A hydrodynamical simulations-based model that connects the FRB DM–redshift relation to suppression of the matter power spectrum via feedback
Kritti Sharma, Elisabeth Krause, Vikram Ravi, Robert Reischke, Pranjal R. S, Liam Connor · 2025
Read A hydrodynamical simulations-based model that connects the FRB DM–redshift relation to suppression of the matter power spectrum via feedback by Kritti Sharma, Elisabeth Krause, Vikram Ravi, Robert Reischke, Pranjal R. S, Liam Connor (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18745.txt.
Introduction
Kritti Sharma and co-authors link the spread of fast radio burst delays to how gas push back warps small scale clumps of matter, in a paper from 2025. Weak lens maps of the sky need part in a hundred truth on those clumps, yet gas heat and jets smear them in ways that stay dim. Burst delays vary by line of sight in step with that push back, which gives a fresh probe.
The team casts the delay spread at each depth as a bent bell whose core marks are worked out from first marks of the gas field. That cast fits sim worlds more truly than the old cast. With ten thousand bursts the warp can be pinned to part in a hundred truth at wide scales. The link turns burst counts into a gas probe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kritti Sharma, Elisabeth Krause, Vikram Ravi, Robert Reischke, Pranjal R. S, Liam Connor |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18745
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A hydrodynamical simulations-based model that connects the FRB DM–redshift relation to suppression of the matter power spectrum via feedback Kritti Sharma, Elisabeth Krause, Vikram Ravi, Robert Reischke, Pranjal R. S, Liam Connor Abstract Understanding the impact of baryonic feedback on the small-scale ( k ≳ 1 h k\gtrsim 1\,h\, Mpc -1 ) matter power spectrum is a key astrophysical challenge, and essential for interpreting data from upcoming weak-lensing surveys, which require percent-level accuracy to fully harness their potential. Astrophysical probes, such as the kinematic and thermal Sunyaev-Zel’dovich effects, have been used to constrain feedback at large scales ( k ≲ 5 h k\lesssim 5\,h\, Mpc -1 ). The sightline-to-sightline variance in the fast radio bursts (FRBs) dispersion measure (DM) correlates with the strength of baryonic feedback and offers unique sensitivity at scales upto k ∼ 10 h k\sim 10\,h\, Mpc -1 . We develop a new simulation-based formalism in which we parameterize the distribution of DM at a given redshift, p ( DM | z ) p(\mathrm{DM}|z) , as a log-normal with its first two moments computed analytically in terms of cosmological parameters and the feedback-dependent electron power spectrum P ee ( k , z ) P_{\mathrm{ee}}(k,z) . We find that the log-normal parameterization provides an improved description of the p ( DM | z ) p(\mathrm{DM}|z) distribution observed in hydrodynamical simulations as compared to the standard F F -parameterization. Our model robustly captures the baryonic feedback effects across a wide range of baryonic feedback prescriptions in hydrodynamical simulations, including IllustrisTNG , SIMBA and Astrid . Leveraging simulations incorporates the redshift evolution of the DM variance by construction and facilitates the translation of constrained feedback parameters to the suppression of matter power spectrum relative to gravity-only simulations. We show that with 10 4 10^{4} FRBs, the suppression can be constrained to percent-level precision at large scales and ∼ 10 \sim 10 % precision at scales k ≳ 10 h k\gtrsim 10\,h\, Mpc -1 with prior-to-posterior 1 σ 1\sigma constraint width ratio ≳ 20 \gtrsim 20 . I Introduction Over the past two decades, observational cosmology has established the standard cosmological model, \Lambda cold dark matter ( \Lambda CDM), in which quantum fluctuations during inflation seed cosmic structure, and a cosmological constant drives late-time accelerated expansion. Observations of the expansion history, obtained through analyses of the fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background [ 82 , CMB;] , lensing of the CMB at intermediate redshifts [ 83 ] , Type Ia supernovae as standard candles [ 91 , 36 ] , the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) scale as a standard ruler [ 2 , 1 ] , and time-delay cosmography of gravitationally lensed quasars [ 119 ] and supernovae [ 81 ] , have constrained the key cosmological parameters, enabling rigorous tests of the