Four Elements to Rule Them All: Abundances are Rigidly Coupled in the Milky Way Disk

Jennifer Mead, Rebeca De La Garza, Melissa Ness · 2025

Read Four Elements to Rule Them All: Abundances are Rigidly Coupled in the Milky Way Disk by Jennifer Mead, Rebeca De La Garza, Melissa Ness (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18532.txt.

Introduction

Jennifer Mead, Rebeca De La Garza, and Melissa Ness study the chemical makeup of Milky Way disk stars, in a 2025 paper. The makeup is so tightly coupled that four elements nearly determine the rest. Astronomers dream of chemical tagging, reading a star's birthplace from its elements. That needs abundances that vary on their own. The team measured thirty elements in seventy-nine nearby stars. A larger sample of five hundred ninety-three stars gave nineteen elements each.

Simple linear models predicted most light and iron-peak elements within about seven percent, and neutron-capture elements within ten. Adding the first two s-process peaks sharpened the rest to five percent. The verdict cuts both ways: tagging birthplaces is hopeless above two percent precision, but the small leftovers carry fingerprints of star formation history. Future surveys must measure thirty-plus elements at a few percent to read them.

Catalog record

CREATORJennifer Mead, Rebeca De La Garza, Melissa Ness
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18532

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Four Elements to Rule Them All: Abundances are Rigidly Coupled in the Milky Way Disk Jennifer Mead, Rebeca De La Garza, Melissa Ness Abstract Chemical tagging is a central pursuit of galactic archaeology, but requires sufficiently discriminative abundances to uniquely identify sites of star formation. This task is complicated by intrinsic scatter among conatal stars, inter-element correlations, imprecise abundance measurements, and systematics across stellar evolutionary states. In this work, we formalize the abundance correlation structure of the disk by quantifying the amplitude of information in individual element abundances once a subset is known, and map inter-element residual correlations to uncover hidden signatures of nucleosynthesis. We use two datasets of 79 (593) stars across − 0.15 < [ Fe / H ] < 0.13 -0.15<\rm[Fe/H]<0.13 ( − 1 < [ Fe / H ] < 0.41 -1<\rm[Fe/H]<0.41 ) with measurements of 30 (19) element abundances of solar neighborhood stars, including 11 (7) light and α \alpha , 7 (3) Fe-peak, and 12 (9) neutron capture elements. With a simple linear regression model, we predict most α \alpha and Fe-peak element abundances within 0.03 dex ( ∼ 7 % \sim 7\% ), and neutron capture elements within 0.05 dex ( ∼ 10 % \sim 10\% ). Including first and second peak s -process elements as predictors improves most neutron capture element predictions to within 0.02 dex (5%), although no predictive power is gained by including an r -process element. We uncover strong (anti-)correlations in small residual abundances between and within element families. Our finding that disk abundance space is rigidly coupled, from light to heavy elements, implies chemical tagging is infeasible at > 2 % >2\% precision for ∼ \sim 30 elements. However, the residual structure encodes fingerprints of star formation history, inherited from nucleosynthesis and environmental variations, and provides critical constraints for chemical evolution models. Future disk surveys must achieve sub-2-5% precision in 30+ elements to access this independent information. I Introduction As the Universe has evolved from the first, metal-free, stars hundreds of millions of years after the Big Bang to the new stars we witness forming in our own Galaxy, each generation of stars has added their own contribution to the chemical composition of all subsequent generations of stars. Elements have different nucleosynthetic origins, and different nucleosynthetic channels produce different families of elements. Each element is typically produced by more than one source and the relative source contribution is a function of time [ 38 ] . Core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) primarily eject \alpha -elements [e.g. magnesium (Mg), silicon (Si), calcium (Ca), titanium (Ti)], which are produced in the cores of massive stars ( >8\,M_{\odot} ) [ 64 , 40 ] . On the other hand, Fe-peak elements [e.g. manganese (Mn), chromium (Cr), iron (Fe), nickle (Ni)] are primarily produced by Type Ia supernovae (SNIa) [ 39 ] . However, while elements are grouped into nucleosynthetic families, and some, like Mg, are considered to be ‘pure’ CCSNe elements, most elements, including