The growth of a lithium abundance dispersion in pre main sequence stars
R. J. Jackson, R. D. Jeffries, E. Tognelli · 2025
Read The growth of a lithium abundance dispersion in pre main sequence stars by R. J. Jackson, R. D. Jeffries, E. Tognelli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18265.txt.
Introduction
Jackson, Jeffries, and Tognelli track how an odd spread in young stars' light-metal marks grows as the stars age. The work came out in 2025. Young stars shrink and burn that metal as they grow. Stock star math says stars of the same heat should reach full growth with the same share left. In fact, a spread shows up.
The team used one clean data set from the Gaia-ESO sky scan. They tracked groups of soon-to-be dwarf stars in packs aged 2 to 300 Myr. In the low-weight stars, a spread in mark strength opens at 10 to 20 Myr. It opens just as burn starts, in stars mixed all the way through too. A model with star spots can match the time and weight marks. Spots cloak a split share of each face. That cloak shifts how fast the metal burns down below.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | R. J. Jackson, R. D. Jeffries, E. Tognelli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18265
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The growth of a lithium abundance dispersion in pre main sequence stars R. J. Jackson, R. D. Jeffries, E. Tognelli Abstract Lithium is predicted, and observed, to be depleted in contracting, low-mass pre main sequence (PMS) stars. Yet these stars reach the zero age main sequence (ZAMS) with a spread in lithium abundance at a given effective temperature that is not predicted by standard stellar evolutionary models and which appears to be correlated with rotation. Using a homogeneous dataset provided by the Gaia -ESO spectroscopic survey, we have followed the evolving photospheric lithium content of cohorts of stars destined to be ZAMS late G-, K- and M-dwarfs, in clusters at ages of 2–300 Myr. We show that a dispersion in the Li i 6708Å line strength develops in the lower mass stars after 10–20 Myr on the PMS, as soon as Li depletion begins, even in fully convective stars. A model based on a surface starspot coverage varying from star-to-star, leading to a differential Li-burning rate, can explain this temporal behaviour and its mass dependence. However, to fully explain the magnitude of the Li dispersion and its correlation with rotation, the spot coverage during Li-burning would need to be a factor of two larger on average than measured in ZAMS clusters like the Pleiades and continue increasing with rotation in PMS stars beyond the usual "saturation limit" observed for other magnetic activity indicators. The growth of a lithium abundance dispersion in pre main sequence stars – 16 2024 1 Introduction The photospheric lithium abundance in cool, low-mass stars probes their internal structure and mixing processes. The dominant 7 Li isotope undergoes fusion at lower temperatures ( \sim 3\times 10^{6} K) than hydrogen, so “Li-burning” begins in the contracting pre main sequence (PMS) phase once central temperatures reach this ignition threshold ( Bildsten et al., 1997 , e.g.,) . In the lowest mass PMS stars that remain fully convective all the way to the zero age main sequence (ZAMS), mixing from centre to surface is efficient, and rapid photospheric Li depletion is predicted. For higher mass stars ( \geq 0.4\,M_{\odot} ), a growing radiative core provides a barrier to deep mixing; in models of this process, photospheric Li depletion is arrested, leaving a mass-dependent, non-zero Li abundance at the ZAMS (e.g., Pinsonneault, 1997 , Baraffe et al., 1998 , Siess, Dufour & Forestini, 2000 , Piau & Turck-Chièze, 2002 , Dotter et al., 2008 , Tognelli, Prada Moroni & Degl’Innocenti, 2011 , Baraffe et al., 2015 ). Different models predict different Li-depletion rates as a function of mass (or effective temperature, T_{\rm eff} ), depending on the adopted opacities, equations of state, treatment of convective mixing and the atmosphere bounding the star ( Tognelli, Degl’Innocenti & Prada Moroni, 2012 , e.g.,) . However, all agree that the Li-depletion pattern should be a single-valued function of mass/ T_{\rm eff} , without dispersion. Observations contradict this prediction. In the Pleiades at an age \sim 120 Myr ( Duncan & Jones, 1983 ; Butler et al., 1987 ; Soderblom et al., 1993 ; Jeffries, 1999 ) , and since confirmed in several other clusters at somewhat younger and older ages (e.g., Randich et al., 1998 , Jeffries, James & Thurston, 1998 , Jeffries & James, 1999 , Randich et al., 2001 , Balachandran, Mallik & Lambert, 2011 ), it has been established that ZAMS stars with 4000\leq T_{\rm eff}/K\leq 5400 have an intrinsic Li abundance dispersion of up to 2 orders of magnitude, inferred from a corresponding range of \sim 300 mÅ in the equivalent width (EW Li ) of the Li i 6708Å resonance line, that is far greater than any observational uncertainties. There are several proposed explanations for the Li dispersion. The photospheres of these young, magnetically active stars are affected by spots, plages and overlying chromospheres, such that EW Li may not accurately reflect Li abundances when interpreted with simple, homogeneous, LTE models ( Stuik, Bruls & Rutten, 1997 ; King, Krishnamurthi & Pinsonneault, 2000 ) ; although other studies suggest these effects are too small to fully explain the observed dispersion ( Barrado y Navascués et al., 2001 ; King et al., 2010 ) . It has also become clear that the dispersion is strongly correlated with rotation rate - the fastest rotating stars at a given T_{\rm eff} have larger EW Li ( Barrado et al., 2016 ; Bouvier et al., 2018 ) and this leads to the idea that the structural effects of dynamo-generated interior magnetic fields or surface starspots might inhibit convection, inflate the star compared to standard model expectations and delay or slow the rate of Li depletion in fast rotators ( Somers & Pinsonneault, 2015b ; Somers & Stassun, 2017 ; Jeffries et al., 2021 , e.g.,) , or that the convection criterion is modified in faster rotators leading to shallower convection ( Constantino et al., 2021 ) . Others suggest that slower rotators undergo additional mixing and Li depletion after their radiative cores have developed, as a result of angular momentum loss and consequent core-envelope decoupling ( Bouvier, 2008 ) , or that faster rotators have less effective convective overshooting into the core ( Baraffe et al., 2017 ) . The solution to this PMS Li-depletion problem is important in understanding the complex interiors of stars, not only in the PMS phase but on the main sequence too. Ongoing mixing is required to explain why the Sun and other cool stars are heavily Li-depleted; ZAMS Li abundances provide the approximate starting point for those processes. Understanding the dispersion is also important in: interpreting a similar Li abundance scatter in older stars in the field and in clusters, where their rotational history may be important; using lithium to identify young stars or as an age indicator; and interpreting Li abundances in the context, and as a probe, of Galactic chemical evolution ( Guiglion et al., 2016 ; Gutiérrez Albarrán et al., 2020 ; Romano et al., 2021 ; Jeffries et al., 2023a ; Saad et al., 2024 , e.g,) . In this paper, we attempt to put observational constraints on the potential mechanisms that drive the Li dispersion by identifying the age at which the scatter appears and the timescale on which it develops on the PMS. Previous heterogeneous studies of individual clusters and associations have suggested that the rotation-dependent spread is already established at 45-60 Myr 1 1 1 See Jeffries, Jackson & Binks (2023b) and references therein on the ages of these clusters. in the IC 2391/2602 clusters ( Randich et al., 2001 ) , is probably present in NGC 2547 at an age of 35-40 Myr ( Binks et al., 2022 ) and at ages of 20-25 Myr in the Beta Pic association ( Messina et al., 2016 ) , and possibly even as early as \sim 5 Myr in NGC 2264 ( Bouvier et al., 2016 ) . Here, we extend these studies by providing an analysis of a homogeneous dataset of EW Li / T_{\rm eff} measurements for thousands of stars in young clusters with well-determined relative ages and secure membership, which were observed as part of the Gaia -ESO spectroscopic survey (GES). In § 2 the observational sample is