Wave Energy Is Conserved in a Spatially Varying and Inhomogeneously Moving Medium

Zhaohua Wu, Jie Sun, Zhe-Min Tan, Ming Cai, Yongyun Hu, Norden E Huang · 2025

Read Wave Energy Is Conserved in a Spatially Varying and Inhomogeneously Moving Medium by Zhaohua Wu, Jie Sun, Zhe-Min Tan, Ming Cai, Yongyun Hu, Norden E Huang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-19302.txt.

Introduction

Zhaohua Wu and co-authors settle a basic question about waves moving through shifting media. Textbooks hold that when a wave crosses a flow that varies in space and motion, the conserved quantity is wave action, not wave energy. That claim seemed to dent the law of energy conservation itself, so the team set out to test it.

They prove that wave action conservation is really wave energy conservation in disguise. As a wave travels through such a medium, it deforms, and the deformation hides the energy bookkeeping. Their derivation draws wave action straight from the energy law. The authors say the result holds for every isolated wave system in varying media, from water waves to waves far beyond fluids.

Catalog record

CREATORZhaohua Wu, Jie Sun, Zhe-Min Tan, Ming Cai, Yongyun Hu, Norden E Huang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-19302

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Wave Energy Is Conserved in a Spatially Varying and Inhomogeneously Moving Medium Zhaohua Wu, Jie Sun, Zhe-Min Tan, Ming Cai, Yongyun Hu, Norden E Huang Abstract Waves are propagating disturbances that redistribute energy across space ( 1–4 ). Previous studies ( 5–7 ) have shown that for waves propagating through an inhomogeneously moving mean flow, the conserved quantity is wave action rather than wave energy, raising questions about the validity of energy conservation—one of the foundational principles of physics. In this study, we prove that wave action conservation is, in fact, an apparent form of wave energy conservation in spatially varying and inhomogeneously moving media, where waves undergo deformation during propagation. We further show that wave action conservation can be derived directly from the law of energy conservation. This result holds universally across all isolated wave systems in varying media, including hydrodynamic and non-hydrodynamic waves. Introduction Hydrodynamic waves are propagating disturbances that travel through the continuous adjustment of unbalanced states between neighboring elements. This process involves the transformation between kinetic and potential energy( 8 ). Kinetic energy is typically associated with the inertial properties of the wave system, while potential energy corresponds to the elastic properties that characterize the medium. In this context, a medium is not merely material but also encompasses the dynamic properties it possesses, which define its behavior and interaction with the propagating waves. For hydrodynamic waves, it is generally believed that the governing conservation law is that of wave action rather than wave energy. The concept of wave action conservation was first derived approximately sixty years ago by Whitham ( 5 ), who applied the variational principle to a set of Boussinesq equations. Whitham demonstrated that the ratio of the local wave energy density to the wave frequency, which he referred to as the ”adiabatic invariant,” remains constant even though the energy density itself varies during wave propagation. Subsequently, Whitham’s work was expanded upon ( 6, 8 ). The ”adiabatic invariant” was later renamed ”wave action” ( 8 ) to align with Lagrange’s definition of action ( 10 ). Wave action conservation can also be derived using the WKB approximation and the stress-energy tensor ( 7, 11 ). However, a fundamental question remains: why does the energy itself not remain conserved during wave propagation? The energy conservation has been a cornerstone of physics for nearly two centuries, serving as one of its foundational principles. Any evidence suggesting the non-conservation of energy in an isolated physical system would challenge this fundamental principle, indicating potential flaws in the current framework of physics. Such claims must be rigorously examined and reconciled to maintain the coherence of the scientific understanding of natural laws. Efforts to reconcile wave action conservation with energy conservation have accompanied studies of the wave action law since its inception. Bretherton and Garrett ( 6 ) devoted a substantial section to discussing why wave energy is not conserved, emphasizing the potential for energy exchange between waves and the medium. They highlighted the challenge of separating the varying mean flow from the waves superimposed on it and minimizing their