Spin decoherence in molecular crystals: nuclear v.s. electronic spin baths
Conor Ryan, Valerio Briganti, Cathal Hogan, Mark O’Neill, Alessandro Lunghi · 2025
Read Spin decoherence in molecular crystals: nuclear v.s. electronic spin baths by Conor Ryan, Valerio Briganti, Cathal Hogan, Mark O’Neill, Alessandro Lunghi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18254.txt.
Introduction
Conor Ryan, Valerio Briganti, Cathal Hogan, Mark O'Neill, and Alessandro Lunghi ask what steals coherence from electron spins in molecular crystals. Decoherence, the loss of phase between two quantum states, blurs spectroscopy and limits the use of molecules as quantum bits. At low heat, the damage can come from other electron spins or from nuclear spins, and which one dominates has been unclear.
Using a cluster-correlation method, the team simulated two typical molecular qubits. Nuclear spins take over as the main source only when electron spins fall below one millimolar in strength. Samples with hydrogen swapped for deuterium could reach coherence times of a tenth of a millisecond, and even hydrogen-rich crystals could reach ten milliseconds with pulse tricks.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Conor Ryan, Valerio Briganti, Cathal Hogan, Mark O’Neill, Alessandro Lunghi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18254
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Spin decoherence in molecular crystals: nuclear v.s. electronic spin baths Conor Ryan, Valerio Briganti, Cathal Hogan, Mark O’Neill, Alessandro Lunghi Abstract The loss of information about the relative phase between two quantum states, known as decoherence, strongly limits resolution in electron paramagnetic spectroscopy and hampers the use of molecules for quantum information processing. At low temperatures, the decoherence of an electronic molecular spin can be driven by its interaction with either other electron spins or nuclear spins. Many experimental techniques have been used to prolong the coherence time of molecular qubits, but these efforts have been hampered by the uncertainty about which of the two mechanisms is effectively limiting coherence in different experimental conditions. Here, we use the Cluster-Correlation Expansion (CCE) to simulate the decoherence of two prototypical molecular qubits and quantitatively demonstrate that nuclear spins become the leading source of decoherence only when the electron spin concentration is below ∼ \sim 1 mM. Moreover, we show that deuterated samples, much easier to achieve than fully spin-free environments, could achieve record coherence times of ∼ \sim 0.1 ms for an electron spin concentration of ∼ \sim 0.1 mM. Alternatively, hydrogen-rich molecular crystals with electron spins concentration below 1 mM can still achieve coherence times of 10 ms through dynamical decoupling, showing that the potential of molecular spins for quantum technologies is still untapped. Introduction Magnetic molecules with a doublet ground state ( S=1/2 ), either originating from organic radicals or coordination compounds, have long been used as probes of their unpaired electron’s environment and more recently have surged as promising building blocks for quantum technology 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 . This promise is highlighted through properties such as the ability to control the qubits’ properties by tuning the chemical nature of its magnetic environment and the potential to synthesize many identical molecular qubits and deposit them in ordered arrays 5 , 6 . An integral feature of spin qubits is their coherence time, denoted by T_{2} , which governs how long the molecular spin will retain its quantum behavior and, therefore, can have quantum operations performed on it during, for instance, computation or signal detection in sensing. Often, T_{2} is decomposed in terms of two different contributions: the spin relaxation time, T_{1} , and pure dephasing time, T_{2}^{*} . According to perturbation theory arguments 7 , 8 , all these quantities are related as \frac{1}{T_{2}}=\frac{1}{2T_{1}}+\frac{1}{T^{*}_{2}}\>. (1) Generally speaking, T_{1} is the time the spin needs to reach its equilibrium state by exchanging energy with a surrounding bath, while T_{2}^{*} describes the loss of phase coherence among identical spins in an ensemble due to perceiving a different dynamically changing environment. Static inhomogeneous contributions to T_{2} are here neglected as they can be easily removed with a simple Hahn-Echo pulse sequence 9 , 7 and