Fe, Si, Ca, Ti, Mn, Cr and Ni have contributions from both SNIa and CCSNe [ 34 , 38 ] . Neutron capture elements have a variety of nucleosynthetic sources: s -process elements [e.g. strontium (Sr), yttrium (Y), barium (Ba), lanthanum (La)] are produced during the AGB phase of stellar evolution for low mass stars ( <8\,M_{\odot} ) [ 17 , 32 , 37 ] , and r -process elements (e.g. europium (Eu), gadolinium (Gd), dysprosium (Dy)) are proposed to originate from binary neutron star mergers [ 42 , 56 , 29 , 67 ] , though other sites of formation have been proposed, including neutrino driven winds from core-collapse supernovae and other exotic sources such as electron-capture supernovae, magneto-rotational supernovae with jets, collapsars, and hypernovae [ 23 , and references therein] . While the neutron capture elements may be dominated by one pathway, most have partial r- and s -process contributions. Laying out the chemical history of the Universe is of course not as simple as measuring element abundances and mapping them to ratios of different nucleosynthetic channels due to multiple nucleosynthetic pathways for all elements [ 38 ] , and the potential metallicity- and mass-dependence of stellar yields [ 72 ] . While mass- and metallicity-dependent yields only have a weak effect on galaxy scale properties (e.g. star formation rate, total metallicity, stellar masses, etc.), these variations in yields have a stronger influence on the spread of individual abundances, particularly at low metallicity [ 51 ] . Comparisons between measured element abundances and chemical evolution models – which track the production, distribution and enrichment of a galaxy over time using yield prescriptions from different sources – offer a route to try to use measured abundances to learn the star formation history of the Milky Way [ Chiappini2002 , Molla2019 , 38 , Johnson2021 , Matt2021 , 13 , e.g.] . The star formation history is typically parameterized by variables including the initial mass function, star formation efficiency, and star formation rate. These models are powerful tools than can successfully explain a number of global empirical trends and identify drivers of abundance signatures. However, there are substantial uncertainties and necessary assumptions made in the parameterization of star formation, element enrichment, and in stellar yields. Stellar yields alone have uncertainties relating to mass and metallicity dependencies, rotation, magnetic fields and mass loss. Additionally, the neutron flux densities that strongly influence s -process element production are typically highly uncertain, and details of the stellar explosions can strongly influence element production. Therefore, in detail, there can be substantial discrepancies between chemical evolution models and the ensemble of empirical measurements of populations of stars. Even individual stars cannot be reproduced by yields from chemical evolution models; the abundance pattern of the Sun cannot be matched with theoretical models, nor can the ratio of two alpha elements [Mg/Si] in typical stars in the disk [ 58 , 9 , 68 ] . Therefore, while global fits between data and models show discriminating power between models, given the uncertainties and assumptions required, it is not surprising there are discrepancies between observed element abundances and those generated in galactic chemical evolution models. Currently lacking in the theoretical landscape are models that track the joint production and distribution of a large number of elements that include constraints based on their measured distributions and correlations. Other approaches include the use of simulations to trace global abundance trends although these typically look to make overall comparisons that look to interpret results rather than directly and accurately reproducing the detailed abundance measurements [ 14 , 18 , 8 , e.g.] . In the present large-data era, whereby hundreds of millions of measured abundances are available, the data offer strong overall constraints for galactic chemical evolution models. In addition, survey data offer the means to test the premise of chemical tagging, i.e. to examine the dimensionality of the large vector of individual abundances. Recent work has demonstrated that the abundance space of the Milky Way disk is far more correlated than anticipated and that there are signals of detailed nucleosynthesis captured in the abundance measurements. In one of the first formalized data-driven approaches to nucleosynthesis, Casey et al. [19] introduced a model where just six latent factors, four of which

Read the complete text