SecCityVR: Visualization and Collaborative Exploration of Software Vulnerabilities in Virtual Reality Conference: The 29th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering; 17–20 June, 2025; Istanbul, Türkiye CCS: Human-centered computing Visualization systems and tools

Dennis Wüppelmann, Enes Yigitbas · 2025

Read SecCityVR: Visualization and Collaborative Exploration of Software Vulnerabilities in Virtual Reality Conference: The 29th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering; 17–20 June, 2025; Istanbul, Türkiye CCS: Human-centered computing Visualization systems and tools by Dennis Wüppelmann, Enes Yigitbas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18238.txt.

Introduction

Dennis Wüppelmann and Enes Yigitbas walk through software flaws as a virtual city, with SecCityVR, a proof-of-concept audit room in virtual reality. Their paper from twenty twenty-five faults flat dashboards for hiding how flaws spread through a codebase. Buildings stand for code parts, colored floors for vulnerabilities. The call graph threads the city together, so each flaw sits among its kin.

Analysts can explore together in real time, a first for this task. Explanations and fixes ride along with each finding. A user study against the find-sec-bugs dashboard favors the city: higher usability, lower time pressure, far less frustration. Tasks did take longer in VR. The authors pitch immersive cities for collaborative security audits.

Catalog record

CREATORDennis Wüppelmann, Enes Yigitbas
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18238

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

SecCityVR: Visualization and Collaborative Exploration of Software Vulnerabilities in Virtual Reality Conference: The 29th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering; 17–20 June, 2025; Istanbul, Türkiye CCS: Human-centered computing Visualization systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative and social computing systems and tools CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality Dennis Wüppelmann, Enes Yigitbas Abstract . Security vulnerabilities in software systems represent significant risks as potential entry points for malicious attacks. Traditional dashboards that display the results of static analysis security testing often use 2D or 3D visualizations, which tend to lack the spatial details required to effectively reveal issues such as the propagation of vulnerabilities across the codebase or the appearance of concurrent vulnerabilities. Additionally, most reporting solutions only treat the analysis results as an artifact that can be reviewed or edited asynchronously by developers, limiting real-time, collaborative exploration. To the best of our knowledge, no VR-based approach exists for the visualization and interactive exploration of software security vulnerabilities. Addressing these challenges, the virtual reality (VR) environment SecCityVR was developed as a proof-of-concept implementation that employs the code city metaphor within VR to visualize software security vulnerabilities as colored building floors inside the surrounding virtual city. By integrating the application’s call graph, vulnerabilities are contextualized within related software components. SecCityVR supports multi-user collaboration and interactive exploration. It provides explanations and mitigations for detected issues. A user study comparing SecCityVR with the traditional dashboard find-sec-bugs showed the VR approach provided a favorable experience, with higher usability (SUS score of 70 to 58.75), lower temporal demand (TLX subscale of 10 to 42.5), and significantly lower frustration (TLX subscale of 17.5 to 52.5) despite having longer task completion times. This paper and its results contribute to the fields of collaborative and secure software engineering, as well as software visualization. It provides a new application of VR code cities to visualize security vulnerabilities, as well as a novel environment for security audits using collaborative and immersive technologies. 1. Introduction Security vulnerabilities are a major risk in software systems, often exploited as entry points for attacks. According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, 90% of security incidents are due to software defects ( Morgan 2015 ) . There are multiple ways to mitigate the risks of security vulnerabilities, like spreading awareness, embedding security checks into the development process, or conducting active security audits. A common place for awareness is the OWASP Top Ten document, which represents a list of the most critical security risks to web applications ( Foundation 2023 ) . Embedding security into the development process often involves tools like Static Analysis Security Testing (SAST), which detects issues without executing the code. SAST can be applied early—even before compilation—and does not require a complete implementation ( Microsoft 2024 ) . A variety of tools support this, including SpotBugs 1 1 1 https://spotbugs.github.io/ , SonarQube 2 2 2 https://www.sonarsource.com/ , and CogniCrypt 3 3 3 https://eclipse.dev/cognicrypt/ , each targeting different aspects like code quality, style, and security vulnerabilities. But with all the development in making the tools increasingly more precise and faster, their results are displayed in overloaded dashboards or aggregations without a connection to the related source code. In these bloated reports, it is hard to grasp the kind of vulnerabilities that are present ( Reynolds et al. 2021 ) . When visualizing code to understand the security impact of a concrete vulnerability, these aggregations are ineffective due to their neglect of most of the codebase’s hierarchy. Two problem statements are derived from this: P_{1} Aggregated visualizations of SAST results do not show detected vulnerabilities in the context of the whole code base. P_{2} Aggregated visualizations of SAST results do not show the possible connections of vulnerable software components to other components. A different way to visualize source code has been studied in recent years. By the use of metaphors like solar systems ( Graham et al. 2004 ) , islands ( Schreiber and Misiak 2018 ) , or cities ( Wettel and Lanza 2007 ) , it is possible to escape the 2D visualizations and visualize the code in a more meaningful way. A commonly used 3D representation is code cities. Using a city metaphor to represent a code base helps the user to comprehend a code base by giving them a sense of locality ( Moreno-Lumbreras et al. 2021 ) . It provides the auditor with a tool to incrementally explore the code, just like they would visit a new city. To create the city, each building represents a single software artifact, e.g., a class. The appearance (height, size, color, texture) of a building can be mapped to metrics suiting the use case of the visualization ( Wettel and Lanza 2007 ) . There have been several studies to explore the application of VR in the field of software visualization and collaborative work on artifacts. Experiments comparing the code city metaphor representation in VR with an on-screen representation indicate that VR is a viable means for software visualization ( Romano et al. 2019 ) . Developers express a need for a way to easily communicate and collaborate when using SAST tools if they work as a team. Currently, if there are collaboration features, they provide asynchronous communication through comments or similar review functionalities ( Johnson et al. 2013 ) . Furthermore, the engagement of developers could be improved through the gamification of software engineering tasks with an interactive software visualization tool in VR ( Merino et al. 2017 ) . This results in the third problem statement: P_{3} Aggregated visualizations of SAST results are not collaborative and engaging. To address the problems, a VR environment named SecCityVR was created. This paper and the development of SecCityVR are guided by the example scenario of a virtual security audit after a vulnerability analysis, where a security professional reviews a Java software repository. The audit focuses on finding the OWASP Top Ten and other known security issues. Together with a developer, they can explore and get an overview of all issues or focus on a high-priority vulnerability and discuss solutions. Additionally, the less specialized developers can use the provided information to learn about different categories of vulnerabilities, the fundamental problems behind them, and ways to prevent them. This leads to the research questions: RQ_{1} How can software vulnerabilities and their impacts on different system components be effectively visualized using VR and the code city metaphor? RQ_{2} To what extent does visualizing software vulnerabilities in a VR code city aid developers in identifying and exploring the affected system components? This paper examines these research questions by conceptually designing, implementing, and evaluating SecCityVR as a proof-of-concept VR environment. It provides a new application of VR code cities to visualize security vulnerabilities and a novel environment for security audits using immersive technologies. Through the usage of collaborative features, together with study participants, we examined a possible multi-user application of this environment. The user study results highlight the benefits of a VR approach, including improved usability, reduced cognitive load, and lower frustration levels, which outweigh the longer task completion times and have significant implications for collaborative and secure software engineering, as well as software visualization. We recommend exploring the novel application of VR in industry software

Read the complete text