More is less in unpercolated active solids
Jack Binysh, Guido Baardink, Jonas Veenstra, Corentin Coulais, Anton Souslov · 2025
Read More is less in unpercolated active solids by Jack Binysh, Guido Baardink, Jonas Veenstra, Corentin Coulais, Anton Souslov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18362.txt.
Introduction
Jack Binysh and co-authors report a surprise in active solids, materials whose parts push themselves. In most such matter, more inner push means a stronger large-scale response. Their 2025 study looks at loose, web-like solids where that rule breaks down.
As the inner push grows, the broad response can fade to nothing, so more gives less. Wobbly, local modes take over and hide the push from the whole. The team find these modes in any sparse repeating frame, and in random webs below a set density. The result gives fresh rules for building materials that work far from rest.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jack Binysh, Guido Baardink, Jonas Veenstra, Corentin Coulais, Anton Souslov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18362
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
More is less in unpercolated active solids Jack Binysh, Guido Baardink, Jonas Veenstra, Corentin Coulais, Anton Souslov Abstract A remarkable feat of active matter physics is that systems as diverse as collections of self-propelled particles, nematics mixed with molecular motors, and interacting robots can all be described by symmetry-based continuum theories. These descriptions rely on reducing complex effects of individual motors to a few key active parameters, which increase with activity. Here we discover a striking anomaly in the continuum description of non-reciprocal active solids, a ubiquitous class of active materials. We find that as microscopic activity increases, macroscale active response can vanish: more is less. In this highly active regime, non-affine and localized modes prevail and destroy the large-scale signature of microscopic activity. These modes exist in any dilute periodic structure and emerge in random lattices below a percolation transition. Our results unveil a counterintuitive facet of active matter, offering new principles for engineering materials far from equilibrium. The stiffer the steel—the stiffer the bridge. This principle broadly applies to mechanical structures in equilibrium: By rigidifying even a single component, the entire structure becomes more rigid. Beyond architecture, this idea connects structure with function in any material, from polymers and glasses to nano– and meta–materials. This one-to-one connection derives from the same logic that guarantees stability in mechanical equilibrium, and is more generally known as Le Chatelier’s principle. The principle dictates that near equilibrium, a system will counteract an external stimulus. Related concepts also apply to fluidic, electric, and chemical networks, and form the foundation of materials mechanics. Active materials—composed of units that use ambient energy to exert local forces, pushing the system far from equilibrium Marchetti et al. 2013 ; Gompper et al. 2025 —routinely challenge the principles of thermodynamics. These materials unlock properties that are traditionally forbidden, from long-range orientational order in 2D and phase separation in the absence of attraction Cates and Tailleur 2015 to time-crystalline states Bruno 2013 ; Watanabe and Oshikawa 2015 ; Fruchart et al. 2021 ; Liu et al. 2023 . Active solids Volpe et al. 2024 ; Tan et al. 2022 ; Baconnier et al. 2022 ; Zhang and Fodor 2023 ; Xu et al. 2023 ; Armon et al. 2021 ; Pérez-Verdugo et al. 2024 combine this far-from-equilibrium character with a stable reference state, in sharp contrast to the instabilities and nonlinearities that plague many active systems Alert et al. 2022 . Significantly, even away from the stable state, these materials exhibit well-controlled dynamics Veenstra et al. 2025 , which can be tuned via external stimuli Saintyves et al. 2024 ; Devlin et al. 2025 . These features make active solids especially attractive for functional materials, but being far from equilibrium presents a challenge in designing their linear response. Here we ask a basic question: when does Le Chatelier’s principle, including the monotonicity of macroscale rigidity with microscale stiffness, break down in active solids? To address this question, we focus on non-reciprocal active matter, which is found in contexts as diverse as spins Hanai 2024 ; Avni et al. 2025 ; Loos et al. 2023 , optomechanical devices Raskatla et al. 2024 ; Liška et al. 2024 ; Reisenbauer