Self-testing of Nonmaximal Genuine Entangled States using Tripartite Hardy Relations

Ranendu Adhikary, Souradeep Sasmal, Arup Roy · 2025

Read Self-testing of Nonmaximal Genuine Entangled States using Tripartite Hardy Relations by Ranendu Adhikary, Souradeep Sasmal, Arup Roy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-19491.txt.

Introduction

Ranendu Adhikary, Souradeep Sasmal, and Arup Roy wrote this 2025 paper on certifying quantum states through a style of nonlocality test. Three parties, far apart, share an entangled state. The team compares Hardy-type tests with the better-known Mermin-type tests, and finds the Hardy form shows stronger nonlocal behavior in the three-party case.

They build a general frame for three-party correlations by widening two independence notions from the two-party world. Within it, Hardy tests can self-certify a wide class of partly entangled pure states, even when the test score falls short of its peak. That trait, they note, lets the same setup mint proven randomness, up to about 2.8 bits. The authors frame Hardy reasoning as a sharper tool for device-free quantum checks.

Catalog record

CREATORRanendu Adhikary, Souradeep Sasmal, Arup Roy
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-19491

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Self-testing of Nonmaximal Genuine Entangled States using Tripartite Hardy Relations Ranendu Adhikary, Souradeep Sasmal, Arup Roy Abstract We demonstrate that, in the tripartite scenario with all parties’ local events being space-like separated, Hardy-type nonlocality constitutes a stronger manifestation of nonlocal correlations than those captured by Mermin-type inequalities, an important distinction that has hitherto remained unrecognised. To substantiate this assertion, we develop a general framework for the characterisation of tripartite correlations by extending the notion of Settings Independence and Outcome Independence beyond their bipartite formulation. This framework highlights the pivotal role of Hardy-type reasoning in the detection and certification of genuine multipartite nonlocality. Furthermore, we show that the tripartite Hardy-nonlocality enables the self-testing of a broad class of pure nonmaximally genuine entangled tripartite states. A key advantage of Hardy-based self-testing over methods based on tripartite Bell inequalities is its ability to certify quantum correlations even in the presence of nonmaximal violations. This, in turn, facilitates the device-independent certification of randomness from Hardy-type correlations. Unlike Bell functionals, which typically enable self-testing of only a single extremal point per inequality, Hardy relation self-tests a set of extremal quantum correlations for any nonzero Hardy probability. We find that the maximum certifiable randomness using Hardy-type correlations is log 2 ​ 7 ≈ 2.8073 \log_{2}7\approx 2.8073 -bits, highlighting both the practical and foundational significance of Hardy-based techniques for quantum randomness generation. I Introduction In practical quantum experiments, a key challenge lies in verifying whether the observed statistics genuinely originate from the intended quantum state and measurements, particularly when the devices are untrusted. Self-testing, based on the Bell nonlocality, addresses this by enabling the inference of both quantum states and measurements directly from observed correlations (i.e., joint probability distributions), without any assumptions regarding the internal workings of the devices [ 1 ] . As such, self-testing underpins many applications in device-independent (DI) quantum information processing, including cryptography, randomness generation, delegated quantum computation, and foundational studies of quantum theory. Bell nonlocality [ 2 ] is typically witnessed through the violation of suitable Bell inequalities, which are linear functionals defined over the set of joint probability distributions [ 3 ] . Within the quantum set, the optimal violations corresponds to unique extremal correlations, realised by specific quantum strategies (up to local unitaries and complex conjugation). Hence, optimal Bell violations form the basis for self-testing [ 1 ] . However, many extremal quantum correlations are non-exposed; they do not maximise any Bell functional and thus cannot be self-tested through Bell inequality violations. These non-exposed extremal points often originate from nonmaximally entangled states, exposing a fundamental limitation of linear Bell inequalities. To overcome this, alternative approaches characterising the full quantum behaviour have been proposed [ 4 ] . Of particular interest are Hardy-type nonlocal arguments [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Hardy’s argument demonstrates that if certain events are constrained to have zero probability within