A lower bound of the energy functional of a class of vector fields and a characterization of the sphere
Giovanni Nunes, Jaime Ripoll · 2025
Read A lower bound of the energy functional of a class of vector fields and a characterization of the sphere by Giovanni Nunes, Jaime Ripoll (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18975.txt.
Introduction
Giovanni Nunes and Jaime Ripoll proved a lower bound for the energy of a class of flow fields on curved spaces, in a mathematics note published in 2025. Their energy weighs a field's rate of change against its size. The spaces in play are compact, two-sided, and bear a symmetry group that sweeps them in one fold. Each fixed point set of the group is rich, with no still tangent directions except zero.
Under a lower bound on the curvature of the space, they show the energy cannot fall below a set bound. The bound is reached just when the space is a round sphere of set curvature. There, the field also sits at the floor of the energy. The note gives a sharp test: one field's energy can identify the sphere.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giovanni Nunes, Jaime Ripoll |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 17 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18975
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A lower bound of the energy functional of a class of vector fields and a characterization of the sphere Giovanni Nunes, Jaime Ripoll Abstract Let M M be a compact, orientable, n − n- dimensional Riemannian manifold, n ≥ 2 , n\geq 2, and let F F be the energy functional acting on the space Ξ ( M ) \Xi(M) of C ∞ C^{\infty} vector fiels of M M , F ( X ) := ∫ M | ‖ ∇ X ‖ 2 𝑑 M ∫ M ‖ | X ‖ 2 d M , X ∈ Ξ ( M ) \ { 0 } . F(X):=\frac{\int_{M}|\left\|\nabla X\right\|^{2}dM}{\int_{M}\left\||X\right\|^{2}dM},\text{ }X\in\Xi(M)\backslash\{0\}. Let G ⊂ Iso ( M ) G\subset\operatorname*{Iso}(M) be a compact Lie subgroup of the isometry group of M M acting with cohomogeneity 1 1 on M . M. Assume that any isotropy subgroup of G G is non trivial and acts with no fixed points on the tangent spaces of M M , except at the null vectors. We prove in this note that under these hypothesis, if the Ricci curvature Ric M \operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M} of M M has the lower bound Ric M ≥ ( n − 1 ) k 2 , \operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M}\geq\left(n-1\right)k^{2}, then F ( X ) ≥ k 2 , F(X)\geq k^{2}, for any G − G- invariant vector field X ∈ Ξ ( M ) \ { 0 } X\in\Xi(M)\backslash\{0\} , and the equality occurs if and only if M M is isometric to the n − n- dimensional sphere 𝕊 k n \mathbb{S}_{k}^{n} of constant sectional curvature k 2 k^{2} . In this case X X is an infimum of F F on Ξ ( 𝕊 k n ) . \Xi(\mathbb{S}_{k}^{n}). 1 Introduction Given a compact, orientable, n- dimensional Riemannian manifold M, n\geq 2, the energy functional F of vector fields of M is defined by F(X):=\frac{\int_{M}\left\|\nabla X\right\|^{2}dM}{\int_{M}\left\|X\right\|^{2}dM},\text{ }X\in\Xi(M)\backslash\{0\}, where \nabla is the Riemannian connection of M and \Xi(M) the space of C^{\infty} vector fields of M. It is well known that the critical values of F are the eingenvalues of the so called rough Laplacian -\operatorname*{div}\nabla of M and form a discrete sequence 0\leq\lambda_{0}<\lambda_{1}<...\rightarrow\infty. In [ 3 ] it is proved that if M is the Euclidean sphere \mathbb{S}_{k}^{n} of constant sectional curvature k^{2}, n\geq 2, then the infimum of F is assumed by a vector field X, orthogonal to the orbits of a compact Lie subgroup of the isometry group of \mathbb{S}_{k}^{n}, acting with cohomogeneity 1 in \mathbb{S}_{k}^{n} and having a fixed point (the orthogonal subgroup \operatorname*{O}(n-1) of \operatorname*{O}(n) fixing a point of \mathbb{S}_{k}^{n}). Moreover, X is G- invariant. We investigate here a possible extension of this result to a Riemannian manifold and arrived to a theorem which gives a characterization of the spheres as the only minimizers for F on a certain space of vector fields: Theorem 1 Let M be a compact, orientable, n- dimensional Riemannian manifold, n\geq 2, and G\subset\operatorname*{Iso}(M) a compact Lie subgroup of the isometry group of M acting with cohomogeneity 1 on M. Assume that any isotropy subgroup of G is non trivial and acts with no fixed points on the tangent spaces of M , except at the null vectors. If the Ricci curvature \operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M} of M has the lower bound \operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M}\geq\left(n-1\right)k^{2}, then F(X)\geq k^{2}, for any G- invariant vector field X\in\Xi(M) , and the