Ethical Challenges of Using Artificial Intelligence in Judiciary

Angel Mary John, Aiswarya M. U, Jerrin Thomas Panachakel · 2025

Read Ethical Challenges of Using Artificial Intelligence in Judiciary by Angel Mary John, Aiswarya M. U, Jerrin Thomas Panachakel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-19284.txt.

Introduction

Angel Mary John, Aiswarya M. U., and Jerrin Thomas Panachakel survey the ethical problems that come with using artificial intelligence in courts. Their 2025 article grants the upside first: AI can speed document review, legal research, and case prediction, cutting cost and delay for the public. Courts around the world have begun to adopt such tools for routine work.

The authors then set out the main moral risks that must be faced before these systems spread further. Biased data, unclear reasoning, and blurred accountability can all distort justice if judges lean on machine output without care. The piece maps the key challenges so that legal systems can take the gains while keeping fairness and trust intact.

Catalog record

CREATORAngel Mary John, Aiswarya M. U, Jerrin Thomas Panachakel
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-19284

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ethical Challenges of Using Artificial Intelligence in Judiciary Angel Mary John, Aiswarya M. U, Jerrin Thomas Panachakel Abstract Artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as a ubiquitous concept in numerous domains, including the legal system. AI has the potential to revolutionize the functioning of the judiciary and the dispensation of justice. Incorporating AI into the legal system offers the prospect of enhancing decision-making for judges, lawyers, and legal professionals, while concurrently providing the public with more streamlined, efficient, and cost-effective services. The integration of AI into the legal landscape offers manifold benefits, encompassing tasks such as document review, legal research, contract analysis, case prediction, and decision-making. By automating laborious and error-prone procedures, AI has the capacity to alleviate the burden associated with these arduous tasks. Consequently, courts around the world have begun embracing AI technology as a means to enhance the administration of justice. However, alongside its potential advantages, the use of AI in the judiciary poses a range of ethical challenges. These ethical quandaries must be duly addressed to ensure the responsible and equitable deployment of AI systems. This article delineates the principal ethical challenges entailed in employing AI within the judiciary and provides recommendations to effectively address these issues. I Introduction The field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has a long and rich history, and there have been many different AI systems developed over the years. The earliest AI systems were developed in the 1950s and 1960s, and they were focused primarily on performing tasks that would normally require human intelligence, such as problem-solving, reasoning, and language processing. One of the earliest and most well-known AI systems is the Logic Theorist, which was developed by Allen Newell and Simon Herbert in 1956 [ 2 ] . The Logic Theorist was a computer program designed to prove mathematical theorems using symbolic logic. Another early AI system was the General Problem Solver (GPS), developed by Newell et al. in 1957, which could solve a wide range of problems by searching through a set of possible solutions [ 3 ] . Other early AI systems included the perceptron, developed by McCulloch and Pitts in 1943, which was a type of neural network that could learn to recognize patterns [ 4 ] ; and ELIZA, developed by Joseph Weizenbaum in 1966, which was a natural language processing system that could simulate a conversation between a human and a computer [ 5 ] . Since then, the field of AI has continued to develop rapidly, with many new and innovative AI systems being developed each year. An important aspect of AI systems, which is often overlooked is the ethics or moral philosophy of AI systems. Ethics deals with moral principles regarding what is morally good & bad and right & wrong [ 6 ] . This article discusses the ethical aspects of using AI in judiciary. II Major AI Systems in Judiciary Similar to other domains such natural language processing (NLP) [ 7 ] , computer vision (CV) [ 8 ] , public health [ 9 ] , biomedical engineering [ 10 , 11 ] and finance [ 12 ] , the domain of judiciary has witnessed the influence of AI in various sub-domains. The major AI systems used in the judiciaries across the globe are: • Giustizia Predittiva: Giustizia Predittiva is an AI-powered platform developed by the Italian Ministry of Justice. It can be used to predict the outcome of a case based on analysis of past cases and legal precedents. • LITI: LITI is an AI-powered legal research tool developed by the Italian Bar Association. It can be used to search legal databases, analyze legal documents, and provide insights into legal issues. • eCourts Services: This is an integrated case management system that is being used by various courts across India. It provides a range of services, including online case filing, case status tracking, and document management. • Case Information and Management System (CIMS): CIMS is an AI-powered case management system that is being used by the Supreme Court of India and several High Courts in India. It helps in the automation of case management processes, including case filing, document management, and case tracking. • Integrated Decision Support System (IDSS): IDSS is an AI-powered system that provides judges with relevant legal information, including case laws and precedents, to help them make informed decisions. It is being used in the High Courts of Delhi, Punjab and Haryana, and Bombay in India. • Artificial Intelligence Legal Information Analysis System (AILIAS): AILIAS is an AI-powered legal research tool that is being used by the Delhi High Court in India. It uses NLP and machine learning algorithms to analyze and summarize legal documents. • SUPACE: The Supreme Court Portal for Assistance in Courts Efficiency (SUPACE) is an AI-powered platform developed by the Supreme Court of India to improve the efficiency of court proceedings. The platform uses advanced analytics and machine learning algorithms to provide judges with relevant legal information and assist them in decision-making. • SUVAS: The Supreme Court Vidhik Anuvaad Software (SUVAS) is an AI-powered translation software developed by the Supreme Court of India to assist judges and lawyers in translating legal documents from English to regional languages and vice versa. The software uses advanced machine learning algorithms and natural language processing (NLP) techniques to provide accurate and efficient translations. • COMPAS (Correctional Offender Management Profiling for Alternative Sanctions) is a risk assessment tool used by some courts in the USA to evaluate a defendant’s likelihood of reoffending and make recommendations for bail or sentencing. The system uses a combination of data analysis and machine learning algorithms to generate a risk score for each defendant based on various factors, such as criminal history, age, and employment status. III Ethical Challenges of using AI in Judiciary There principle ethical challenges in using AI in judiciary, which are: 1. Bias and fairness 2. Transparency and accountability 3. Privacy and data protection 4. Speech imagery-based BCI systems III-A Bias and Fairness AI systems are primarily dependent on the data they are trained on. Therefore any biases in the criminal justice system in the data will be reflected in the trained model. This can lead to unfair or discriminatory outcomes for certain groups, such as minorities, and raise concerns around due process and equal protection under the law. Comparing the bias of an AI system to human psychology, the bias can be termed as an implicit bias where both the AI system and its developers are unaware of the bias [ 13 , 14 ] . Due to the lack of the awareness of the bias, the developers do not fine tune the AI model to mitigate this bias. For instance, consider an AI system trained to assist in law enforcement professionals in drug-related incidents. Since currently disproportionately large number of people of colour are prosecuted in drug-related cases [ 14 , 15 ] , an AI system trained on this data will also exhibit a racial bias similar to the implicit racial bias in humans [ 13 , 16 ] . That is, the system is not explicitly trained to exhibit this bias but the data the system has seen during the training phase has made system to exhibit

Read the complete text