Magnetic Dipole Trapping Potential between Infinite Superconducting Plates

Francis J. Headley · 2025

Read Magnetic Dipole Trapping Potential between Infinite Superconducting Plates by Francis J. Headley (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18852.txt.

Introduction

Francis Headley works out the exact pull on a small magnet floating between two endless superconducting plates in a 2025 note. Mirror copies of the magnet, reflected in each plate, stand in for the plates own screening currents. Summing those copies gives a closed-form formula for the trapping force at any spot between the plates. The result serves as a yardstick for computer simulations of magnetic levitation and as groundwork for stability studies in precision measurement setups.

Catalog record

CREATORFrancis J. Headley
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18852

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Magnetic Dipole Trapping Potential between Infinite Superconducting Plates Francis J. Headley Abstract We derive the exact analytic form of the potential experienced by a magnetic dipole trapped between two infinite parallel superconducting plates using the method of image dipoles, providing a benchmark for numerical methods and a foundation for studying the stability and dynamics of magnetically levitated systems in precision measurements and fundamental physics experiments. I Introduction The image charge method has long been used to solve boundary problems in electrostatics, particularly those concerning conductors and dielectrics Jackson1998 . More recently the image charge method has been used to approximate the potential of macroscopic magnets levitated in superconducting traps lin_theoretical_2006 ; vinante_levitated_2022 . These levitated systems boast high quality factors vinante_ultralow_2020 ; fuchs_magnetic_2023 and force sensitivity, being currently at the forefront of technological applications and the exploration of fundamental physics problems such as probing the quantum nature of weak forces such as gravity fuchs_magnetic_2023 ; prat-camps_ultrasensitive_2017 ; gonzalez-ballestero_levitodynamics_2021 ; bose_massive_2023 as well as its current use in the search for dark matter Amaral:2024rbj ; carney2020 . For levitated systems in general, finding the potential for a trapped magnetic dipole is often done numerically, utilising finite element methods to solve the field equations, however in some special cases it is possible to obtain analytical solutions vinante_levitated_2022 ; lin_theoretical_2006 . For macroscopic superconductors the London penetration depth can be assumed to be negligibly small and as such the superconductors can be assumed to be in an ideal Meissner state, a perfect diamagnet Tinkham1996 . With this assumption, it is possible to obtain an analytic form of the potential of a dipole levitated above an infinite superconducting plate without ever having to solve the field equations lin_theoretical_2006 ; vinante_levitated_2022 . The purpose of this letter is to present an analytic form of the potential generated by a dipole trapped between two superconducting plates, which should serve as a good approximation of the trapping potential observed in real world experiments in fundamental physics, and furthermore provide a benchmark for numerical approximations of dipole potentials in more complicated geometries. We first present the derivation of the potential for a single dipole in the presence of one infinite superconducting plate. This solution is already present in the literature vinante_levitated_2022 , however the calculations serve as instruction for the derivation of the potential between two plates, which is presented directly after. These results are then compared with the Finite Element Method, which is a commonly used numerical technique for solving PDE’s with different boundary conditions. II Dipole above an infinite superconducting plane To begin, consider a magnetic dipole in the presence of an infinite superconducting plate. As the superconductor can be treated as a perfect diamagnet, the magnetic induction inside of the plate is zero. Thus, we only need to consider the magnetic field outside of the plate. There is no free electric current outside of the plate, therefore we can introduce the magnetic scalar potential \Phi_{\text{I}} such that the total magnetic field is \mathbf{B}=-\mu_{0}\nabla(\Phi_{0}+\Phi_{\text{I}}) where \Phi_{0} is the scalar potential of the magnetic dipole and \Phi_{\text{I}} is the scalar potential generated by the induced currents on the surface of the superconductor. Noting that we have rotational symmetry of the scalar potential, we work in cylindrical coordinates (\rho,\phi,z) . In this case, we may set the angular component \phi=0 without loss of generality. The scalar potential at a point \bm{r}=(\rho,z) for a dipole \bm{\mu}=\mu(\cos\beta_{0},\sin\beta_{0}) located at \mathbf{r}_{0}=(\rho_{0},z_{0}) is given by \Phi_{0}(\rho,z)=\dfrac{\bm{\mu}\cdot(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{0})}{4\pi|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{0}|^{3}}. (1) Our dipole is situated near an infinite superconducting plate, defined at coordinate z=a . In order to calculate the induced scalar potential \Phi_{\text{I}} , we note that the Meissner effect implies the boundary condition on the induced magnetic field, that is \mathbf{n}\cdot\mathbf{B}|_{z=a}=0 , where \mathbf{n} is the unit vector normal to the surface of the superconductor, which in this case is a unit vector in the z direction. To solve the boundary problem we place an image dipole located at \mathbf{r}_{1}=(z_{1},\rho_{1}) \Phi(\rho,z)=\Phi_{0}(\rho,z)+\Phi_{\text{I}}(\rho,z)=\dfrac{\bm{\mu}\cdot(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{0})}{4\pi|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{0}|^{3}}+\dfrac{\bm{\mu}\cdot(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{1})}{4\pi|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_{1}|^{3}}. (2) Where