constant viscosity, we find that the topographic relaxation time scale is constant for wavelengths larger than the ice thickness, an idea that runs contrary to the existing paradigm. For a shell with a viscosity that decreases exponentially with depth, we show numerically that there is a regime where the larger viscosity outer crust acts as a nearly rigid boundary. In this case, the relaxation time scale depends on the wavelength. For the largest spatial scales, however, the time scale becomes independent of wavelength again and the value is set by the average shell viscosity. However, the spatial scale that this transition occurs at becomes larger as the viscosity contrast increases, limiting the applicability of the scale-independent relaxation rate. These results for the relaxation of topography have implications for interpreting relaxed crater profiles, inferences of ice shell thickness from topography, and upcoming observations from missions to the outer solar system. 1 Introduction Icy satellites are water ice-covered moons of the outer solar system. These icy moons occur around all of the gas giants, e.g. Jupiter hosts Europa, Saturn hosts Enceladus, Uranus hosts Miranda, Neptune hosts Triton, and many others. Ocean worlds are a subset of the icy satellites for which the ice shell overlies a liquid ocean. Europa is thought to have a liquid ocean due to magnetic reversal observed by the Galileo spacecraft ( Kivelson et al. 2000 ) . Evidence for an ocean on Enceladus comes primarily from observations of the moon’s libration ( Thomas et al. 2016 ) . Some icy satellites are geologically active bodies hosting, for example, systems that suggest tectonics, plate motion, geysers, and convection ( Nimmo and Pappalardo 2016 ) . Large-scale topography, as is present on Enceladus ( Giese et al. 2008 ; Iess et al. 2014 ; Hemingway et al. 2018 ; Hemingway and Mittal 2019 ; Berne et al. 2023a ; Berne et al. 2023b ) , is expected to drive lateral differences in the melting temperature at the base of the ice shell ( Rempel et al. 2022 ; Kang 2022 ; Style et al. 2023 ) . These differences correspondingly imply differences in hydrostatic pressure, which may drive ocean circulation ( Ashkenazy et al. 2018 ; Zeng and Jansen 2021 ; Kang et al. 2022 ; Kang 2022 ; Kang and Jansen 2022 ) . The ice shell thickness also affects conductive and convective heat flow in the satellite ( Zeng and Jansen 2021 ; Carnahan et al. 2021 ) . Knowledge of the ice shell thickness also informs the extent that surface is topography is isostatically compensated, e.g. Airy isostasy ( Hemingway et al. 2018 ; Hemingway and Mittal 2019 ; Čadek et al. 2019b ; Čadek et al. 2019a ; Akiba et al. 2022 ) . In this way, improving dynamic ice flow models could improve inferences of ice shell thickness from observations of ice satellite’s shape and gravity field. Given the central role large-scale ice flow plays in numerous processes and the upcoming gravity and topography data from upcoming planetary missions (e.g. NASA’s Europa Clipper and ESA’s Juice), understanding viscous deformation of icy satellite shells is important. In an earlier paper, Nimmo 2004 showed that there should not be any small-scale topography on icy satellites. In the next section, we write out the details of this argument mathematically, but in words, the Nimmo 2004 idea follows from a scaling analysis resulting in a relaxation time scale that is small for small-scale topography and large for large-scale topography. The implication is that small-scale topography relaxes away so quickly that only the large-scale topography is likely to be observable in the present. In this paper, we revisit the Nimmo 2004 argument for the purported non-existance of small-scale topography, make connections to viscous flow on glaciers and ice shelves on Earth, and present new scaling relationships for topographic relaxation on icy satellites. In section 2, we describe the model, boundary conditions, and two “shallow” approximations based on the fact that the ice shell circumference is much larger than its thickness, which is true for most icy satellites. In section 3, we present scalings for the different regimes and discuss the implications for topographic relaxation time scales. We also discuss a linearized analysis for perturbations to ice thickness. In section 4, we include spatial variation in the shell viscosity into our model and compare our results to the prior analysis. In section 5, we discuss the role of spatially varying viscosity in the context of prior work and our analysis. Finally, in section 6, we conclude by describing our results and comparing them to the scaling relationship derived by Nimmo 2004 . 2 Model for ice flow within icy satellite shells We treat the flow within the ice shell as viscous motion at zero Reynolds number, where differences in ice shell thickness lead to gravity-driven deformation. The equations of conservation of momentum and mass in this context are the Stokes equations, given by \displaystyle\nabla\cdot\left\{\mu\left[\nabla\boldsymbol{u}+\left(\nabla\boldsymbol{u}\right)^{T}\right]\right\}=\boldsymbol{\nabla}p+\rho g\boldsymbol{\hat{z}}, (1) \displaystyle\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot\boldsymbol{u}=0, (2) where \boldsymbol{u} is the velocity of ice parcels within the shell, p is the pressure, \rho_{i} is the ice density, which we treat as constant, g is gravity, and \mu is the ice viscosity. The Stokes equations for a Newtonian fluid are time-invariant, reversible, and linear ( Acheson 1990 ) . We consider nonlinear effects in section 4 . Laboratory, field, and remote sensing studies of glacier ice ( Goldsby and Kohlstedt 2001 ; Millstein et al. 2022 , e.g.) show that the ice viscosity is a nonlinear function of the strain rate (i.e., a power law, which is sometimes called Glen’s law) and a strongly nonlinear function of the temperature (Arrhenius exponential). There has been significant work on exploring the roles of nonlinear processes on the viscosity, e.g., temperature, grain size, and strain rate ( Nimmo 2004 ; Barr and Pappalardo 2005 ; Rudolph and Manga 2012

Read the complete text