Insights from Analytical Theory of Eccentric Circumbinary Disks

Marcela Grcić, Daniel J. D’Orazio, Martin E. Pessah · 2025

Read Insights from Analytical Theory of Eccentric Circumbinary Disks by Marcela Grcić, Daniel J. D’Orazio, Martin E. Pessah (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17658.txt.

Introduction

Marcela Grcic and two co-authors worked out in 2025 a theory of lopsided disks around pairs of stars. Gas circling a star pair can hollow out a center that sits off-center and slowly turns. Such steady states can be read as trapped waves in a bowl-shaped field set by the pair's gravity and the disk's own pressure. One ratio, of pressure pull to gravity pull, rules the wave set.

The team solved the problem at several levels of detail, from sharp-edged disks to smooth ones. Thinner disks and more equal star pairs host more wave modes. For thin disks, the main mode hugs the gravity peak inside the hollow, while thick disks anchor it at the hollow's rim. Their results match computer simulations well, including a halving of rates in three-dimensional disks.

Catalog record

CREATORMarcela Grcić, Daniel J. D’Orazio, Martin E. Pessah
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE98 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17658

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Insights from Analytical Theory of Eccentric Circumbinary Disks Marcela Grcić, Daniel J. D’Orazio, Martin E. Pessah Abstract Eccentric cavities in circumbinary disks precess on timescales much longer than the binary orbital period. These long-lived steady states can be understood as trapped modes in an effective potential primarily determined by the binary quadrupole and the inner-disk pressure support, with associated frequencies ω Q \omega_{Q} and ω P \omega_{P} . Within this framework, we show that the ratio ω P / ω Q \omega_{P}/\omega_{Q} is the main parameter determining the mode spectrum, and obtain a thorough understanding of it by systematically solving this problem with various degrees of sophistication. We first find analytical solutions for truncated power-law disks and use this insight in disks with smooth central cavities. Our main findings are: (i) The number of modes increases for thinner disks and more-equal-mass binaries. (ii) For 2D disks, the normalized ground-mode frequency, ω 0 / ( ω Q + ω P ) \omega_{0}/(\omega_{Q}+\omega_{P}) , decreases monotonically with the ratio ω P / ω Q \omega_{P}/\omega_{Q} . (iii) For thin disks, ω P ≪ ω Q \omega_{P}\ll\omega_{Q} , the ground-mode frequency coincides with the maximum of the effective potential, which tracks the gravitational quadrupole frequency inside the inner-disk cavity, and is thus rather sensitive to the density profile of the cavity, where these modes are localized. (iv) For thick disks, ω P ≫ ω Q \omega_{P}\gg\omega_{Q} , increasing pressure support anchors the peak of the effective potential at the inner cavity radius as the ground-mode extends farther out and its frequency decreases. (v) In agreement with numerical simulations, with ω P / ω Q ≃ 0.1 \omega_{P}/\omega_{Q}\simeq 0.1 , we find that disk precession is rather insensitive to the density profile and ground-mode frequencies for 3D disks are about half the value for 2D disks. I Introduction Gaseous circumbinary disks (CBDs) form in a range of astrophysical scenarios, and can play a large role in binary orbital evolution and electromagnetic emission from such systems. We observe CBDs in the form of gas-rich protostellar disks around young stellar binaries [ 7 , 23 , 9 , 49 , 4 , 10 , 30 ] , which shape stellar binary orbits [ 60 ] and the planets that surround them [ 29 ] . We also expect CBDs around massive black hole binaries (MBHBs), which form as a consequence of galaxy mergers [ 8 ] . If the merging galaxies are gas-rich, an accretion disk may form around the MBHB [ 6 , 5 ] , altering its path towards merger [ 2 , 53 , e.g. ,] and rendering it discoverable in the electromagnetic (EM) spectrum [ 13 ] . The rate-of-change of the binary orbital elements caused by the interaction with a gas disk, and the modulation of EM emission from an accreting binary are both closely connected to the response of the disk to the binary potential. In many scenarios, eccentricity is excited in the CBD. The CBD eccentricity and its precession properties are deeply intertwined with