Geometric scaling of elastic p p pp cross section at the LHC
Michał Praszałowicz · 2025
Read Geometric scaling of elastic p p pp cross section at the LHC by Michał Praszałowicz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18841.txt.
Introduction
Praszałowicz revisits a striking pattern in proton-proton collisions first noticed more than fifty years ago at the ISR accelerator. When protons bounce off each other elastically, the scattering strength shows a dip-and-bump pattern, and a rule called geometric scaling was thought to govern how it changes with energy.
The author shows the same scaling still holds at the far higher energies of the Large Hadron Collider. The ratio between the bump and dip positions stays constant across the whole energy range. Using crossing symmetry and analyticity, the paper separates the real and imaginary parts of the scattering amplitude and computes key quantities. It also discusses where the scaling breaks down outside the dip-bump region.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michał Praszałowicz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18841
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Geometric scaling of elastic p p pp cross section at the LHC Michał Praszałowicz Abstract We show that geometric scaling conjectured and observed at the ISR more than 50 years ago, still holds at the LHC. We discuss regularities of the dip - bump structures of the differential elastic cross sections, emphasizing the fact that the ratio of bump to dip positions is constant from the ISR to the LHC. Applying crossing and analyticity we identify imaginary and real parts of the scattering amplitude and compute the ρ \rho parameter and the ratio of bump to dip values of the differential p p pp cross sections. We also discuss the energy dependence of the total elastic cross section and the violation of geometrical scaling outside the dip - bump region at the LHC. 1 Introduction In this paper we argue that geometric scaling conjectured and observed at the ISR more than 50 years ago [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , still holds at the LHC. This is not so obvious, since recent attempts to find a scaling law for elastic pp cross sections at the LHC energies have pointed to a different scaling [ 4 , 5 ] , possibly associated with high energy saturation [ 6 ] . For other studies on scaling properties of elastic cross sections see [ 7 , 8 ] . There exist three sets of total and two of differential pp high energy data. The ISR data [ 9 , 10 ] collected at CERN in 1970’s cover energies 20~\mathrm{GeV}\lesssim W=\sqrt{s}\lesssim 60~\mathrm{GeV} , recent LHC data by the TOTEM [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] and ATLAS [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] Collaborations at 3~\mathrm{TeV}\lesssim W=\sqrt{s}\lesssim 13~\mathrm{TeV} and the cosmic rays total cross section data, which, however, have rather large errors (see Fig. 2 ). Starting from the ISR energies total pp cross sections rise with energy, but the increase is faster at the LHC than at the lower energies. To show this in Ref. [ 5 ] a power law fit was performed in the restricted energy ranges, separately for the ISR data [ 10 ] and for the LHC data [ 18 ] . The results are shown in Table 1 . One can see that at the ISR all pp cross sections (total, elastic and inelastic) increase with energy with a universal power of \simeq 0.11 , which led to the formulation of geometric scaling (GS) in the 1970’s [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . This is no longer true at the LHC, casting doubt on the possibility that GS still holds at the LHC [ 4 , 5 ] . elastic inelastic total \rho ISR W^{0.1142\pm 0.0034} W^{0.1099\pm 0.0012} W^{0.1098\pm 0.0012} 0.02-0.095 LHC W^{0.2279\pm 0.0228} W^{0.1465\pm 0.0133} W^{0.1729\pm 0.0163} 0.15-0.10 Table 1: Energy dependence of the integrated pp cross sections for the energies W=\sqrt{s} at the ISR [ 10 ] and at the LHC [ 18 ] , and the \rho parameter [ 10 , 19 ] . Table from Ref. [ 5 ] . GS for the integrated cross sections can be best visualized in the impact parameter space. To see this, let’s consider the textbook formulas for the total and elastic cross sections in the normalization, where the scattering amplitude is dimensionless \displaystyle\sigma_{\text{tot}}(s) \displaystyle=2{\displaystyle\int}d^{2}\boldsymbol{b}\,\operatorname{Im}T_{\text{el}}(s,b), \displaystyle\sigma_{\text{el}}(s) \displaystyle={\displaystyle\int}d^{2}\boldsymbol{b}\,\left|T_{\text{el}}(s,b)\right|^{2}. (1) Very often one uses eikonal parametrization \operatorname{Im}T_{\text{el}}(s,b)=1-\exp(-\Omega(s,b)) where \Omega is called opacity. Inelastic cross-section is given as \sigma_{\text{inel}}(s)=\sigma_{\text{tot}}(s)-\sigma_{\text{el}}(s) . GS in impact parameter space means that \operatorname{Im}T_{\text{el}}(s,b)=\operatorname{Im}T_{\text{el}}(b/R(s)) , where R(s) is a so called interaction radius to be determined from the data [ 1 ] . It follows that the amplitude, which is formally a function of two independent variables b and s , depends in fact only on one dimensionless scaled variable B(s)=b/R(s) . Changing variables in the first equation ( 1 ) b\rightarrow B=b/R(s) one obtains \sigma_{\text{tot}}(s)=2R^{2}(s){\displaystyle\int}d^{2}\boldsymbol{B}\,\operatorname{Im}T_{\text{el}}(B). (2) If the real part of the elastic scattering amplitude can be neglected, as suggested by the smallness of the parameter \rho=\operatorname{Re}{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t=0)/\operatorname{Im}{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t=0) in momentum space, see Table 1 , we get that also \sigma_{\text{el}}(s)\sim R^{2}(s) and as a consequence also \sigma_{\text{inel}}(s)\sim R^{2}(s) [ 3 ] . As mentioned above GS of integrated cross sections is clearly seen at the ISR, but not at the LHC. 2 Elastic differential cross section and the dip - bump structure Let us now recall main features of pp differential elastic cross section d\sigma_{\mathrm{el}}/dt . One observes a rapid decrease for small |t| , then a minimum at t_{\mathrm{dip}} , followed by a broad maximum at t_{\mathrm{bump}} . This dip - bump structure emerges, as we will see later, from the Fourier transform of the impact parameter amplitude [ 20 ] and is related to the zeros and extrema of J_{0} Bessel function. A universal and striking property was reported in Ref. [ 5 ] , namely that the ratio of bump to dip positions is constant over the large energy span from the ISR to the LHC \mathcal{T}_{\mathrm{bd}}(s)=|t_{\mathrm{bump}}|/|t_{\mathrm{dip}}|=1.355\pm 0.011\,. (3) On the contrary, the ratio of the cross section values \mathcal{R}_{\mathrm{bd}}(s)=\frac{d\sigma_{\mathrm{el}}/d|t|_{\mathrm{{bump}}}}{d\sigma_{\mathrm{el}}/d|t|_{\mathrm{dip}}}\,, (4) which saturates at the LHC energies at a value of approximately 1.8, is rather strongly energy dependent at the ISR (see e.g. Fig. 2 in Ref. [ 21 ] and Fig 4 ). Property ( 3 ) implies that dip and bump positions should be identical at all energies if d\sigma_{\mathrm{el}}/dt is plotted in terms of a scaling variable \tau=f(s)|t| . In order to find f(s) at the LHC Ref. [ 5 ] performed a power law fit to the dips |t_{\mathrm{dip}}|=\mathrm{const}\times(W/(1~\mathrm{TeV}))^{-\beta} with the result \beta=0.1686\pm 0.0037 and \mathrm{const}=0.732\pm 0.003 GeV 2 . Therefore f(s)\sim W^{\beta} . Bumps are reproduced due to the property ( 3 ). Note that, within experimental accuracy, \beta is equal to exponent of the total cross section (see Table 1 ). Hence from Eq. ( 2 ) we can take f(s)=R^{2}(s)\sim\sigma_{\mathrm{tot}}(s) . At the ISR the situation is very similar. The authors of Ref. [ 2 ] used R^{2}(s)\sim\sigma_{\mathrm{inel}}(s) , however, since the energy dependence of \sigma_{\mathrm{inel}} and \sigma_{\mathrm{tot}} is the same, they could have used f(s)=R^{2}(s)\sim\sigma_{\mathrm{tot}}(s) as well, which they did in Ref. [ 22 ] . In order to further discuss GS it is more convenient to work in the momentum representation T_{\text{el}}(s,b)={\displaystyle\int}\frac{d^{2}\boldsymbol{q}}{(2\pi)^{2}}e^{i\,\boldsymbol{bq}}T_{\text{el}}(s,t). (5) Here b=\left|\boldsymbol{b}\right| , t=-\boldsymbol{q}^{2} . Then, from Eq. ( 1 ) \displaystyle s\sigma_{\text{tot}}(s) \displaystyle=2\operatorname{Im}\tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,0). (6) Following Refs. [ 1 , 2 ] we prefer work in a normalization where the elastic amplitude is dimensionless \tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t)=s{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t) . In this normalization the total elastic cross-section reads \displaystyle\sigma_{\text{el}}(s) \displaystyle=\frac{1}{4\pi s^{2}}{\displaystyle\int}dt\left|\tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t)\right|^{2}. (7) Now, we would like to parametrize \tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t) in a way which explicitly obeys GS and reproduces the energy dependence of the total cross section ( 6 ), neglecting for the moment the real part. In momentum representation GS means that \tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,t)\rightarrow\tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,\tau) , 1 1 1 Dependence of \tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,\tau) on s is only in the normalization factor. where \tau=\left|t\right|R^{2}(s) . Then, to recover the energy dependence \sigma_{\text{tot}}(s)\sim R^{2}(s) in Eq. ( 6 ), we assume that (we will be more precise later) \tilde{T}_{\text{el}}(s,\tau)=isR^{2}(s)\Phi(\tau)\,. (8) Here \Phi(\tau) is a dimensionless real function of the scaling variable \tau . Substituting ( 8 ) to Eq. ( 7