standard \Lambda CDM model. While the origins of the Hubble tension and the S_{8} tension 1 1 1 S_{8}=\sigma_{8}\Omega_{\mathrm{m}}^{0.5} quantifies the degree of late-time matter clustering, where \sigma_{8} is the root-mean-square amplitude of the linear matter density fluctuations smoothed with a top-hat filter of comoving radius 8 h^{-1} Mpc and \Omega_{\mathrm{m}} is the matter density parameter. – whether physical or unaccounted systematics – remain under investigation, the broader consensus questioning the completeness of the standard model continues to build (see Di Valentino et al. 30 for a review). Paving the way for the era of precision cosmology, current and upcoming experiments, such as the Vera Rubin Observatory [ 48 ] , Euclid [ 57 ] and Wide-Field Infrared Survey Telescope [ 102 , 35 , WFIRST;] are designed to map the distribution of matter with unprecedented precision, leveraging techniques like gravitational lensing 2 2 2 The galaxy clustering analyses are primarily limited by the modeling of the non-linear galaxy bias (as opposed to baryonic feedback). Currently, the analyses using perturbation theory-based models are limited to k\sim 0.25\,h\, Mpc -1 , where the impact of feedback is almost negligible. [ 3 , 100 , 26 , 25 , 73 , 32 , 120 ] . To meet the expected statistical precision of these experiments, the impact of baryonic feedback on the matter power spectrum needs to be constrained with percent-level precision at scales k\lesssim 10\,h Mpc -1 [ 43 , 3 , 84 , 109 ] . The cosmic shear measurements at such small scales should practically only be limited by shape noise. Ignoring the impact of baryons can introduce systematic uncertainties into cosmological analyses, where the expected bias in the parameters of the equation of state ( w_{0},w_{a} ) and the sum of neutrino masses can be as large as \sim 5\sigma and \sim 20\sigma , respectively [ 18 ] . Therefore, cosmic shear analyses would benefit from accurate models of the matter power spectrum at small scales for cosmological inference. Broadly, cosmic shear analyses so far internally mitigate baryonic feedback through (i) scale cuts excluding scales affected by feedback [ 111 , 29 ] , (ii) analytic halo models with empirical baryon profiles [ 69 , 78 ] (iii) power spectrum emulators trained on post-processed N-body simulations [ 99 , 5 , 118 , the “baryonification” approach;] , and (iv) data-driven marginalization, such as principal component analysis [ 33 , PCA;] . These approaches eliminate systematics by either sacrificing valuable information from non-linear scales or marginalizing over complex feedback models, thus reducing the constraining power. Complementary to these strategies, independent observational probes of baryons offer a promising avenue for constraining the effects of baryonic feedback. For example, joint analyses of cosmic shear with X-ray observations [ 97 , 34 , 37 , 39 , 56 , e.g.] , the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel’dovich [ 16 , 97 , 10 , 40 , 9 , kSZ; e.g.] effect and the thermal Sunyaev-Zel’dovich [ 110 , 79 , 12 , tSZ; e.g.] effect help constrain the impact of baryonic feedback at small scales, using the information from independent probes of the baryon distribution. Fast Radio Bursts [ 80 , FRBs;] are a class of millisecond-duration transients that probe the distribution of baryons at scales upto k\sim 10\,h\, Mpc -1 (see § IV.3 for a description). The frequency-dependent dispersive delays caused by intervening plasma are encoded in the spectrum of the burst, quantified as the dispersion measure (DM), which probes the ionized electron column density along the line of sight, thus helping us constrain the location of baryons [ 63 ] . Specifically, the sightline-to-sightline variance in FRB DMs, parameterized by the form of the DM distribution p(\mathrm{DM}|z) , is sensitive to the influence of feedback on the degree of clustering of baryons [ 66 , 58 , 90 , 52 , 20 , 89 , 70 , e.g.,] . FRBs were quickly recognized as powerful probes of intergalactic baryons, with early studies highlighting their potential for cosmological applications [ 62 , 108 , 66 ] . The first precise localizations [ 17 , 86 , 7 ] established the extragalactic distance scale, and Macquart et al. [63] was the first to model the DM-redshift distribution of an FRB sample, laying the foundation for using FRBs as large-scale baryon tracers. Combining FRBs with other cosmological probes, such as Type Ia supernovae, BAO, and CMB,