A Directional Measure of Marginal Inhomogeneity for Square Contingency Tables using Discrete-time hazard

Jun Tamura, Satoru Shinoda · 2025

Read A Directional Measure of Marginal Inhomogeneity for Square Contingency Tables using Discrete-time hazard by Jun Tamura, Satoru Shinoda (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-18100.txt.

Introduction

Jun Tamura and Satoru Shinoda propose a new measure for square tables of paired ratings, in a 2025 statistics paper. Such tables arise when the same scale is applied twice, for example before and after treatment. Analysts often ask whether the row and column margins match, a property called marginal homogeneity, and how far they depart when they do not.

Their measure treats the categories as time points and borrows the hazard, a tool from survival analysis. It captures both the size and the direction of the departure on a scale from minus one to one. They derive an estimator and a confidence interval, and discuss the measure's properties.

Catalog record

CREATORJun Tamura, Satoru Shinoda
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-18100

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Directional Measure of Marginal Inhomogeneity for Square Contingency Tables using Discrete-time hazard Jun Tamura, Satoru Shinoda Abstract In the analysis of square contingency tables with ordered categories, it is essential to assess deviations from marginal homogeneity (MH) when marginal equivalency between row and column variables does not hold. Some measures for evaluating the degree of departure from the MH model have been proposed. This study proposes a new directional measure using the discrete-time hazard, assuming that categories represent discrete time points. The proposed measure is capable of capturing both the magnitude and direction of deviation from the MH model. It is defined on a continuous scale from − 1 -1 to 1 1 , which allows for intuitive interpretation of the nature of marginal change. An estimator of the proposed measure and an asymptotic confidence interval are derived using the delta method. The theoretical properties of the measure are also discussed. The proposed measure provides a flexible tool for characterizing marginal inhomogeneity in square contingency tables under ordinal settings. Keywords: Continuation Odds, Discrete-time Hazard, Ordinal Category, Square Contingency Table, Statistical Inference Correspondence: Author Name: Jun Tamura Institution: Graduate School of Medicine, Yokohama City University, Japan Address: 3-9 Fukuura, Kanazawa-ku, Yokohama 236-0004, Japan Email: [email protected] 1 Introduction In clinical research, it is essential to determine whether treatment effects improve or worsen over time compared to pre-intervention conditions. Traditional evaluation methods often rely on continuous variables, assessing effectiveness by calculating differences between pre- and post-intervention measures. However, continuous evaluation may not always be practical in real-world settings. For instance, Francom et al. [ 1 ] categorized sleep onset times into discrete ordinal categories before and after a two-week treatment period, comparing active sleep medication and placebo groups (Table 1 ). This approach highlights the challenges of using continuous variables to assess treatment effects when responses are collected in discrete ordinal categories. In their study, subjects receiving the two treatments were treated as independent samples, simplifying the analysis but not accounting for potential within-subject variability. The primary objective was to evaluate whether sleep onset times improved or worsened post-intervention and to compare the effects between the two groups. These examples illustrate that, in clinical research, outcomes of interest are frequently observed in discrete ordinal categories [ 12 , 9 , 11 ] . The ordinal nature of such data poses significant challenges for applying conventional methods that rely on continuous variables, necessitating alternative approaches tailored to discrete data analysis. In square contingency tables where row and column variables share the same ordinal categories, such as Table 1 , observed values often cluster along the main diagonal. This clustering reflects the tendency of responses to remain consistent across pre- and post-intervention conditions, a common feature in ordinal data. This structure highlights the relevance of assessing the marginal distributions’ equivalency rather than independence between rows and columns. The Marginal Homogeneity (MH) model, introduced by Stuart [ 2 ] , is commonly used to evaluate the equivalency of marginal distributions. However, when the interest lies in the direction and magnitude of changes—such as pre- to post-intervention