The possible frustrated superconductivity in the kagome superconductors

Hong-Min Jiang, Wen-Qian Dong, Shun-Li Yu, Z. D. Wang · 2025

Read The possible frustrated superconductivity in the kagome superconductors by Hong-Min Jiang, Wen-Qian Dong, Shun-Li Yu, Z. D. Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18336.txt.

Introduction

Hong-Min Jiang and three co-authors propose a frustrated pairing state in kagome superconductors. Kagome nets are lattices with corner shared triangles that breed frustration, oft studied for magnets. Here the clash is between pairing pull and lattice shape, not spins.

A phase twist of a set step around the Fermi surface gives a six fold strength wave and breaks time symmetry. The state shrugs off dirt with no in gap states and shows a famed peak in nuclear response below the switch point. Dirt can flip it to a plain round state, which matches lab tales that seemed at odds.

Catalog record

CREATORHong-Min Jiang, Wen-Qian Dong, Shun-Li Yu, Z. D. Wang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18336

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The possible frustrated superconductivity in the kagome superconductors Hong-Min Jiang, Wen-Qian Dong, Shun-Li Yu, Z. D. Wang Abstract Geometric frustration has long been a subject of enduring interest in condensed matter physics. While geometric frustration traditionally focuses on magnetic systems, little attention is paid to the ”frustrated superconductivity” which could arise when the superconducting interaction conflicts with the crystal symmetry. The recently discovered kagome superconductors provide a particular opportunity for studying this due to the fact that the frustrated lattice structure and the interference effect between the three sublattices can facilitate the frustrated superconducting interaction. Here, we propose a theory that supports the frustrated superconducting state, derived from the on-site s s -wave superconducting pairing in conjunction with the nearest-neighbor pairings hopping and the unique geometrical frustrated lattice structure. In this state, whereas the mutual 2 ​ π / 3 2\pi/3 difference of the superconducting pairing phase causes the six-fold modulation of the amplitude and breaks the time-reversal symmetry with 4 ​ π 4\pi phase changes of the superconducting pairing as one following it around the Fermi surface, it is immune to the impurities without the impurity-induced in-gap states and produces the pronounced Hebel-Slichter peak of the nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate below T c T_{c} . Notably, the theory also reveals a disorder-induced superconducting pairing transition from the frustrated superconducting state to an isotropic s s -wave superconducting state without traversing the nodal points, recovering and explaining the behavior found in experiment. This study not only serves as a promising proposal to mediate the divergent or seemingly contradictory experimental outcomes regarding superconducting pairing symmetry, but may also pave the way for advancing investigations into the frustrated superconducting state. I Introduction The discovery of superconductivity in a family of compounds AV 3 Sb 5 (A=K, Rb, Cs), which share a common lattice structure with kagome net of vanadium atoms, has set off a new boom of researches on the superconductivity as well as the associated exotic quantum states Ortiz1 ; SYYang1 ; Ortiz2 ; QYin1 ; KYChen1 ; YWang1 ; ZZhang1 ; YXJiang1 ; FHYu1 ; XChen1 ; HZhao1 ; HChen1 ; HSXu1 ; Liang1 ; CMu1 ; CCZhao1 ; SNi1 ; WDuan1 ; Xiang1 ; PhysRevX.11.041030 ; PhysRevB.104.L041101 ; ZLiu1 ; NatPhys.M.Kang ; YFu1 ; HTan1 ; Shumiya1 ; FHYu2 ; LYin1 ; Nakayama2 ; KJiang1 ; LNie1 ; HLuo1 ; Neupert1 ; YSong1 ; Nakayama1 ; HLi1 ; CGuo1 ; HLi2 ; HLi3 ; XWu1 ; Denner1 ; SCho1 ; YPLin3 ; LZheng1 ; CWen1 ; Tazai1 ; Jiang1 ; Mielke1 . The appealing aspects of these compounds lie in that they incorporate many remarkable properties of the electron structure, such as VHF, FS nesting and nontrivial band topology Ortiz1 . Meanwhile, the superconducting (SC) phase emerges next to a charge density wave phase in the pressure-temperature phase diagram. As the electrons in these materials suffer simultaneously from the geometrical frustration, topological band structure and the competition between different possible ground states, the observations of the superconductivity in these topological metals