Crafting a Personal Journaling Practice: Negotiating Ecosystems of Materials, Personal Context, and Community in Analog Journaling

Katherine Lin, Juna Kawai-Yue, Adira Sklar, Lucy Hecht, Sarah Sterman, Tiffany Tseng · 2025

Read Crafting a Personal Journaling Practice: Negotiating Ecosystems of Materials, Personal Context, and Community in Analog Journaling by Katherine Lin, Juna Kawai-Yue, Adira Sklar, Lucy Hecht, Sarah Sterman, Tiffany Tseng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-19767.txt.

Introduction

Katherine Lin and five co-authors study how people build a habit of writing in a paper journal over time. Those who keep journals hold strong views on their books, pens, page layouts, and what should go on the page. The team sought to see how those tastes form and settle in.

They went through journal content shared in public on YouTube and Instagram, and they spoke with eleven journalers one on one. Habits, it turns out, are shaped by three forces at once: the stuff used, the person's own life and needs, and the group round them. Those forces also feed how journalers see who they are. The team close with design ideas for tools to come. Good support, they argue, should respect what paper is good at, not press it flat into apps like any other.

Catalog record

CREATORKatherine Lin, Juna Kawai-Yue, Adira Sklar, Lucy Hecht, Sarah Sterman, Tiffany Tseng
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-19767

