Peeking under the clouds: Is exoplanet imaging with the solar gravitational lens feasible?
Viktor T. Toth 1 · 2025
Read Peeking under the clouds: Is exoplanet imaging with the solar gravitational lens feasible? by Viktor T. Toth 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18630.txt.
Introduction
Viktor Toth, a solo author, wrote an astronomy paper in 2025 on photographing planets around other stars. The sun's gravity bends light and can act as a giant lens. In theory, that lens could give sharp images of a far planet's surface. Many hurdles stand in the way, from lens flaws to noise.
Toth raises a hurdle past work had not faced: changing clouds on the target planet. A planet with shifting cloud cover hides its surface in a moving veil. That veil badly degrades the image that can be rebuilt from the lens data. His tests show the damage is large, not a minor blur. The paper ends with a cautious verdict on the whole idea. The lens may be far less practical than its promise suggests.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Viktor T. Toth 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18630
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Peeking under the clouds: Is exoplanet imaging with the solar gravitational lens feasible? Viktor T. Toth 1 Abstract Exoplanet imaging using the solar gravitational lens is an enticing prospect. The fundamental physical properties of the lens, including its angular resolution and light amplification, promise exceptional capabilities. These expectations, however, are tempered by the realization of numerous challenges, including imperfections of the lens itself, noise sources, the properties of the imaging target and difficult technical issues. We discuss, in particular, a subject not previously addressed, the impact of temporally varying surface features, notably a variable cloud cover, obscuring the target exoplanet. This has a substantial detrimental effect on image recovery, leading to our cautious assessment of the practical feasibility of using the Sun’s gravitational field as an effective telescope. keywords gravitational lensing: strong — instrumentation: miscellaneous — methods: numerical — planets and satellites: terrestrial planets — software: simulations 1 Introduction Compact, massive sources of gravitation such as the Sun deflect electromagnetic waves, including light. Light rays grazing the solar surface are deflected by \sim 1.75 arc seconds, a prediction of general relativity ( Einstein 1915 ) that was first observationally confirmed by Eddington’s famous 1919 solar eclipse expedition ( Dyson et al. 1920 ) . Knowing the solar radius, R_{\odot}\simeq 6.96\times 10^{8} m allows us to perform a simple calculation: initially parallel rays of light converge in a focal region that is located \sim 548 AU (astronomical units) from the Sun. This suggests that the Sun, serving as a giant magnifying lens, can be used to view distant sources at levels of light amplification and angular resolution far beyond what is achievable using manufactured instruments. When we investigate the details, however, a more nuanced picture emerges. The solar gravitational lens (SGL), like any compact gravitational lens, is a lens characterized by significant negative spherical aberration ( Turyshev & Toth 2017 ) . It does not project light to a focal point. Rather, light is focused along a focal half-line. Observers at increasing distance from the Sun would see rings of light (the Einstein ring) surrounding the Sun, with the ratio of the observed angular radius of the ring vs. the angular radius of the solar disk increasing as the square root of the observer’s distance. As a consequence, the SGL projects a blurred image of a light source even under ideal circumstances ( Turyshev & Toth 2020a ) . In reality, there are further challenges, which we addressed in past studies. These range from additional distortions due to the small but significant quadrupole mass moment of the Sun ( Turyshev & Toth 2021 ) , various sources of noise and light contamination such as the solar corona ( Turyshev & Toth 2019 ) , the formidable technical difficulties associated with the SGL focal region distance and the need for precise navigation ( Turyshev & Toth 2022 ; Helvajian et al. 2023 ) , and the fact that intended targets, exoplanets, will rotate around their axes under varying illumination while being observed ( Toth & Turyshev 2023 ) . One challenge remained unaddressed: potentially life-bearing Earth-like exoplanets also have a temporally varying