Target-Date Funds: A State-of-the-Art Review with Policy Applications to Chile’s Pension Reform
Fernando Suárez, José Manuel Peña, Omar Larré · 2025
Read Target-Date Funds: A State-of-the-Art Review with Policy Applications to Chile’s Pension Reform by Fernando Suárez, José Manuel Peña, Omar Larré (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17713.txt.
Introduction
Fernando Suarez, Jose Manuel Pena, and Omar Larre review target-date funds and advise Chile's pension reform on taking them up, in work from 2025. Target-date funds shift savings toward safer assets on their own as the saver nears the end of work life. Chile's reform swaps its old multi-fund habit for them. The theory and practice of glide paths, the preset slide toward safety, are surveyed in depth. Hurdles for regulators and managers get close attention throughout.
The glide path, they argue, should respond to total wealth as it changes. Risk tolerance should bend the path for each saver. A wide band around the standard mix of assets is proposed. That room would spur rivalry in strategy among fund managers. Other kinds of assets and wider spread would gain space to grow. A glide path model shaped for Chile remains future work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Fernando Suárez, José Manuel Peña, Omar Larré |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17713
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Target-Date Funds: A State-of-the-Art Review with Policy Applications to Chile’s Pension Reform Fernando Suárez, José Manuel Peña, Omar Larré Abstract This review paper explores the evolution and implementation of target-date funds (TDFs), specifically focusing on their application within the context of Chile’s 2025 pension reform. The introduction of TDFs marks a significant shift in Chile’s pension system, which has traditionally relied on a multifund structure (essentially a target-risk funds system). We offer a comprehensive review of the theoretical foundations and practical considerations of TDFs, highlighting key challenges and opportunities for Chilean regulators and fund managers. Notably, we recommend that the glide path design should be dynamic, incorporating adjustments based on total accumulated wealth, with particular flexibility depending on each investor’s risk tolerance. Furthermore, we propose that the new benchmark for generational funds should feature a wide deviation band relative to the new benchmark portfolio, which could foster a market with more investment strategies and better competition among fund managers, encourage the inclusion of alternative assets, and foster greater diversification. Lastly, we highlight the need for future work to define a glide path model that incorporates the theoretical frameworks described, tailored to the unique parameters of the Chilean pension system. These recommendations aim to optimize the long-term retirement outcomes for Chilean workers under the new pension structure. 1 Introduction In 1994, Donald Luskin and Larry Tint of Wells Fargo Investment Advisors ( Luskin and Tint 1998 ) introduced the first target-date funds (TDFs) to the asset management industry. These funds, though straightforward, represent a smart approach to long-term investing. The concept is simple: investors commit their capital until a predetermined target date, during which the asset allocation shifts dynamically over time to adjust for the remaining investment horizon. This gradual adjustment in portfolio composition, widely known as the glide path, typically begins with a heavy allocation to riskier assets such as stocks, and then gradually transitions to a portfolio that is more concentrated in less risky instruments, such as bonds ( Estrada 2019b ) , as the investor approaches retirement. Although TDFs have grown immensely in popularity, they are just one example of a broader approach to investing known as life cycle investing. This approach adjusts an individual’s asset allocation as they progress through different life stages, taking into account factors such as age, financial goals, and risk tolerance. Life cycle investments are thus designed to ensure that the portfolio remains aligned with the investor’s changing needs. The theoretical foundation for these strategies, which predates their modern application, can be traced back to Samuelson 1969 and Merton 1969 , who extended the static portfolio theory of Markowitz 1952 by introducing dynamic programming models and calculus of variations techniques. This innovation enabled the determination of an optimal, evolving asset allocation over an investor’s lifetime, accounting for path-dependent investment and consumption decisions. Despite their solid theoretical foundation, life cycle funds only began gaining