Ab initio modeling of TWIP and TRIP effects in β \beta -Ti alloys

David Holec, Johann Grillitsch, José L. Neves, David Obersteiner, Thomas Klein · 2025

Read Ab initio modeling of TWIP and TRIP effects in β \beta -Ti alloys by David Holec, Johann Grillitsch, José L. Neves, David Obersteiner, Thomas Klein (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18378.txt.

Introduction

David Holec and four co-authors model from first principles how alloying shifts phase change effects in beta titanium alloys, known by the short names TWIP and TRIP. These effects shape how the metal bends without breaking. Their work came out in twenty twenty-five.

The team used density based theory on pure titanium and on mixes with nine other elements. Some elements steadied the beta phase, yet the most stable phase sat between beta and alpha, a martensite form. Twin borders of one type face a positive energy wall that alloying raises. The other twin type shows no wall save for two elements, since its mid state looks like the alpha phase. Twin border energies round out design hints.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Holec, Johann Grillitsch, José L. Neves, David Obersteiner, Thomas Klein
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18378

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ab initio modeling of TWIP and TRIP effects in β \beta -Ti alloys David Holec, Johann Grillitsch, José L. Neves, David Obersteiner, Thomas Klein Abstract Transformations in bcc- β \beta , hcp- α \alpha , and the ω \omega phases of Ti alloys are studied using Density Functional Theory for pure Ti and Ti alloyed with Al, Si, V, Cr, Fe, Cu, Nb, Mo, and Sn. The β \beta -stabilization caused by alloying Si, Fe, Cr, and Mo was observed, but the most stable phase appears between the β \beta and the α \alpha phases, corresponding to the martensitic α ′′ \alpha^{\prime\prime} phase. Next, the { 112 } ​ ⟨ 11 ​ 1 ¯ ⟩ \{112\}\langle 11\bar{1}\rangle bcc twins are separated by a positive barrier, which further increases by alloying w.r.t. pure Ti. The { 332 } ​ ⟨ 11 ​ 3 ¯ ⟩ \{332\}\langle 11\bar{3}\rangle twinning yields negative barriers for all species but Mo and Fe. This is because the transition state is structurally similar to the α \alpha phase, which is preferred over the β \beta phase for the majority of alloying elements. Lastly, the impact of alloying on twin boundary energies is discussed. These results may serve as design guidelines for novel Ti-based alloys with specific application areas. keywords DFT, Ti alloys, TRIP, TWIP, Phase transformations, Plasticity 1 Introduction Titanium alloys generate a lot of interest due to a favorable combination of mechanical and structural properties, making them applicable in the aerospace industry Najafizadeh et al. (2024) . Furthermore, their general biocompatibility also enables medical usage Sidambe (2014) . Recently, even stronger application-driven interest has been generated due to the additive manufacturing (AM) of parts with complicated geometries, as exemplified by the wire and arc additive manufacturing process Lin et al. (2021) . Titanium is an allotropic material Leyens and Peters (2006) . The two phases commonly associated with Ti are hcp- \alpha -Ti (space group: P6_{3}/mmc , Fig. 1 d) and bcc- \beta -Ti ( Im\bar{3}m , Fig. 1 b), with the low-temperature \alpha -Ti maintaining stability up to \approx 1155\,\text{K} Dinsdale (1991) . The 0\,\text{K} ground state structure is \omega -Ti ( P6/mmm , Fig. 1 a), and its stability has been predicted to extend only to \approx 186\,\text{K} at ambient pressure Mei et al. (2009) . Lastly, martensitic transformation upon rapid cooling from the \beta phase field may yield either \alpha^{\prime\prime} or \alpha^{\prime} , depending on the amount of alloyed \beta -stabilizing elements in the Ti matrix. The \alpha^{\prime} is an only slightly distorted \alpha phase with lattice parameters close to the ideal hcp structure. On the contrary, the \alpha^{\prime\prime} ( Cmcm , Fig. 1 c) resembles the lattice of the \beta phase described in an orthorhombic frame, with atoms displaced (shuffled) away from their bcc positions towards the hcp arrangement Zheng et al. (2022) . Figure 1: Unit cells of common Ti phases considered in this paper: a) \omega -Ti, b) bcc- \beta -Ti, c) martensitic \alpha^{\prime\prime} -Ti, and d) hcp- \alpha -Ti. The red lines denote the conventional cells used for their description. Visualized using VESTA Momma and Izumi (2011) . The mechanical response of Ti-based alloys is governed, next to