equality occurs if and only if M is isometric to the n- dimensional sphere \mathbb{S}_{k}^{n} of constant sectional curvature k^{2} . In this case X is an infimum of F on \Xi(\mathbb{S}_{k}^{n}). We observe that rank 1 compact symmetric spaces admit a compact Lie group of isometries satisfying the conditions of Theorem 1 . More generally, any G- symmetric compact Riemannian manifold, where G is the isotropy subgroup of a compact rank 1 symmetric space 1 1 1 The definition of a G- invariant Riemannian manifold is a natural and direct generalization of a rotationally symmetric manifold as defined in ( [ 1 ] , definition 3.1) ( G is isomorphic to one of the groups: \operatorname*{O}(n), \operatorname*{U}(n)\times\operatorname*{U}(1), \operatorname*{Sp}(n)\times\operatorname*{Sp}(1), \operatorname*{Spin}(9)). In particular, rotationally symmetric compact Riemannian manifolds ( G is isomorphic to \operatorname*{O}(n) ). One should also mention other non trivial examples of compact cohomogeneity one actions. They are given by certain submanifolds of \mathbb{R}^{n} using a construction introduced in [ 2 ] , as follows: Let G be a compact Lie subgroup of the isometry group of \mathbb{R}^{n}, n\geq 3, acting with cohomogeneity k\geq 2, that is, the principal orbits of G are submanifolds of \mathbb{R}^{n} with codimension k. It is known that there is an open dense subset \left(\mathbb{R}^{n}/G\right)^{\ast} of the quotient space \mathbb{R}^{n}/G, with the quotient topology, which is a smooth manifold of dimension k (see the Theorem of Section 2 of [ 2 ] ). If \gamma is a closed curve in \left(\mathbb{R}^{n}/G\right)^{\ast} and \pi:\mathbb{R}^{n}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}^{n}/G the quotient projection, then M:=\pi^{-1}\left(\gamma\right) is a compact G- invariant manifold of dimension n-k+1. Clearly, G acts with cohomogeneity 1 in M. The compact subgroups of \operatorname*{Iso}\left(\mathbb{R}^{n}\right) acting with cohomogeneity 2 and 3 are classified in Theorems 5, 6 and 7 of [ 2 ] and explicit examples can be constructed using the representations of these groups given in these theorems. 2 Preliminary and prior results In this section we quote some Theorems of [ 3 ] and prove other results which we will be used in the proof of Theorem 1 . Theorem 2 Let M be a compact n- dimensional Riemannian manifold, n\geq 2, and G\subset\operatorname*{Iso}(M) a compact Lie subgroup of the isometry group of M . Then the set S_{G} of critical points of F restricted to the subspace of G- invariant vector fields of \Xi\left(M\right) is contained in the set of critical points of F on \Xi\left(M\right) . Theorem 3 Let \mathbb{S}_{k}\subset\mathbb{R}^{n+1}, k>0, n\geq 2, be the n- dimensional sphere of constant sectional curvature k^{2}. Then the infimum of F on \Xi\left(\mathbb{S}_{k}\right) is k^{2} and is assumed by the orthogonal projection on T\mathbb{S}_{k} of a constant nonzero vector field of \mathbb{R}^{n+1} . These two theorems above are proved, respectively, in Theorem 3, Section 3 and Theorem 1, Section 2 of [ 3 ] . We also need the following results: Lemma 4 Let M be a compact n- dimensional Riemannian manifold, n\geq 2. If V\in\Xi(M)\backslash\{0\} is a gradient vector field , then F\left(V\right)\geq\frac{1}{n-1}\int_{M}\operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M}\left(V,V\right)dM. Proof. Assume that V=\operatorname{grad}h, h\in C^{\infty}\left(M\right)\backslash\{0\}. From Bochner’s formula, \displaystyle\int_{M}\left(\Delta h\right)^{2}dM \displaystyle=\int_{M}\operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M}\left(\operatorname*{grad}h,\operatorname*{grad}h\right)dM+\int_{M}\left|\operatorname*{Hess}\left(h\right)\right|^{2}dM \displaystyle=\int_{M}\operatorname*{Ric}\nolimits_{M}\left(V,V\right)dM+\int_{M}\left|\operatorname*{Hess}\left(h\right)\right|^{2}dM. The proof then follows by using the inequality \left(\Delta h\right)^{2}\leq n\left|\operatorname*{Hess}\left(h\right)\right|^{2} and observing that \left|\operatorname*{Hess}\left(h\right)\right|=\left\|\nabla V\right\|. Lemma 5 Let M be a compact n- dimensional Riemannian manifold, n\geq 2, and G\subset\operatorname*{Iso}(M) a compact Lie subgroup of the isometry group of M acting with cohomogeneity 1 on M. If V\in\Xi(M) is a G -invariant vector field orthogonal to the orbits of G then V is the gradient of a C^{\infty} function in M . Proof. From the Theorem, Section 2 of [ 2 ] , there is an open dense submanifold M^{\ast} of M such that any orbit of G through a point of M^{\ast} is contained in M^{\ast} , has dimension n-1 and, hence, divides M into two connected components. Let O\subset M^{\ast} be an orbit of