Eliashberg theory prediction of critical currents in superconducting thin films under DC electric fields
Giovanni Alberto Ummarino 1,2 , Alessio Zaccone 3,4 , Alessandro Braggio 5 , and Francesco Giazotto 5 · 2025
Read Eliashberg theory prediction of critical currents in superconducting thin films under DC electric fields by Giovanni Alberto Ummarino 1,2 , Alessio Zaccone 3,4 , Alessandro Braggio 5 , and Francesco Giazotto 5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17893.txt.
Introduction
Ummarino and co-authors predict how an electric field can throttle current in superconducting films, in a 2025 theory paper. Thin films whose supercurrent answers to a gate field could become transistors for quantum electronics. The mechanism behind the effect lacked a quantitative microscopic account. Working with niobium nitride, the team apply Eliashberg theory in the dirty limit, with no adjustable parameters.
Their analysis ties the critical current to the kinetic energy of the Cooper pairs that carry it. Current first rises with that energy, then pair-breaking wins and current falls, giving a peak. From the peak they estimate the field needed to kill superconductivity, matching experiments without fitting. Disorder softens the temperature pattern yet raises the raw field required, a trade-off device designers can use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giovanni Alberto Ummarino 1,2 , Alessio Zaccone 3,4 , Alessandro Braggio 5 , and Francesco Giazotto 5 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17893
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Eliashberg theory prediction of critical currents in superconducting thin films under DC electric fields Giovanni Alberto Ummarino 1,2 , Alessio Zaccone 3,4 , Alessandro Braggio 5 , and Francesco Giazotto 5 Abstract Superconducting thin metallic films, functioning as supercurrent gate-tunable transistors, have considerable potential for future quantum electronic devices. Despite extensive research, a comprehensive microscopic quantitative mechanism that elucidates the control or suppression of supercurrents in thin films remains elusive. Focusing on NbN, a prototypical material, and starting from a phenomenological ansatz that links the critical electric field with the kinetic energy parameter needed to break Cooper pairs, we provide a quantitative analysis of the critical current using Eliashberg theory in the dirty limit without adjustable parameters. The critical kinetic energy value is identified, corresponding to the maximum supercurrent that can flow in the thin film. The peak in supercurrent density as a function of the Cooper pairs’ kinetic energy arises from the interplay between the increase in supercurrent due to increased kinetic energy and the depairing effect when the kinetic energy becomes sufficiently large. The critical value of the pair’s kinetic energy is subsequently employed to estimate the critical value of an external electric field required to suppress superconductivity in the sample. This estimation is in parameter-free agreement with the experimental observations. Although the disorder reduces the temperature dependence of the gating effect on the critical current, at the same time, it increases the unscreened critical electric field needed to suppress superconductivity. This enables the proposal of methods to control and reduce the critical field value necessary to suppress superconductivity in superconducting electronics. I Introduction In metallic substances, the effect of an electric field is usually considered negligible because of the high density of charge carriers and the strong screening effects. Nevertheless, recent experimental findings suggest that, in superconducting materials, a sufficiently strong electric field applied in proximity to a superconducting bridge could gradually reduce the critical current of the superconducting channels. This suppression of superconductivity induced by an electric field has been observed in a variety of superconducting materials [ 1 ] , primarily metallic ones, such as titanium transistor-like devices [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] and aluminum nanodevices [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . In particular, this effect has also been reported without direct current flow from the gates to the superconducting channels [ 4 , 8 ] . Furthermore, the influence of electric fields on superconductivity has been a subject of scientific inquiry since 1960s [ 9 ] . However, the theoretical justification for specific observations [ 10 ] and the prediction of additional observable phenomena have been formulated only in recent years [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 16 , 17 ] . The critical current density J_{c} , in conjunction with the critical temperature T_{c} and the upper critical field B_{c2} , is an intrinsic critical parameter