et al. 2024 ; Ruesink et al. 2016 , optics Weidemann et al. 2020 , acoustics Fleury et al. 2014 ; Lim et al. 2024 , hydrodynamics Beatus et al. 2006 ; Bililign et al. 2022 ; Gu et al. 2025 , reaction–diffusion chemistry and colloidal physics You et al. 2020 ; Brauns and Marchetti 2024 ; Saha et al. 2020 ; Dinelli et al. 2023 ; Osat and Golestanian 2023 ; Meredith et al. 2020 . Crucially, non-reciprocity can also be defined at the level of mechanics Scheibner et al. 2020a ; Fruchart et al. 2023 , where the non-equilibrium nature of linear response manifests itself via amplified waves and linear work cycles. However, in all of those studies, Le Chatelier’s principle is respected: the macroscopic response is monotonic in the microscopic activity. Here we create materials in which increasing the microscopic activity weakens linear response, violating Le Chatelier’s principle. Combining experiments on robotic metamaterials with analytical coarse graining, we discover that this anomalous behaviour is rooted in a percolation transition within the active parts of the elastic solid. Below percolation, active floppy modes emerge, which kill the macroscopic manifestation of microscale activity. At the same time that continuum response fails to capture the signatures of non-reciprocity, we discover a proliferation of active higher-frequency optical modes. Our work establishes the percolation of active units as a general principle for understanding active solids, with applications ranging from the design of self-learning networks Goodrich et al. 2015 ; Rocks et al. 2017 ; Yan et al. 2017 ; Stern et al. 2021 and mechanical metamaterials Saintyves et al. 2024 ; Devlin et al. 2025 ; Du et al. 2025 to the dynamics of biological lattices Armon et al. 2021 ; Pérez-Verdugo et al. 2024 ; Ronceray et al. 2019 ; Duque et al. 2024 ; Chao et al. 2024 . Figure 1: Anomalous odd response in non-reciprocal materials. Transversely shearing an isotropic lattice built from non-reciprocal plaquettes generates normal stresses, the hallmark of odd elasticity. These odd moduli break equilibrium conditions of monotonic response, and can anomalously vanish as microscopic activity increases. (a-b) A robotic metamaterial built from a mixture of active (blue highlights) and passive hexagonal plaquettes. Each active plaquette is made from three bar linkages (side length a ). Motors on each linkage vertex exert torques according to a non-reciprocal torque-angle relation \tau_{i}=\kappa^{a}(\delta\theta_{i+1}-\delta\theta_{i-1}) , alongside a passive elastic response \tau_{i}=-\kappa\delta\theta_{i} . The lowest deformation modes of these plaquettes are the transverse S_{1} and vertical S_{2} shears. (c) Shearing the lattice reveals an anomalous regime where the odd modulus K^{o} decreases as microscale non-reciprocity \kappa^{a} diverges, with crossover occurring at \kappa^{a}/\kappa\sim 1 . Points correspond to experimental runs, solid curve indicates coarse-grained theory. (d,e) Visualising the strain field within the lattice in experiment and periodic theory reveals a non-affine checkerboard pattern in which active plaquettes lock, admitting no shear deformation at all. Plaquette colors show hexagonal strain |S|=\sqrt{S_{1}^{2}+S_{2}^{2}} , with active plaquettes indicated by inset circles. (f) To track the plaquette-level response to an applied shear \epsilon , we average the strain over all active plaquettes, \langle S\rangle , and then compute the susceptibility {d\langle S\rangle}/{d\epsilon} as a function of activity \kappa^{a} . We find that the anomalous plaquette-locked regime emerges at high activity, with crossover in the shear modes occurring concurrently with the peak and decay of the odd modulus. We first illustrate how macroscale non-reciprocal response can vanish even as microscale non-reciprocity increases. Figure 1 (a) shows a robotic metamaterial built from hexagonal plaquettes of torque motors. When the motors are off, each hinge in the lattice has a passive torque-angle relation \tau_{i}=-\kappa\delta\theta_{i} with stiffness \kappa . Within each active plaquette [Fig. 1 (a), blue highlights] the i^{\mathrm{th}} motor additionally exerts an active torque \tau_{i}=\kappa^{a}(\delta\theta_{i+1}-\delta\theta_{i-1}) via an antisymmetric combination of neighboring angular deflections \delta\theta_{i+1},\delta\theta_{i-1} [Fig. 1 (b)] (Methods § VII and Supplemental Video S1). This microscale antisymmetry, quantified by \kappa^{a} , breaks Maxwell-Betti reciprocity and generates an antisymmetric coupling between the horizontal S_{1} and vertical S_{2} shear modes of