effects—quantifying deviations from marginal homogeneity becomes critical. Several measures for deviations from the MH model have been proposed [ 8 , 6 , 7 ] . These measures primarily aim to quantify the extent to which marginal distributions retain uniformity or deviate from it. Additionally, to represent structures deviating from marginal equivalency in greater detail, Shinoda et al. [ 3 ] proposed the Marginal Continuation Odds Ratio (MCOR) model. This model uses marginal continuation odds to capture changes in distributions before and after intervention. It is particularly useful for evaluating the direction and magnitude of shifts observed pre- and post-intervention. Similarly, Ando et al. [ 4 ] proposed a measure of deviation from the MH model that corresponds to MCOR model, providing valuable insights into treatment effects. However, their measure is limited to a 0 – 1 scale, which does not capture the direction of location shifts. To address this limitation, we propose a novel measure for evaluating deviations from marginal equivalency, designed to correspond to discrete-time hazards while also indicating the direction of shifts. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. Section 2 provides an overview of the basic models and scales for square contingency tables with ordinal categories. Section 3 introduces the proposed measure and its theoretical properties. Section 4 outlines the methodology for constructing asymptotic confidence intervals for the proposed measure. Section 5 present real-world data analysis to validate the methodology. Finally, the paper concludes with a summary of the findings and a discussion of potential applications and future research directions. Active Sleep Medication Group Placebo Group Pre-intervention Post-intervention Total Pre-intervention Post-intervention Total <20 20-30 30-60 >60 <20 20-30 30-60 >60 <20 7 4 1 0 12 <20 7 4 2 1 14 20-30 11 5 2 2 20 20-30 14 5 1 0 20 30-60 13 23 3 1 40 30-60 6 9 18 2 35 >60 9 17 13 8 47 >60 4 11 14 22 51 Total 40 49 19 11 119 Total 31 29 35 25 120 Table 1: Comparison of Active Sleeping Medication and Placebo Groups 2 Contingency Table Analysis In this section, we introduce models and measures important for analyzing r\times r square contingency tables. Section 2.1 explains the structure of the MH model and MCOR model using mathematical formulas. Section 2.2 describes the definition and properties of the measure proposed by Ando et al. [ 4 ] . 2.1 Model 2.1.1 MH Model Let the joint probability of the row variable X=i and the column variable Y=j be denoted as \Pr(X=i,Y=j)=p_{ij} , where i=1,\dots,r and j=1,\dots,r . The MH model can be expressed in various forms. For instance, the MH model can be defined in terms of cell probabilities as follows: p_{i\cdot}=p_{\cdot i},\quad i=1,\dots,r, where p_{i\cdot}=\sum_{t=1}^{r}p_{it} and p_{\cdot i}=\sum_{s=1}^{r}p_{si} . For further details on the MH model, refer to Stuart [ 2 ] and Bishop et al. [ 5 ] . The MH model indicates that the marginal distributions of the row and column variables are identical. The MH model admits several equivalent representations. In particular, when the categories are ordered, the formulation using continuation odds provides an insightful characterization: \omega_{i}^{X}=\omega_{i}^{Y},\quad i=1,\dots,r-1, where \omega_{i}^{X}=\frac{p_{i\cdot}}{1-F_{i-1}^{X}}=\Pr(X=i\mid X\geq i),\quad\omega_{i}^{Y}=\frac{p_{\cdot i}}{1-F_{i-1}^{Y}}=\Pr(Y=i\mid Y\geq i), and F_{i}^{X}=\sum_{k=1}^{i}p_{k\cdot} , F_{i}^{Y}=\sum_{k=1}^{i}p_{\cdot k} denote the cumulative marginal probabilities for X and Y , respectively. This equivalence also implies that the conditional probability of being in a lower category given survival beyond a higher one—i.e., \Pr(X\leq i\mid X\geq i+1) and \Pr(Y\leq i\mid Y\geq i+1) —is the same for both variables. In the context of square contingency tables where the categories represent discrete-time survival, the row variable’s discrete-time survival probability can be expressed as: s_{i}^{X}=\sum_{k=i}^{r}p_{k\cdot}=\Pr(X\geq i)=1-F_{i-1}^{X},\quad i=1,\dots,r-1. Thus, the row variable’s discrete-time hazard function can be written as: 1-\frac{s_{i+1}^{X}}{s_{i}^{X}}=\frac{p_{i\cdot}}{s_{i}^{X}}=\Pr(X=i\mid X\geq i)=\omega_{i}^{X},\quad i=1,\dots,r-1. Similarly, the column variable’s discrete-time survival probability and hazard function can be defined analogously. Therefore, the discrete-time hazard \omega_{i}^{X} and \omega_{i}^{Y} can be interpreted as the discrete-time hazard functions for the row and column variables, respectively. 2.1.2 MCOR model In cases where the MH model does not hold, applying models of marginal inhomogeneity may be of interest. This is because, if such models fit the dataset

Read the complete text