do not pose particular challenges. At high temperatures, often already above 10-20 K, spin-phonon interactions are the leading cause of decoherence in solid-state spin systems, be they color centers like NV centers 10 , 8 and vacancies in h-BN 11 , 12 , impurities such as P-doped Si 13 , 14 , or molecular qubits 15 , 16 , 17 . At the microscopic level, this interaction arises from the modulation of the electronic structure defining the qubit by lattice vibrations and is made possible by spin-orbit coupling. Spin-phonon coupling has been the focus of intense research in recent years 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , and its contribution to both T_{1} and T_{2}^{*} is now largely established 8 , 22 , 23 . On the other hand, at low temperatures, where the phonon population eventually vanishes, spin-phonon decoherence is suppressed, and T_{2} becomes dominated by spin-spin dynamics 24 . The latter originates from the interaction of the qubit’s spin moment with other electronic spins, often other equivalent spin qubits present in the surrounding environment, or nuclear spins. The latter interaction is generally considered as prominent in molecular qubits, where hydrogen atoms, with their large nuclear spin gyromagnetic factor, are commonly present in the qubit’s structure itself and its solid-state matrix. Several successful strategies have been employed to date to counteract spin-spin decoherence. For instance, dynamical decoupling has been used in a few instances to enhance T_{2} by systematically refocusing spins precessing at different rates and thus subject to pure dephasing 25 , 26 , 27 . The engineering of spin state properties, such as introducing clock transitions 28 , 29 , is another possible strategy employed in recent years to protect coherence from magnetic noise. Finally, chemical principles have also been employed in the attempt to dilute the spin bath as much as possible. This is relatively easy to perform for the electronic spin bath by diluting qubits in a solid-state diamagnetic host or frozen solutions. Removing nuclear spins is also possible 15 , 16 , but at the cost of drastically reducing the type of organic ligands that can be possibly used to assemble magnetic molecules. As a compromise, the substitution of hydrogen for deuterium, which bears a much smaller gyromagnetic factor, is a commonly employed strategy 25 . Despite the abundant evidence that dilution strategies work, a systematic study on the role of both electronic and nuclear spin baths is currently lacking, and incongruous reports on the value of T_{2} in different spin environments are present in the literature. For instance, the works of Bader et al. 15 and Zadrozny et al. 16 both report molecular qubits based on hydrogen-free coordination compounds, but found starkly different values of T_{2} for deuterated molecular environments, 68 \mu s and 8 \mu s, respectively. Similarly, the work of de Camargo et al. 30 reported a molecular qubit in deuterated frozen solvent to have a T_{2} of about 10-40 \mu s, which is surprisingly longer than what was observed by Zadrozny et al. 16 for a hydrogen-free molecular qubit. To complicate the matter, all these experiments are performed at different molecular spin concentrations, which may vary from \sim 45 mM 31 to 0.01 mM 16 . On this last regard, while experimental studies often comment on the innocence of electronic spin baths in their respective operating conditions 16 , systematic evidence for such claims is often not available, and a theoretical study suggested the opposite 32 , with interactions between the qubit and its electronic spin bath predicted to be driving spin decoherence for concentrations down to \sim 0.5 mM. This state of affairs obscures the true nature of the mechanism that leads spin decoherence at low temperatures, severely impacting our ability to judge the real value of different strategies for improving T_{2} , and ultimately precluding us from maximizing spin coherence. Theory and computational modeling can play a key role in solving these ambiguities. Here we build on the corpus of literature employing Cluster-Correlation Expansion (CCE) methods 33 and similar approaches to tackle the problem of simulating spin decoherence 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 . Unlike previous reports 40 , 35 , 36 , here we simulate on the same footing the effect of both electron and nuclear spin baths over the coherence of molecular spins. We perform our study for two prototypical molecular qubits with