orbital evolution and observational signatures, motivating further investigation of eccentric CBD morphology. Numerical hydrodynamical simulations of 2D and 3D CBDs show that the CBD evolves to an eccentric state over time, even if the binary’s orbit is circular [ 37 , 41 , 21 ] . This leads to several sources of periodic accretion variability that depend on the eccentric disk’s precession frequency, structure, and eccentricity [ 37 , 52 , 17 , 16 , 65 , 44 , e.g. ,] . For eccentric binaries, disk eccentricity can also be excited, and the disk-precession rate relative to the binary eccentricity vector mediates the ratio of mass transfer onto the binary components, allowing preferential accretion, even for equal mass binaries [ 22 , 42 , 54 , 15 ] . Furthermore, the evolution of the binary separation and eccentricity exhibits a change when the disk transitions from a highly eccentric precessing state to a barely eccentric non-precessing state [ 40 , 14 , 54 ] . Similarly, [ 11 ] discuss the effect of the disk aspect ratio and viscosity on torques through changes in the disk morphology and dynamics. [ 61 ] found that slow cooling in the disk can cause the disk cavity to become circular, followed by suppressed accretion variability of the binary, and an increased specific angular momentum transferred from the disk to the binary. To probe the development of this important aspect of circumbinary disk morphology, and to gain further insight into binary-disk dynamics, we employ semi-analytical techniques to investigate the disk eccentricity and precession frequency. Such methods utilize perturbation theory to describe the deviation of thin disks from an axisymmetric state [ 35 , 45 , 26 ] . Such perturbative models provide interpretation of numerical solutions to the full equations of hydrodynamics, and extend beyond the numerically accessible range of parameter space. Previously, a number of works have applied this approach to interpret results from numerical hydrodynamical calculations of the full non-linear fluid flow for CBDs. [ 40 ] used this approach to identify possible causes for a changing disk eccentricity and precession frequency with binary mass ratio and eccentricity. [ 52 ] and [ 54 ] employed such semi-analytical methods to find a good match to the computed disk eccentricity distribution and precession frequency. [ 43 ] carried out a study of locally isothermal CBDs and found that the precession rates derived from the perturbative approach match reasonably well with numerical hydrodynamical simulations, at least in the tested regions of parameter space. Applying the perturbative method for the disk eccentricity to CBDs generally results in a consistent picture. Namely, an eccentric, freely precessing disk is a natural result of a centrally truncated disk density profile [ 43 ] ; the disk is significantly eccentric in its innermost part [ 45 , 26 , 34 , 43 ] ; the binary gravitational potential drives, and the pressure in the disk damps the disk precession frequency; multiple solutions for the disk precession rate and eccentricity are possible in thinner disks [ 34 , 43 ] ; and non-precessing, eccentric disk solutions exist and were observed in numerical simulations [ 47 , 54 , 15 ] . Additionally, [ 36 ] proposes a resonant-like increase in the eccentricity of non-precessing disks around eccentric binaries for suitable values of the disk aspect ratio, but this phenomenon has not yet been seen in numerical hydrodynamical calculations. While perturbative methods have shed light on several aspects of the CBD problem, its applications are somewhat limited. The limitations arise because we require knowledge of the background non-eccentric disk solutions to predict the perturbed eccentric state. Different studies adopt different choices to model the CBD, making systematic comparisons difficult. This in turn complicates the predictive use of the perturbative approach. Choices for the binary model are mostly straightforward, and include the expansion of the binary potential and its parameterization in binary mass ratio, separation, and eccentricity. The disk model, however, can be less straightforward and includes the disk dimension, the gas equation of state, and importantly, a choice for the radial density distribution. Therefore, it is crucial to know how much, and in what way, the

Read the complete text