significant traction after the Pension Protection Act of 2006, which designated them as one of the Qualified Default Investment Alternatives (QDIAs) in U.S. employer-sponsored retirement plans. QDIAs are investment options that plan sponsors can use as default choices for participants who do not actively select an investment, offering a safe harbor under ERISA guidelines ( Martin and Rafsky 2006 ) . Since then, the market for these funds has expanded dramatically, with a greater variety of offerings, increasing assets under management, and declining expense ratios ( Chang and Booth 2023 ; Elton et al. 2015 ) . With this international context established, we turn to Chile. This year, after years of debate, Chile’s Congress passed a comprehensive pension reform ( Ministerio de Hacienda de Chile 2025 ) . Among other changes, the reform introduces target-date funds—referred to as “fondos generacionales”—as the default investment option. Although Chile is not the first Latin American country to incorporate TDFs into its pension system—Mexico adopted them in 2019 ( Comisión Nacional del Sistema de Ahorro para el Retiro 2024 ) —the recent reform leaves key details unresolved. For instance, the specific glide path strategy has yet to be defined, and the responsibility for establishing it falls to the regulator, the Superintendencia de Pensiones. In addition to defining the benchmark glide path, the regulator must also determine the maximum allowable deviations from that benchmark, as well as certain investment limits aimed at mitigating specific portfolio risks. Consequently, both regulators and fund managers now face the challenge of determining the most suitable investment policy for the future target-date pension fund portfolios. Against this backdrop, the aim of this paper is to provide a solid bibliographical foundation and a state-of-the-art overview of life cycle investing and TDFs. By examining lessons learned from these strategies, we hope to offer valuable insights to fund managers and Chilean regulators as they design effective glide path frameworks. The paper is organized into two sections. The first provides a bibliographical review, covering foundational models through to the current state of the target-date fund industry. The second examines Chile’s pension system and investment framework, concluding with a discussion of the critical factors that regulators and fund managers must consider when developing glide path strategies. 2 Literature Review 2.1 Foundations of Life Cycle Investment Theory The theoretical foundations of life cycle investment strategies can be traced back to Samuelson 1969 , who extended Markowitz’s classical portfolio selection theory in 1969 to incorporate multiple time periods. Markowitz’s static framework, which seeks to select the optimal set of assets to maximize returns under risk constraints (often represented by volatility), was adapted by Samuelson to address how optimal portfolio decisions evolve over an individual’s life. Samuelson framed the problem using the Ramsey model ( Ramsey 1928 ) , which is based on maximizing intertemporal utility through an optimal consumption function. In this model, individuals face decisions about how much to consume in each period and how to allocate their wealth between risky and risk-free assets. Samuelson’s life cycle model was formulated as an optimal control problem, solvable using the calculus of variations, with the objective of maximizing the expected utility of consumption over time. More formally, let us define W_{t} as total wealth at time t , C_{t} as the consumption rate at time t , and w_{t} as the proportion of wealth invested in risky assets at time t . Wealth evolves according to the constraint C_{t}=W_{t}-W_{t+1}\left[(1-w_{t})(1+r)+w_{t}Z_{t}\right], where r is the return on the risk-free asset and Z_{t} is the return on the risky asset at time t . Samuelson looked for an optimal policy J such that J=\max_{\{C_{t},w_{t}\}}E\left[\sum_{t=0}^{T}\frac{U(C_{t})}{(1+\rho)^{t}}\right], where U(\cdot) is the utility function and \rho is the discount rate. The model assumes no bequest, that is, W_{T+1}=0 , and the proportion of wealth allocated to risky assets, w_{t} , is limited to lie between 0 and 1. Samuelson’s work was extended by his student, Robert Merton, who introduced a continuous-time version ( Merton 1969 ) and examined portfolio choices under two types of utility functions: Constant Relative Risk Aversion (CRRA) and Constant Absolute Risk Aversion (CARA). In the CRRA case, the portfolio allocation remains constant over time, whereas under CARA, the portfolio exhibits a descending glide path, with a decreasing allocation to risky assets as the investor ages. Merton also introduced a “hump-shaped” savings