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Crafting a Personal Journaling Practice: Negotiating Ecosystems of Materials, Personal Context, and Community in Analog Journaling Katherine Lin, Juna Kawai-Yue, Adira Sklar, Lucy Hecht, Sarah Sterman, Tiffany Tseng Abstract . Analog journaling has grown in popularity, with journaling on paper encompassing a range of motivations, styles, and practices including planning, habit-tracking, and reflecting. Journalers develop strong personal preferences around the tools they use, the ideas they capture, and the layout in which they represent their ideas and memories. Understanding how analog journaling practices are individually shaped and crafted over time is critical to supporting the varied benefits associated with journaling, including improved mental health and positive support for identity development. To understand this development, we qualitatively analyzed publicly-shared journaling content from YouTube and Instagram and interviewed 11 journalers. We report on our identification of the journaling ecosystem in which journaling practices are shaped by materials , personal context , and communities , sharing how this ecosystem plays a role in the practices and identities of journalers as they customize their journaling routine to best suit their personal goals. Using these insights, we discuss design opportunities for how future tools can better align with and reflect the rich affordances and practices of journaling on paper. DOI: 10.1145/3698061.3726923 Conference: Creativity and Cognition; June 23–25, 2025; Virtual ISBN: 979-8-4007-1289-0/25/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI 1. Introduction Putting thoughts to the page is a storied practice, with physical notebooks playing a critical role in supporting idea-construction ( Abtahi et al., 2020 ; Inie et al., 2022 ) , memory ( Cardell, 2017 ) , and historical preservation for centuries ( Allen, 2024 ) . The practice of journaling in particular, or the autobiographical recording of one’s experiences, thoughts, aspirations, and ideas, has a long history of supporting well-being and self-reflection ( Ayobi et al., 2018 ; Baldwin, 1977 ; Michael Brady and Sky, 2003 ; Rainer, 1979 ; Yuan, 2021 ) . Despite a wide array of digital tools available today for note-taking and journaling, there has been a recent revitalization of analog journaling on paper, with the rise of Japanese stationery products in western markets ( Ha, 2025 ) and heavily accessorized decorative planning ( Legardye, 2020 ) , especially among Gen Z and millennials ( Donnell, 2022 ) . Hashtags like #journaling and #junkjournal, along with well-beloved notebook brands like #hobonichi and #travelersnotebook, each have over 1 million posts on Instagram, indicating the popularity and strength of active users engaging with journaling today. Recent efforts studying journaling practices in HCI have focused on data-driven practices, such as users who engage in lifelogging in the ‘quantified-self’ movement ( Abtahi et al., 2020 ; Ayobi et al., 2018 ) , as well as use of digital notetaking applications ( Elsden et al., 2016a ; Grahame, 2016 ; Shi et al., 2020 ; Katayama et al., 2005 ) and blogging ( Davis, 2010 ; Boniel-Nissim and Barak, 2013 ; Celdrán et al., 2019 ) . These efforts have examined user motivations for journaling and how well these motivations are supported by both analog and digital practices. In contrast, our research is primarily concerned with how user’s journaling practices develop over time and the role of factors beyond the page in shaping journaling practice. Our goals are to, 1) characterize the attributes and factors that contribute to how an individual crafts their own journaling practice, 2) identify design considerations for how these factors might be better accounted for in future journaling tools. To uncover user practices and preferences when engaging with analog journaling over time, we utilized data across three sources: YouTube videos of journalers sharing their favorite stationery tools; Instagram posts sharing a diversity of journaling layouts; and interviews with active journalers in which they shared their physical journals and described how their journaling routine and goals develop. These data sources enable us to consider how material choices, such as what writing instruments and accessories are used, manifest on the page and relate to an individual’s decisions about what their journal represents about their life. Through this analysis, we situated analog journaling in a larger ecosystem of materials , personal context , and community that each contribute to how journalers choose how to journal and what to journal about. We then discuss design opportunities for how changing practices over time can be more fully considered in the design of future tools to support journalers. Overall, our contributions are: (1) A framework of a journaling ecosystem and description of how each component of this ecosystem affects journaling practices (2) Characterization of how journaling practices are crafted and formed over time and identifications of shortcomings and opportunities for journaling tools and technologies to better align with these practices 2. Related Work Our research draws from literature in the space of personal documentation more broadly to inform our understanding and interpretations of modern journaling practices, given how central documentation is to both the act of writing and motivations for doing so. This related work section covers two areas: 1) an overview of documentation practices and preferences across domains, and 2) tools that blend digital and analog approaches to supporting documentation. 2.1. Documentation Practices and Preferences Personal documentation practices span diverse domains and user motivations ( Allen, 2024 ) . For example, documentation and various forms of journaling are a popular practice for supporting physical health ( Luo et al., 2021 ; Cordeiro et al., 2015 ; Anhøj et al., 2004 ) , mental well-being ( Smyth et al., 2018 ; Jean-Berluche, 2024 ; Langan and Keppen, 2022 ) , and mindfulness ( Ayobi et al., 2018 ; Ramasubramanian, 2017 ) . Personal documentation plays a critical role for creative practices, including artistic expression ( Li et al., 2021 ; Sterman et al., 2022 ) and idea management ( Inie et al., 2022 ; Rosselli Del Turco and Dalsgaard, 2024 ; Dalsgaard et al., 2023 ) . It is commonly associated with user goals of capturing and preserving one’s legacy ( Gulotta et al., 2013 ) and daily life through life-logging ( Abtahi et al., 2020 ; Choe et al., 2014 ; Elsden et al., 2016b ; Elsden et al., 2016a ) . In the context of analog documentation, prior research sheds light on the benefits of reflective writing on paper, which offers an open format that can foster self-discovery ( Yuan, 2021 ; Davis, 2010 ) . For instance, studies on self-tracking and bullet journaling, which incorporate habit, health, and wellness tracking, show that users value the slow process provided by paper, which enables reflection, relaxation, and the ability to reminisce ( Abtahi et al., 2020 ) . Additionally, people appreciate the flexibility of paper ( Luo et al., 2021 ; Ayobi et al., 2018 ) and its finite space, which encourages prioritization ( Tholander and Normark, 2020 ; Abtahi et al., 2020 ; Fernández Camporro and Marquardt, 2020 ) . Further, prior work has shown how people value the natural wear and tear of materials as they convey evolution and context, such as homemade cookbooks ( Davis et al., 2014 ) and heritage artifacts ( Gulotta et al., 2013 ) , suggesting that meaning lies not only in content but also in its physical form.

Read the complete text