Acoustic turbulence: from the Zakharov-Sagdeev spectra to the Kadomtsev-Petviashvili spectrum

E.A. Kochurin, E.A. Kuznetsov · 2025

Read Acoustic turbulence: from the Zakharov-Sagdeev spectra to the Kadomtsev-Petviashvili spectrum by E.A. Kochurin, E.A. Kuznetsov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18174.txt.

Introduction

Kochurin and Kuznetsov present a 2025 review of acoustic turbulence theory and sims. Sound wave turbulence can sit in a weak regime, where waves are small, or a strong one. Two classic camps from the 1960s and 1970s gave unlike spectra for the weak case, and the field lacked firm numeric tests to split them.

Recent direct sims by the review authors back both views in their own domains. One spectrum holds not just for weak positive dispersion but also with no dispersion at all. At low wave numbers the flow forms narrow jets in Fourier space, which broaden as waves shorten. The review pulls the old theory and new numeric proof into one account.

Catalog record

CREATORE.A. Kochurin, E.A. Kuznetsov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18174

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Acoustic turbulence: from the Zakharov-Sagdeev spectra to the Kadomtsev-Petviashvili spectrum E.A. Kochurin, E.A. Kuznetsov Abstract This paper presents a brief review on theoretical and numerical works on three-dimensional acoustic turbulence both in a weakly nonlinear regime, when the amplitudes of sound waves are small, and in the case of strong nonlinearity. This review is based on the classical studies on weak acoustic turbulence by V.E. Zakharov (1965) and V.E. Zakharov and R.Z. Sagdeev (1970), on the one hand, and on the other hand, by B.B. Kadomtsev and V.I. Petviashvili (1972). Until recently, there were no convincing numerical experiments confirming one or the other point of view. In the works of the authors of this review in 2022 and 2024, strong arguments were found based on direct numerical modeling in favor of both theories. It is shown that the Zakharov-Sagdeev spectrum of weak turbulence ∝ k − 3 / 2 \propto k^{-3/2} is realized not only for small positive dispersion of sound waves, but also in the case of complete absence of dispersion. The calculated turbulence spectra in the weakly nonlinear regime have anisotropic distribution: for small k k , narrow cones (jets) are formed, broadening in the Fourier space. For weak dispersion, the jets are smoothed out, and the turbulence spectrum tends to be isotropic in the region of short wavelengths. In the absence of dispersion, the turbulence spectrum is a discrete set of jets subjected to diffraction divergence. For each individual jet, nonlinear effects are much weaker than diffraction ones, which prevents the formation of shock waves. Thus, the weakly turbulent Zakharov-Sagdeev spectrum is realized due to the smallness of nonlinear effects compared to dispersion or diffraction. As the pumping level increases in the non-dispersive regime, when nonlinear effects begin to dominate, shock waves are formed. As a result, acoustic turbulence passes into a strongly nonlinear state in the form of an ensemble of random shocks described by the Kadomtsev-Petviashvili spectrum ∝ k − 2 \propto k^{-2} . Introduction As is known, developed hydrodynamic turbulence at large Reynolds numbers, Re\gg 1 , in the inertial interval is an example of a system with strong nonlinearity, when its energy coincides with the interaction Hamiltonian. Another classic example is acoustic turbulence, which exhibits both strong and weak regimes depending on the ratio of nonlinearity and linear wave characteristics. In this sense, acoustic turbulence is much more diverse and richer than hydrodynamic turbulence. When the nonlinear interaction of waves is small compared to linear effects, a weak turbulence regime KZ-book is realized, which can be studied on the basis of perturbation theory using the random phase approximation. The theory of weak turbulence KZ-book ; naz-book statistically describes ensembles of interacting waves within the framework of the corresponding kinetic equations KZ-book ; naz-book . This theory assumes that each wave with its random phase propagates almost freely for a long time and very rarely undergoes small deformations due to nonlinear interaction with other waves. To date, the theory of weak turbulence has found many applications, ranging from ocean and plasma waves, waves in solid state physics, in Bose-Einstein condensates