Generative to Agentic AI: Survey, Conceptualization, and Challenges

Johannes Schneider · 2025

Read Generative to Agentic AI: Survey, Conceptualization, and Challenges by Johannes Schneider (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18875.txt.

Introduction

Johannes Schneider surveys in a 2025 paper how generative AI is growing into agentic AI. The newer form adds stronger thought, learning, and contact with the world, so it can act on its own for long tasks. Since ChatGPT spread, many people know the older form, but the line between the two stays fuzzy.

The first half contrasts the two forms using past work and traces the steps from one to the next. It also splits early agent systems from a newer kind that improves itself as it runs. The second half goes deep on new traits and hard parts, such as what counts as an agent. Schneider closes with open problems that could guide the next wave of research.

Catalog record

CREATORJohannes Schneider
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE106 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18875

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Generative to Agentic AI: Survey, Conceptualization, and Challenges Johannes Schneider Abstract Agentic AI builds upon Generative AI (GenAI). It constitutes the next major step in the evolution of AI with much stronger reasoning, learning, and interaction capabilities that enable more autonomous behavior to tackle complex, long-running tasks. Since the initial release of ChatGPT 3.5, Generative AI has seen widespread adoption, giving users firsthand experience. However, the distinction between Agentic AI and GenAI remains less well understood. To address this gap, our survey is structured in two parts. In the first part, we compare GenAI and Agentic AI using existing literature, discussing their key characteristics, how Agentic AI remedies limitations of GenAI, and the major steps in GenAI’s evolution toward Agentic AI. We also distinguish between early Agentic AI aiming at reasoning and interacting and the increasingly emerging paradigm of self-improving Agentic AI that operates continuously and learns from its experiences by updating itself. This section is intended for a broad audience, including academics in both social sciences and engineering, as well as industry professionals. It provides the necessary insights to comprehend novel applications that are possible with Agentic AI but not with GenAI. In the second part, we deep dive into novel aspects of Agentic AI, including recent developments and practical concerns such as defining agents. Finally, we discuss several challenges that could serve as a future research agenda, while cautioning against risks that can emerge when exceeding human intelligence. keywords Agentic AI, Generative AI, Conceptualization, Survey 1 Introduction Agentic AI constitutes a paradigm shift in artificial intelligence , enabling systems to act independently, pursue broad objectives rather than isolated decisions, and carry out complex tasks that require reasoning elements such as planning and reflection. Agents can act proactively rather than just reactively. While Agentic AI builds on earlier seeds of shallow reasoning and interaction already observed in early GenAI systems, it extends and structures these capabilities profoundly. Agents (i) interact with environments and tools, and (ii) perform deep reasoning, which manifests as multi-step, problem-dependent computation with planning and reflection, and increasingly (iii) agents learn from collected experiences to better understand their environment and improve on (recurring) tasks. For example, reasoning models such as ChatGPT o3 or ChatGPT 6 Astra in “Pro” mode can spend minutes to hours processing user and self-generated prompts as part of a search and planning process, whereas earlier GenAI models like ChatGPT 3.5 (released in 2022) typically provided instantaneous responses, as shown in Figure 1 . Increasingly, harnesses steering AI models trigger processes to store, distill, and retrieve experiences, allowing agents to learn during long-running tasks as observed for coding and personal agent (harnesses) operating 24/7 Liu et al. (2026) ; OpenClaw () . Figure 1: Reasoning models perform extensive problem-dependent computations, commonly employing problem analysis, planning and reflection, while non-reasoning is shown by immediate responses without intermediate steps. Beyond limited reasoning capabilities, tasks handled by GenAI are typically structured to be solved directly using the available information—that is, by generating an output from the input without engaging with the environment or external tools. In contrast, Agentic AI systems integrate elements of reinforcement learning: Agents interact with environments using tools through a sequence of actions, making observations and receiving feedback that informs and guides future actions via learning. Figure 2: On the ARC challenge ( Chollet, 2019 ) , Agentic AI with growing reasoning effort involving planning and reflection dramatically outperform. This new wave of AI fosters novel opportunities and challenges , making it crucial to understand and conceptualize differences clearly. Defining and using an autonomous agent is more challenging and riskier, as agents have a greater direct real-world impact: they can directly alter the environment by taking actions and solve tasks with less-detailed instructions, leading to more diverse, unpredictable, and harder-to-control solutions. Their dangers have been demonstrated by multiple unintendet hacker attacks, e.g., on HuggingFace by OpenAI’s flagship model OpenAI (2026) . Moreover, capabilities such as memory use, tool selection, and open-ended exploration amplify both the potential benefits and risks compared to GenAI. On the positive side, AI agents, like GenAI, can be used with plain, everyday language instead of complex programming languages, boosting ease of adoption. On the negative side, properly specifying an agent to account for various eventualities is more demanding than crafting a prompt for a narrower task. While some experts already warned against the threats of GenAI ( Vincent, 2023 ) , many researchers deemed those threats as overstated ( Nolan, 2024 ) . This is not a surprise, as GenAI models struggled to solve tasks that were easy for laypeople. For instance, in the ARC challenge ( cla18 ) —which consists of tasks considered simple for ordinary people—early GenAI models such as GPT 4o achieved below 10%. However, reasoning models that are part of Agentic AI show striking improvements , as illustrated in Figure 2 . In other areas, such as programming ( El-Kishky et al., 2025 ) and generating coherent and accurate radiology reports, Agentic AI with reasoning capabilities also outperform other models ( Zhong et al., 2024 ) . These outcomes also suggest that Agentic AI represents a major step toward artificial general intelligence (AGI), where AI is not confined to a narrow domain but can generalize to new situations. However, scaling compute at test-time alone (a key aspect of “deep” reasoning) may not guarantee progress toward AGI, and important challenges remain, including training data limitations and error accumulation. Thus, the debate on the risks and opportunities of AI should intensify again, requiring a renewed and cautious assessment. Understanding the differences between the two is important for businesses to choose the right technology to save time and reduce costs, and for society and policymakers to engage in a meaningful ethical and social debate surrounding the technology ( Marr, 2025 ) . However, the situation becomes more intricate as Agentic AI is not a magic bullet for all problems. In particular, it does not offer dramatic improvements over GenAI in all areas. This makes it challenging to assess which problems benefit from clear-cut gains that enable novel applications. Like GenAI, Agentic AI can make mistakes on relatively simple problems ( Zhong et al., 2024 ) . Social intelligence is not necessarily higher in models performing deep reasoning ( Hou et al., 2024 ) , although differences may emerge in tasks requiring the anticipation of behavioral strategies, such as those found in games. Only minor improvements using Agentic AI have been observed on translation tasks ( Chen et al., 2025a ) . On the well-known MMLU benchmark—consisting of multiple-choice questions spanning factual and procedural knowledge from various domains—reasoning models show only a slight edge, as illustrated in Figure 4 , and at the cost of significantly more computation. Many of these questions are considered “hard” in the sense that they require PhD level knowledge in specific domains. Likely, there are a number of analogous questions to those in the benchmark in the model’s training data – in the most extreme case even the questions and answers themselves. Thus, the questions may be easier to answer through association rather than genuine reasoning. Generally, fine-tuning GenAI models for specific domains may outperform Agentic AI counterparts that lack domain-specific knowledge, while also

Read the complete text