are in themselves exotic and rare. The connection to the underlying lattice geometry and the topological nature of the band structure further place them in the context of wider research efforts in topological physics and superconductivity. To understand the underlying mechanism of the superconductivity in this family of kagome superconductors, the determination of the pairing symmetry of the SC order parameter is thought to be a prerequisite step. For this goal, numerous experiments with various means have been conducted in the past several years. However, inconsistent results were found so far in experimental measurements and data analysis, and some unusual features were discovered as well in the SC state of AV 3 Sb 5 . On the one hand, the SC pairings in these compounds are suggested to be of the conventional s -wave type, supported by the appearance of the Hebel-Slichter coherence peak just below T_{c} in the nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy CMu1 and the nodeless SC gap in both the penetration depth measurements WDuan1 and the angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) experiment YZhong1 . Intriguingly, recent magnetic penetration depth measurements also revealed a impurity induced transition from an anisotropic fully-gapped state to an isotropic full-gap state without passing through a nodal state Roppongi1 . On the other hand, the indications of time-reversal symmetry breaking discovered in the SC state Mielke1 ; YWang1 ; YWu1 , together with the nodal SC gap feature detected by some experiments HZhao1 ; CCZhao1 ; HSXu1 ; Liang1 ; HChen1 , hint to an unconventional superconductivity. Although the majority of experimental evidence in the AV 3 Sb 5 materials indicates that the superconductivity has a conventional origin with spin singlet s -wave pairing CMu1 ; WDuan1 ; YZhong1 ; YXie1 , the field is haunted by the seemingly divergent experimental observations regarding the pairing symmetry. Theoretically, a variety of possible pairing symmetries have been put forward in the kagome systems, ranging from the s -wave WSWang1 ; THan1 ; Tazai1 , d -wave, and extended s_{ext} -wave to d_{x^{2}-y^{2}}+id_{xy} -wave pairing symmetries SLYu1 ; WSWang1 ; Romer1 ; Kiesel3 , and even triplet p -wave Tazai1 and f -wave pairing symmetries SLYu1 ; CWen1 ; XWu1 ; TZhou1 . Considering the interplay of the superconductivity and CDW phase, theoretical analysis has also shown that a conventional fully gapped superconductivity is unable to open a gap on the domains of the chiral 2\times 2 charge density wave (CDW) and results in the gapless edge modes in the SC state YGu1 . A more direct consideration of the interplay between the superconductivity and the chiral 2\times 2 CDW has revealed that a modulated and even nodal SC gap features show up albeit an on-site s -wave SC order parameter being included in the study HMJiang2 ; HMJiang3 ; TZhou2 . In this scenario, the coexistence of the conventional superconductivity and the chiral CDW has also been proposed to explain time-reversal symmetry breaking in the kagome superconductors HMJiang2 ; HMJiang3 ; TZhou1 . Nevertheless, more recent experiments have evidenced that the time-reversal symmetry breaking has a direct connection to the SC state YWang1 ; TLe1 , especially in the case where the CDW order was fully suppressed by Ta atoms doping into CsV 3 Sb 5 HDeng1 . While a variety of possible pairing states with time-reversal symmetry breaking have been proposed, there is still limited knowledge as to how the SC pairings that possess the conventional origin could have the intrinsic time-reversal symmetry breaking SC state. In this paper, we propose a theory in which the conventional on-site s -wave SC pairing transforms to the time-reversal symmetry breaking SC state, as a result of the nearest-neighbor pairings hoping and the unique geometrical frustrated lattice structure. In this state, the phase of the SC pairing on the three sublattices mutually differs by 2\pi/3 , an analogy to the frustrated magnetism, which is dubbed as ”frustrated SC state” thereafter. The amplitude of the frustrated SC state modulates along the Fermi surface six-fold symmetrically without passing through the nodes. The frustrated SC state breaks the time-reversal symmetry explicitly with the 4\pi phase changes of the SC pairing as one following it around the Fermi surface, i.e., winding

Read the complete text