and ending with turbulence in both astrophysics and high-energy physics. Here we will cite only some of the latest works on this topic: Naz22 ; ShavitFalkovich ; FrahmShepelyansky ; Semisalov ; Galtier1 ; grav ; Galtier ; Shuryak . It should be noted that for waves on the surface of a liquid, both capillary and gravitational (dispersive waves), the theory of weak turbulence has been confirmed with very high accuracy FM . However, for acoustic turbulence, a sufficiently complete understanding has not been yet. This is due to two different approaches to the study of acoustic turbulence. The first works on this topic were carried out by V.E. Zakharov in 1965 zakh65 , and then in 1970 by V.E. Zakharov and R.Z. Sagdeev zs-70 based on the theory of weak turbulence. As a result, in the region of weak positive dispersion, a scale-invariant turbulence spectrum E(k)\propto k^{-3/2} was found, called the Zakharov-Sagdeev spectrum. This spectrum was an exact solution in the long-wave limit of the stationary kinetic equation for waves, proportional to the square root of the energy flux \epsilon into the region of short wavelengths. In 1972, B.B. Kadomtsev and V.I. Petviashvili KP proposed their spectrum, which is now called the Kadomtsev-Petviashvili spectrum, which has a different dependence E(k)\propto k^{-2} . According to KP , acoustic turbulence was considered as an ensemble of random shock waves. Shock waves arise as a result of the breaking of sound waves of finite amplitude. The k^{-2} dependence is due to density jumps. Until recently, there was not a single direct numerical experiment in which one or the other spectrum was observed. In this review, based on numerical experiments KochurinKuznetsov1 , KochurinKuznetsov2 , it will be shown what are the criteria for the emergence of the Zakharov-Sagdeev and Kadomtsev-Petviashvili spectra. In both cases, for small but finite amplitudes, the main nonlinear process is the three-wave interaction, which is resonant when the synchronism conditions are met \omega(\mathbf{k})=\omega(\mathbf{k_{1}})+\omega(\mathbf{k_{2}}),\quad\mathbf{k}=\mathbf{k_{1}}+\mathbf{k_{2}} (1) where \omega=\omega(\mathbf{k}) is the dispersion law of linear waves. If \omega(\mathbf{k})=kc_{s} , where c_{s} is the speed of sound, then these relations are obviously satisfied only for parallel wave vectors \mathbf{k_{i}} . Thus, a triplet of interacting waves forms a ray in k -space. Obviously, the transition to a coordinate system moving with the velocity c_{s} along a separate ray makes this wave system strongly nonlinear. In one-dimensional gas dynamics, this nonlinearity leads to the breaking of acoustic waves in accordance with the famous Riemann solution. In the multidimensional case, the transition to a moving coordinate system with the velocity c_{s} is possible only for one given ray; for all other rays propagating at certain angles, such a transition is not correct. A set of continuously distributed beams with close angles of wave propagation forms an acoustic beam, which, as is known, is subject to diffraction in the transverse direction. For any small but finite transverse beam width, the phenomenon of diffraction divergence will inevitably arise. This effect was first discussed in the original paper by Zakharov and Sagdeev zs-70 ; at almost the same time, similar ideas were developed in the work of Newell (see also AT ). From these considerations it follows that the regime of weak turbulence for acoustic waves can be realized not only in the case of weak dispersion, but also in a dispersion-free situation due to the diffraction divergence of the wave beam. It should be noted that the resonance conditions ( 1 ) are also satisfied for acoustic waves with weak positive dispersion, when \omega=kc_{s}(1+a^{2}k^{2}),\quad(a^{2}k^{2}\ll 1), (2) where a is the dispersion parameter, which has the dimension of length. In the weakly dispersive case, the interacting waves form cones with small angles \sim(ak)^{2} instead of rays. In the case of small nonlinear effects compared to the dispersion of the waves, a weakly turbulent regime of the evolution of sound waves can be realized. For this case, the exact isotropic solution of the kinetic equation for three-dimensional weak acoustic turbulence, obtained in zakh65 ; zs-70 , has the form E(k)=C_{KZ}\left(\rho c_{s}\epsilon\right)^{1/2}k^{-3/2}, (3) where C_{KZ} is the dimensionless Kolmogorov-Zakharov constant, \rho is the equilibrium gas

Read the complete text