that fundamentally confines the endurance of superconductivity. Although T_{c} and B_{c2} are relatively straightforward to measure, J_{c} is rarely assessed due to the technical challenges of heating the sample at high currents. The depairing or pair-breaking current has been derived within the Ginzburg-Landau theoretical framework, illustrating a temperature-dependent variation of the critical current density J_{c}(T) , particularly near the critical temperature T_{c} , expressed as J_{c}(T)=J_{0}(1-T/T_{c})^{3/2} , where J_{0} signifies an impurity-dependent coefficient [ 18 ] . This research concentrates on the critical current in thin films of thickness L , as comprehending the bulk critical current density requires understanding the flux lattice pinning and intricate material considerations. Conversely, this geometric configuration is more relevant for addressing matters related to the foundational superconducting state and can be used in experimental critical current experiments. Consequently, the conclusions are more general. We determine the critical current density J_{c}(T) for a thin film of thickness L that is comparable to the coherence length \xi_{0} and the magnetic penetration depth \lambda_{M} , i.e., L\leq\xi_{0}<\lambda_{M} . We assume that the superconductor is in the dirty limit ( \ell\ll\xi_{0} ) where \ell is the mean free path, well within the framework of Eliashberg theory [ 19 , 26 ] of strong-coupling superconductivity, which is well adapted to describe NbN superconducting thin films. We will establish a connection between J_{c}(T) and the screened critical value E_{cr}(T) required to suppress the superconductivity. The connection with the externally applied electric field E_{cr,ex}(T) needed to suppress the superconductivity in the thin film can be obtained following the discussion of Ref. [ 18 ] . Eliashberg’s theory has adeptly accounted for the deviations in superconducting properties of actual materials from the universal predictions of BCS theory. This theoretical framework is dependent on two primary variables: the electron-phonon spectral function \alpha^{2}F(\Omega) , which can be measured through tunneling experiments or calculated from the first principles, and the Coulomb pseudopotential \mu^{*}(\omega_{c}) , whereby \omega_{c} serves as a cut-off energy ( \omega_{c}\geq 3\Omega_{max} , \Omega_{max} denotes the maximum phonon energy). The Coulomb pseudopotential \mu^{*}(\omega_{c}) can be obtained indirectly through tunneling experiments or, albeit with difficulty, calculated from first principles; however, it is generally treated as a free parameter, approximately spanning between the limits described in [ 19 , 26 ] and 0.1-0.3 . Once these two parameters are established, all other superconducting properties can be computed, and for conventional superconductors, all computed physical observables exhibit perfect concordance with experimental results [ 19 , 26 ] . Using this approach, we can compute the critical current as a temperature- and impurity-content (disorder) function with a parameter-free theory. In a previous paper [ 28 ] , we examined the same problem from a different angle: i.e., the suppression of superconductivity by an external electrostatic field. That theoretical model [ 28 ] treats the Cooper pair as an s-wave bound state, which is subjected to a small but non-vanishing electric field at a surface layer of thickness \lambda_{E} quite comparable with the same metallic film layer. Using the Schrödinger equation solution for s-wave bound state dissociation through electric-field-assisted tunneling, an expression for the critical electric field magnitude inside the thin film layer is calculated to break the Cooper pairs, thus suppressing superconductivity. This screened critical electric field E_{cr} is proportional to the ratio between the value of the superconducting energy gap \Delta(T) , calculated with Eliashberg theory, and the effective coherence length \xi(T) which is associated with the average size of the Cooper pair that lives in a strong inhomogeneous electric field on the metal surface. In this paper [ 28 ] , we also calculated that this critical electric field E_{cr} is connected to the external (non-screened) critical electric field E_{cr,ex} . We used an empirical input from the experiments of Piatti et al. [ 29 ] , for the same example of NbN thin films discussed above. According to that reference, the penetration depth of the electric field into NbN superconducting thin films is significantly greater than what is predicted by Thomas-Fermi estimates and other standard screening theories of (normal) metals, which typically measure just a few angstroms in the range from 0.5 to 3 nm. The purpose of this paper is to establish a phenomenological relationship between the critical supercurrent density J_{c} that the material can host and the critical value of