we write explicitly: \displaystyle\Phi_{0}(\rho,z) \displaystyle=\dfrac{\mu(z-z_{0})\sin\beta_{0}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{0}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+z^{2}+z_{0}^{2}-2zz_{0})^{3/2}}, (3) \displaystyle\Phi_{\text{I}}(\rho,z) \displaystyle=\dfrac{\mu(z-z_{1})\sin\beta_{1}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+z^{2}+z_{1}^{2}-2zz_{1})^{3/2}}. (4) The correct boundary condition requires that the normal component of the magnetic field in the z direction to be zero at the surface of the plate. Taking the derivative with respect to z and evaluating at z=a we find the boundary term: \displaystyle\partial_{z}\Phi|_{z=a}= \displaystyle\dfrac{\mu\sin\beta_{0}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(z_{0}-a)^{2})^{3/2}}+\dfrac{\mu\sin\beta_{1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(z_{1}-a)^{2})^{3/2}} \displaystyle-3(a-z_{0})\left(\dfrac{\mu(a-z_{0})\sin\beta_{0}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{0}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(z_{0}-a)^{2})^{5/2}}\right) \displaystyle-3(a-z_{1})\left(\dfrac{\mu(a-z_{1})\sin\beta_{1}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(z_{1}-a)^{2})^{5/2}}\right). (5) To set the term ( 5 ) to zero, we fix the z -coordinate of the image charge to be z_{1}=2a-z_{0} and its orientation \beta_{1}=-\beta_{0} . This is tantamount to placing an oppositely oriented dipole of equal strength equidistant on the other side of the plate. The scalar potential of the image charge is thus: \Phi_{\text{I}}(\rho,z)=\dfrac{-\mu(z-(2a-z_{0}))\sin\beta_{0}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{0}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+z^{2}+(2a-z_{0})^{2}-2z(2a-z_{0}))^{3/2}}. (6) The potential experienced by the dipole above the plate is calculated using lin_theoretical_2006 : U(z_{0},\beta_{0})=-\frac{1}{2}\bm{\mu}\cdot\mathbf{B}_{\text{I}}, (7) where \mathbf{B}_{\text{I}}=-\mu_{0}\bm{\nabla}\Phi_{\text{I}} . After some simple calculation, the potential experienced by the dipole levitated above an infinite superconducting plate may be expressed as: U(z_{0},\beta_{0})=\dfrac{\mu_{0}\mu^{2}}{64\pi(z-a)^{3}}(1+\sin^{2}\beta_{0}). (8) As we have translational invariance along the \rho axis, we have set \rho=0 . Although this result is known in the literature vinante_levitated_2022 , the derivation will serve as a basis for the calculations in the next section. III Dipole trapped between two superconducting plates To calculate the potential between two plates located at z=a and z=b , we generalize the method from the single-plate case by accounting for an infinite series of image dipoles. This iterative process ensures that the boundary conditions are consistently satisfied on both superconducting surfaces. To begin, we introduce two image dipoles with potentials \Phi_{1} and \Phi_{-1} at z_{1}=2a-z_{0} and z_{-1}=2b-z_{0} respectively: \displaystyle\Phi_{0}= \displaystyle\dfrac{\mu(z-z_{0})\sin\beta_{0}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{0}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+z^{2}+z_{0}^{2}-2zz_{0})^{3/2}}, (9) \displaystyle\Phi_{1}= \displaystyle\dfrac{-\mu(z-(2a-z_{0}))\sin\beta_{1}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+z^{2}+(2a-z_{0})^{2}-2z(2a-z_{0}))^{3/2}}, (10) \displaystyle\Phi_{-1}= \displaystyle\dfrac{-\mu(z-(2b-z_{0}))\sin\beta_{-1}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{-1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+z^{2}+(2b-z_{0})^{2}-2z(2b-z_{0}))^{3/2}}. (11) We introduce these dipoles with the same intention as in the previous section, to set the normal component of the B -field to zero at the plates \partial_{z}\Phi|_{z=a/b}=0 , however this fails immediately. To see this, we sum these terms \Phi=\Phi_{0}+\Phi_{1}+\Phi_{-1} and take the derivative with respect to z . Figure 1: Schematic representation of the infinite stack of image charges used to model the magnetic dipole \mathbf{\mu} trapped between two infinite superconducting plates. The image dipole method is used to represent the influence of the superconductors, creating an infinite series of mirror dipoles that enforce the boundary conditions. Evaluating at the a -plate we find that the image dipole located at z_{-1} contributes a non-zero term, similarly the image dipole located at z_{1} contributes a non-zero term on the b -plate. Explicitly: \displaystyle\partial_{z}\Phi|_{z=a}= \displaystyle\dfrac{\mu\sin\beta_{-1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(a-(2b-z_{0}))^{2})^{3/2}}-3(a-(2b-z_{0}))\left(\dfrac{\mu(a-(2b-z_{0}))\sin\beta_{-1}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{-1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(a-(2b-z_{0}))^{2})^{5/2}}\right), (12) \displaystyle\partial_{z}\Phi|_{z=b}= \displaystyle\dfrac{\mu\sin\beta_{1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(b-(2a-z_{0}))^{2})^{3/2}}-3(b-(2a-z_{0}))\left(\dfrac{\mu(b-(2a-z_{0}))\sin\beta_{1}+\mu\rho\cos\beta_{1}}{4\pi(\rho^{2}+(b-(2a-z_{0}))^{2})^{5/2}}\right). (13) To set these terms to zero we must modify our scalar potential to include two new image charges \Phi\to\Phi^{\prime}=\Phi+\Phi_{-2}+\Phi_{2} . To cancel the term ( 12 ) we add a dipole \Phi_{-2} at z_{-2}=2a-2b+z_{0} with orientation \beta_{-2}=\beta_{0} . Similarly to cancel the term ( 13 ) we introduce a fourth dipole \Phi_{2} at z_{2}=2b-2a+z_{0} with orientation \beta_{2}=\beta_{0} . However, we are not out of the woods yet. Indeed, if we evaluate the derivative of our new scalar potential at both plates \partial_{z}\Phi^{\prime}|_{z=a/b} we find that the image charges we introduced to generate counter terms, will themselves require counter terms. It is easy to see how the charges introduced to generate counter terms require counter terms themselves. Luckily for us, we can do this forever. Repeating the process with our new potential \Phi^{\prime}

Read the complete text