AI Recommendations and Non-instrumental Image Concerns

David Almog · 2025

Read AI Recommendations and Non-instrumental Image Concerns by David Almog (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-19047.txt.

Introduction

David Almog wrote this economics paper, published in 2025. It uses an online experiment to show why people ignore good advice from AI: they worry about how taking the advice makes them look, even when looking bad costs them nothing.

Hopes for human and AI teamwork rest on each side playing to its strengths. In practice, people often underuse AI tips. Almog shows that image concerns, cares about others' perceptions with no money attached, push participants to set AI recommendations aside. Performance on the task drops as a result. The finding names a quiet social force behind a common puzzle in workplaces and products. It suggests that making AI use look normal, rather than just making AI better, may be needed for people to accept its help.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Almog
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-19047

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI Recommendations and Non-instrumental Image Concerns Thanks: I am especially grateful to Yuval Salant, Jörg Spenkuch, Alex Imas, Daniel Martin, Alvaro Sandroni, Benjamin Golub, and Tali Dayan for their continuous support. I also thank Effi Benmelech, Joshua Dean, Uri Gneezy, Anders Humlum, Rafael Jiménez-Durán, Annie Liang, Ryan Oprea, Devin Pope, and Avner Strulov-Shlain, as well as the audiences at the Booth Behavioral Economics Lab and the Kellogg Strategy Brown Bag Seminar, for their helpful comments. The experiment was pre-registered on aspredicted.org (#220425). The IRB ID at Northwestern University for the experiment is STU00222514. David Almog Abstract There is growing enthusiasm about the potential for humans and AI to collaborate by leveraging their respective strengths. Yet in practice, this promise often falls short. This paper uses an online experiment to identify non-instrumental image concerns as a key reason individuals underutilize AI recommendations. I show that concerns about how one is perceived, even when those perceptions carry no monetary consequences, lead participants to disregard AI advice and reduce task performance. 1 Introduction We are witnessing a surge in the use of artificial intelligence (AI) systems across various work environments, a trend likely to intensify in the coming years. As algorithmic predictive capabilities advance and digitization and data collection efforts expand, new opportunities are emerging to observe how professionals make decisions with the assistance of these tools. Machine learning algorithms are eclipsing experts in many areas, including bail judges predicting pretrial misconduct ( Kleinberg et al. 2018 ) , radiologists predicting pneumonia from chest X-rays ( Rajpurkar et al. 2017 ; Topol 2019 ) , and workforce professionals predicting productivity for hiring and promotion ( Chalfin et al. 2016 ) . While AI has the potential to outperform many human professionals, there is hope that human-AI collaboration can yield even better results by leveraging the unique strengths of each. AI excels at processing large volumes of data and remains free from emotional biases, while humans may possess private information or be better equipped to handle edge cases. One of the most popular decision-making frameworks involves humans making choices based on AI recommendations, a structure that preserves decision-making authority in human hands. However, making decisions in environments with algorithmic recommendations requires humans to exercise discretion—an area that research shows can be particularly challenging. For instance, Hoffman et al. (2018) highlights the difficulties in exercising discretion within hiring contexts, where managers often overrule algorithmic recommendations based on personal biases rather than legitimate private information. Similarly, Agarwal et al. (2023) finds that providing radiologists with access to AI predictions does not, on average, improve performance, primarily due to factors such as overconfidence and correlation neglect. In a recent study of a pretrial bail court, Angelova et al. (2024) report that 90% of judges perform worse than an algorithm when they override its recommendations. The implication is striking: nearly every judge in that setting could improve decision quality by always following the algorithmic advice. So why don’t they? The answer may lie not in a lack of information or incentives, but in deeper psychological forces that shape how people engage with algorithmic tools. In this paper I explore a new mechanism that contributes to the explanation on why human-AI collaboration, particularly in AI recommendation systems, often falls short of expectations. This paper focuses on studying the impact of non-instrumental image concerns (also referred to as hedonic motives by Bursztyn and Jensen (2017) ) on AI utilization rates. Are workers worried about how others perceive them when they use AI? If so, image concerns may discourage workers from making decisions based solely on accuracy. For instance, a worker who consistently follows AI recommendations may be perceived as exerting low effort or contributing little value ( Weitzner 2024 ) , while one who rarely follows them may appear resistant to technological adaptation. These examples illustrate that image concerns could plausibly push AI utilization in either direction. However, recent evidence suggests that social norms are beginning to emerge against the use of AI. For example, Ling and Imas (2025) find that social desirability bias leads people to under-report their AI usage. Similarly, Awuah et al. (2025) show that human evaluators tend to penalize LLM-generated job applications, even though this is not formally specified as an evaluation criterion. While image concerns may affect payoffs either directly or indirectly, my focus here is to show that they can also reflect psychological forces that operate independently of monetary incentives. I conducted an online experiment in Prolific where participants completed a 50-round image classification task with assistance from AI recommendations. Incentives were tied solely to performance: one round was randomly selected for payment, and participants earned a bonus if their final answer for that round was correct. At the end of the study, all participants were required to join a brief video call with a member of the research team to learn whether they had earned the bonus. For those randomly assigned to the treatment group, the video call also included a short review of the participant’s AI usage, comparing it to the average behavior of others. This intervention was designed to trigger image concerns without introducing reputational or monetary consequences. While such concerns may be even stronger in real-world settings—where people care more deeply about how they are perceived by peers, supervisors, or close collaborators—cleanly isolating non-instrumental image concerns in the field is methodologically challenging. The controlled online experimental setting used here allowed me to shut down instrumental channels and induce a relatively modest image concern shock. Nonetheless, the effect was meaningful: participants in the treatment group relied significantly less on AI and performed worse, despite being incentivized solely on accuracy. Specifically, AI usage dropped by 4.5 percentage points (10%), and accuracy declined by 2.7 percentage points (3.3%). These findings underscore how subtle psychological forces, such as concern about how one’s choices are perceived by a recently met individual, can distort decision making, even at the cost of task success. One of the most important questions in the AI adoption discourse is who stands to benefit—and who may be left behind. With this in mind, the paper examines whether the image concerns studied here affect specific segments of the population differently. The heterogeneity analysis reveals that minority participants are significantly more affected by image-related pressures, exhibiting stronger treatment effects in the form of lower AI adoption and reduced performance relative to white participants. Before concluding the study, participants were asked to report their level of discomfort regarding the upcoming video call. The results support the presence of psychological forces: participants in the treatment group were 55 percent more likely to report feeling uncomfortable about the call. They also expressed lower satisfaction with how effectively they used the AI recommendations during the task, which is consistent with the idea that their choices were shaped by additional constraints related to image concerns. There are two main reasons to believe the findings from this online experiment could generalize horizontally across a range of field settings. First, the study captures participants’ responses to being observed by someone from the research team they had just met. In most real-world work environments, however, image concerns are shaped by interactions with colleagues, clients, or other stakeholders with whom individuals have

Read the complete text