appearance, dominated by a variable cloud cover. It is this issue that is the focus of the current study. More broadly, however, it leads to a fundamental question. We know that exoplanet imaging using a gravitational lens is possible in principle. But is it feasible ? That is to say, is it possible to recover images of planets in distant solar systems at a level of quality and resolution that is commensurate with the required effort? We recap the basic concepts of the SGL in Section 2 . To establish context, we discuss in more detail the specific challenges that an SGL imaging mission will have to answer in Section 3 . The cloud cover, the main topic of this paper, is discussed in detail in Section 4 . We assess these results in the context of overall feasibility and offer conclusions in Section 6 . 2 Basic concepts Our study of the SGL began with the simplest model ( Turyshev & Toth 2019 ) : Treating the Sun as a compact, spherically symmetric source of gravitation in the weak field approximation, and in the context of Maxwell’s theory of electromagnetism, we developed a model of an electromagnetic wave, passing near, and deflected by, the Sun. The SGL is characterized by a point-spread function (PSF) ( Turyshev & Toth 2020a ; Turyshev & Toth 2020b ) that, in the geometric optics limit ( Toth 2024 ) , may be averaged over the circular aperture d of an observing telescope as \displaystyle\overline{\tt PSF}(\rho)=\frac{2}{\pi}\Re{\tt E}\left(\frac{\rho}{\tfrac{1}{2}d}\right), (1) where {\tt E}(z)=\int_{0}^{1}\sqrt{1-k^{2}t^{2}}/\sqrt{1-t^{2}}~dt is the complete elliptic integral in Legendre normal form and \rho is the distance of the center of the telescope aperture, within the SGL’s projected image plane (i.e., the telescope lens plane), from the intersection of the “optical axis”—the imaginary line connecting the distant source with the center of the Sun and continuing towards the focal region—and the image plane. We derived this expression from a robust wave-optical model of the gravitational lens, but it is also derivable in the context of geometric optics. When \rho\gg d , this expression is very closely approximated by \overline{\tt PSF}(\rho)\simeq d/4\rho , which makes it explicit that the PSF drops off very slowly, with significant quantities of light spread over the image plane, resulting in substantial blur. This PSF characterizes lensing by a spherically symmetric mass. The actual Sun has a small quadrupole mass moment and higher multipole mass moments ( Turyshev & Toth 2021 ) , which lead to a modified PSF that incorporates angular dependence: {\rm PSF}(\boldsymbol{\mathrm{x}})=|B(\boldsymbol{\mathrm{x}})|^{2} , with the complex amplitude of the electromagnetic field in the lens plane characterized by \displaystyle B({\boldsymbol{\mathrm{x}}})=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{2\pi}d\phi_{\xi}\exp\bigg[ \displaystyle{-i}\frac{2\pi}{\lambda}\Big(\sqrt{\frac{2r_{g}}{z}}\rho\cos(\phi_{\xi}-\phi) \displaystyle{}+2r_{g}\sum_{n=2}^{\infty}\frac{J_{n}}{n}\left(\frac{R_{\odot}}{\sqrt{2r_{g}z}}\right)^{n}\sin^{n}\beta_{s}\cos[n(\phi_{\xi}-\phi_{s})]\Big)\bigg], (2) where \boldsymbol{\mathrm{x}}=(\rho,\phi) is a location in the image plane, J_{n} is a dimensionless zonal harmonic coefficient characterising the n -th mass moment of the Sun, while \phi_{s} and \beta_{s} are the heliocentric azimuth and colatitude of the observing location. There is no closed form expression like ( 1 ) in this case involving elementary or well-known special functions, though the corresponding integrals can be evaluated using standard numerical methods. As one might expect, the presence of the quadrupole moment can significantly increase blur at higher imaging resolutions. The SGL thus projects light from distant sources by forming blurred images of those sources in any image plane that is at a distance greater than \sim 548 AU from the Sun, perpendicular to the optical axis. The size of the projected image is easily calculated using elementary geometry: given a source distance R and an image plane distance r from the center of the Sun, the size of the projected image will be r/R times the size of the source. By way of example, an exoplanet with the same diameter as the Earth, located at 30 pc from the solar system will have a projected image of \sim 1,300 meters in diameter at \sim 650 AU from the Sun. This geometry dictates any imaging strategy. Rather obviously, we do not have access to a movie theater projection screen that is several square kilometers in size. Instead, we envision a