dislocation motion, by triggering specific deformation mechanisms, namely Transformation-Induced Plasticity (TRIP) and Twinning-Induced Plasticity (TWIP) Zhao et al. (2021) . TRIP is a phase transformation upon applied stress from a metastable phase ( \beta ) to a martensitic one ( \alpha^{\prime} / \alpha^{\prime\prime} ), thereby enhancing strength and ductility. TWIP improves ductility by absorbing some of the applied strain in the form of deformation twins. Although TWIP is usually associated with the stable \alpha phase of Ti, it also can occur in the \beta phase. The prominent twinning mechanisms involve the \{112\}\langle 11\bar{1}\rangle and \{332\}\langle 11\bar{3}\rangle systems Kwasniak et al. (2022) , where the latter has been proposed to happen more likely due to a lower extent of required shuffling Tobe et al. (2014) . Which deformation mechanism dominates is often assessed using the semi-empirical Bo-Md method Abdel-Hady et al. (2006) ; Ren et al. (2018) ; Lilensten et al. (2020) ; Zhao et al. (2021) . The Bo-Md model was first suggested by Morinaga et al. (1988) . It has been shown to be effective in achieving the desired dominant deformation mechanism in several newly designed titanium alloys Lilensten et al. (2020) ; Marteleur et al. (2012) . The method uses two calculated parameters. Bo is the bond order measure of the covalent bond strength between the Ti matrix and the alloying elements. Md is the correlation of the electronegativity of the metallic radii of the elements. Both of these parameters have been calculated and tabulated for each element. These parameters are then used to plot the alloys in the form of maps (see e.g. Lilensten et al. (2020) ; Marteleur et al. (2012) ). The original work by Morinaga et al. (1988) also evidences how the position of an alloy is changed in this map by additions of a chemical element (see Fig. 9 in their work). This method offers a straightforward starting point for screening alloy compositions, particularly when targeting TRIP or TWIP behavior in metastable \beta -titanium alloys. For example, Lilensten et al. (2020) successfully designed a dual-phase Ti-7Cr-1.5Sn alloy that exhibits both TRIP and TWIP mechanisms. Their alloy design approach combined the Bo–Md method with CALPHAD-based thermodynamic modeling. Experimental validation of the alloy’s deformation behavior, including stress-induced \alpha^{\prime\prime} martensite, \{33\bar{2}\}\langle 11\bar{3}\rangle twinning, and at larger strains, \{11\bar{2}\}\langle 11\bar{1}\rangle twinning and \omega phase formation, was achieved using in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction and EBSD analysis. Applying the Bo-Md method to elements considered in the present study, it can be concluded that the combined use of elements from both groups (V, Fe, Cr, Nb, Mo) and (Cu, Al, Sn) is necessary to induce twinning instead of conventional dislocation plasticity. However, recent experimental investigations have increasingly highlighted the limitations of purely empirical models. For instance, Ballor et al. (2023) highlight in their comprehensive review multiple cases where alloys with similar Mo-equivalent values exhibited significantly different deformation responses, ranging from \alpha^{\prime\prime} formation to unexpected \omega phase precipitation. Such discrepancies emphasize the fact that models like Mo-equivalency and Bo-Md , while valuable, do not fully capture the complexity of phase transformations and deformation behavior. A recently published machine-learning-based approach has been claimed to supersede its prediction accuracy Coffigniez et al. (2024) . Another indicator for the transformation mechanism is the stacking fault energy (SFE). Generally, materials with a low SFE prefer TRIP; a moderate SFE results in deformation via TWIP, while alloys with a high SFE deform via dislocation slip Pierce et al. (2015) . These material characteristics can be influenced by chemical composition. Hence, alloying is a practical design tool for tuning the actual deformation mechanism Zhao et al. (2021) . Useful insights into the mechanics of the phase transformations can be obtained from atomistic simulations. DFT revealed that the martensitic \alpha^{\prime\prime} phase prefers to nucleate and grow at the \{332\}\langle 11\bar{3}\rangle twin boundary Chen et al. (2019) and therefore dominates the deformation mechanism in pure Ti. Later, Zhang et al. (2023) argued that \alpha^{\prime\prime} is unlikely to be directly formed at the twin boundary and is likely to be

Read the complete text