a local ontic (realist) model, then another event, the Hardy probability, must also necessarily vanish [ 5 ] . Yet, quantum theory predicts a strictly nonzero value for specific states [ 5 ] , resulting in a direct contradiction with the predictions of any local realist model. It has been shown that Hardy nonlocality enables self-testing [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] of non-exposed extremal correlations on the nosignalling boundary [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] , even without maximal violation, thereby certifying a broader class of quantum correlations than those accessible via Bell inequalities. Despite this promise, Hardy-based self-testing has so far been largely confined to bipartite systems. In particular, the self-testing of tripartite systems remains significantly less explored. Early developments in multipartite self-testing concentrated on graph states [ 14 ] , the maximally entangled GHZ state [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] , and subsequently on partially entangled GHZ states via stabiliser-based approaches [ 18 ] . The W state [ 19 ] , another prominent multipartite entangled state, has been self-tested using the SWAP method [ 20 ] . Nevertheless, progress in this area has been constrained by the intrinsic complexity of multipartite systems [ 21 , 22 ] and the rich variety of pure tripartite entangled states, each characterised by distinct entanglement structures. Further challenges arise from issues such as bi-separability and the reliable identification of genuine multipartite entanglement [ 23 ] , complicating the self-testing landscape even further. A major conceptual challenge in multipartite scenarios is that the definition of locality itself becomes significantly more nuanced [ 24 , 21 , 22 , 25 ] . For instance, in a setting with three spatially separated parties (Alice, Bob, and Charlie), generating deterministic outputs from local inputs can exhibit fully-local correlations [ 26 ] . If no causal constraints are imposed between two of the parties (e.g., Bob and Charlie), the correlations reduce to bilocal forms [ 24 , 22 ] . Any correlation that cannot be decomposed into such a bilocal form is said to exhibit genuine multipartite nonlocality. In this work, we propose a framework for characterising multipartite nonlocality based on the notions of Settings Independence (SI) and Outcome Independence (OI), generalising the seminal ideas of Jarrett and Shimony from the bipartite case [ 27 , 28 ] . This framework not only provides a clearer conceptual foundation for understanding nonlocality in tripartite systems, but also captures essential causal independence constraints across multiple parties. Specifically, we show that this approach brings out a stronger form of tripartite nonlocality exhibited by the tripartite Hardy relation proposed in [ 29 ] than was previously identified. We begin by showing that fully local correlations satisfy mutual SI and OI between all parties, implying a vanishing Hardy probability. Remarkably, we find that even if two-way OI is relaxed between any pair (e.g., Bob and Charlie), the Hardy probability remains zero. This leads us to conclude that that a nonzero Hardy probability necessarily implies the failure of both two-way SI across all parties and two-way OI between at least one pair. Moreover, we show that such correlations correspond precisely to nosignalling genuine nonlocal correlations, as characterised in [ 22 ] , thereby enabling the certification of genuine multipartite nonlocality in scenarios where the local events of Alice, Bob, and Charlie are space-like separated. Building upon this, we leverage Hardy-type genuine nonlocality to self-test a broad class of pure, genuinely entangled tripartite quantum states, including scenarios where the Hardy relation is nonmaximally violated. Furthermore, we demonstrate that such self-testing facilitates the certification of genuine quantum randomness from observed Hardy statistics, highlighting both the foundational significance and the practical utility of our results. The paper is organised as follows. In Sec. II , we introduce the notion of OI and SI and establish that tripartite Hardy nonlocal correlations are genuine nonlocal. Sec. III characterises all pure three-qubit states compatible with the Hardy-type nonlocality conditions. In Sec. IV , we show how to self-test quantum states that exhibit nonmaximal Hardy violations. Sec. V derives the maximum certifiable randomness arising from Hardy-type correlations. We conclude with a discussion of the implications and future directions in Sec. VI . II Tripartite Hardy-type nonlocality Let us consider three spatially separated observers: Alice, Bob, and Charlie. Each party independently performs randomly selected one of two possible local

Read the complete text