interaction—particularly for hydrodynamic waves in an inhomogeneously moving medium. The idea that wave energy can be exchanged with the medium through processes such as reflection, scattering, refraction, and absorption in a varying environment has been widely accepted to reconcile wave energy conservation in various systems, including sound waves ( 12 ), plasma waves ( 13 ), and seismic waves ( 14 ). However, a more fundamental confirmation of energy conservation across all wave systems would be a derivation that begins with the energy conservation law and leads directly to wave action conservation—without invoking any exchange of energy between the wave and its medium. This study seeks to address the reconciliation challenge precisely in the manner proposed above. We consider the general case of waves in a varying medium, treating the case of an inhomogeneously moving medium as a special case. We show that the apparent wave action conservation is, in fact, a manifestation of the underlying energy conservation law. This reconciliation unifies the governing conservation principles for wave propagation across diverse systems, providing a consistent framework that reaffirms the fundamental role of energy conservation in physics. Since the entire proof does not require any specific type of wave, energy conservation remains valid not only for hydrodynamic waves but also for non-hydrodynamic waves, such as electromagnetic waves propagating in a varying medium. From Wave Action Conservation to Wave Energy Conservation The process of reconciliation is schematically illustrated in Fig. 1. It consists of two parts: (1) transforming the traditional wave action, which is a mathematically derived quantity for the special case of an inhomogeneously moving constant medium, into a more general form with clearer physical meaning that applies to any continuously varying medium; and (2) deriving the general form of wave action conservation from a general waveform and the energy conservation law. The detailed mathematical proof can be found in the Supplementary Material. In the following, we discuss the key steps and their physical interpretations. Figure 1: A schematic diagram illustrating the reconciliation between wave energy and wave action conservation. The background of the figure represents a varying continuous medium, with the horizontal axis representing space and the vertical axis representing time, and a wave packet propagating in the medium. The darker-colored region (on the right-hand-side) corresponds to a medium with a slower wave packet propagation speed. Two key concepts are involved in the derivation of wave action conservation: the wave packet, which is a spatially localized bundle of waves, and ray theory, which focuses on the propagation path of a wave packet. In most previously considered cases, it is assumed that the packet contains little spread of frequency, making it almost non-dispersive. Although a dispersive case can also be considered, in such a case, the packet’s coherence will not be preserved. In this case, the wave packet can be expressed as A(x,t)e^{i\theta(x,t)} , where A(x,t) is the amplitude of the wave bundle and and its square is the wave energy density. \theta(x,t) is the phase function, whose (negative) temporal change rate gives locally observed frequency \omega and spatial change rate gives wavenumber k . For simplicity, here we first consider a one spatial dimensional case. When the packet propagates in an inhomogeneously moving constant medium, the intrinsic frequency, \omega_{i} , which is the wave frequency measured by an observer moving at the local speed of the medium, also needs to be considered. These two frequencies are related by the Doppler shift caused by the medium’s movement, i.e., \omega(x)=\omega_{i}(x)+U(x)k(x) , where U(x) is the spatially varying medium moving speed. The wave action density is defined as A^{2}/\omega_{i} and its conservation is expressed as \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\left(\frac{A^{2}}{\omega_{i}}\right)+c_{g}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left(\frac{A^{2}}{\omega_{i}}\right)+\frac{A^{2}}{\omega_{i}}\cdot\frac{\partial c_{g}}{\partial x}=0. (1) Equation (1) has the same form as the continuity equation for mass in fluid dynamics when the wave action density is replaced by mass density and packet propagation velocity, c_{g} , replaced by the mass moving speed. This is not surprise since the density of any conservation quantity should satisfy the same expression. Our first step (Supplementary Material Section S.2) toward reconciliation is to prove that the locally observed frequency, \omega , at any spatial location, x , remains constant for

Read the complete text