Are EVs Cleaner Than We Think? Evaluating Consequential Greenhouse Gas Emissions from EV Charging

Riti Bhandarkar, Qian Luo, Emil Dimanchev, Jesse D. Jenkins · 2025

Read Are EVs Cleaner Than We Think? Evaluating Consequential Greenhouse Gas Emissions from EV Charging by Riti Bhandarkar, Qian Luo, Emil Dimanchev, Jesse D. Jenkins (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17632.txt.

Introduction

Riti Bhandarkar and co-authors measure the true climate cost of charging electric cars in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. EVs cut tailpipe emissions, but charging draws power that can add emissions elsewhere. Common yardsticks use past grid data or ignore how the grid itself grows.

Using a capacity expansion model of the western United States grid, the team tracked how mass EV uptake reshapes power plants and storage. Average emission rates could miss the true impact in either direction. Short-run marginal rates understated the savings, above all when charging times flex. Steering charging by those rates could even raise emissions compared with price signals. The authors urge better control strategies.

Catalog record

CREATORRiti Bhandarkar, Qian Luo, Emil Dimanchev, Jesse D. Jenkins
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17632

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Are EVs Cleaner Than We Think? Evaluating Consequential Greenhouse Gas Emissions from EV Charging Riti Bhandarkar, Qian Luo, Emil Dimanchev, Jesse D. Jenkins Abstract While electrifying transportation eliminates tailpipe greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, electric vehicle (EV) adoption can create additional electricity sector emissions. To quantify this emissions impact, prior work typically employs short-run marginal emissions or average emissions rates calculated from historical data or power systems models that do not consider changes in installed capacity. In this work, we use an electricity system capacity expansion model to consider the full consequential GHG emissions impact from large-scale EV adoption in the western United States, accounting for induced changes in generation and storage capacity. We find that the metrics described above do not accurately reflect the true emissions impact of EV adoption–average emissions rates can either under - or over -estimate emission impacts, and short-run marginal emissions rates can significantly underestimate emission reductions, especially when charging timing is flexible. Our results also show that using short-run marginal emission rates as signals to coordinate EV charging could increase emissions relative to price-based charging signals, indicating the need for alternative control strategies to minimize consequential emissions. keywords Electric Vehicles, Power Systems, Marginal Emissions, Consequential Emissions, Demand Response, Macro-Energy Systems † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. 1 Introduction More than 17 million electric vehicles (EV) and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) were sold worldwide in 2024, accounting for more than one in five new light-duty vehicles Parodi 2025 . EV adoption is expected to increase in the coming years as the cost and performance of electric vehicles continue to improve and policies support the phaseout of internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEVs) and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) BloombergNEF 2024 ; International Energy Agency 2024 ; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 2024 . While electrifying transportation eliminates tailpipe GHG emissions, the emissions impact of EV adoption also depends on any induced changes in electricity sector emissions. To elucidate trade-offs and benefits associated with EV adoption, a substantial body of prior work estimates induced power sector emissions or net ‘well-to-wheels’ emissions associated with EV adoption across varying geographies and contexts Choi et al. 2018 ; Chen et al. 2021 ; Gagnon & Cole 2022 ; Vega-Perkins et al. 2023 ; Wu et al. 2024 ; Sharma et al. 2024 ; Singh et al. 2024 . Prior work typically employs one of two metrics to estimate power sector emissions associated with EV charging: average emissions rates or short-run marginal emissions rates (see Table 1 ). For example, a variety of studies estimate the ‘well-to-wheels’ emissions intensity for EVs in different regions across the world using average emissions rates for historical or projected future grids Qiao et al. 2019 ; Andersson & Börjesson 2021 ; Vega-Perkins et al. 2023 ; Wu et al. 2024 . Some studies have compared the emission impact when average and marginal emission factors are used in the analysis and found significant differences when the two metrics are used Tamayao et al. 2015 ; Zhong et al. 2023 . While employing marginal emissions rates, some studies conclude that EV adoption may result in higher GHG emissions than equivalent ICEVs or gasoline hybrids, depending on the location and brand of EVs Vega-Perkins et al. 2023 ; Singh et al. 2024 . Table 1 : Taxonomy of emissions impact metrics Metrics Definition Average emissions rate (AER) Total emissions divided by total electricity supply or consumption. Short-run marginal emissions rate (SR-MER) The emissions change per unit change in electricity consumption, holding the structure of the electrical system (e.g., the generation, storage and network capacity) fixed. Long-run marginal emissions rate (LR-MER) The emissions change per unit change in electricity consumption, accounting for induced changes in both the operation and structure (installed capacity) of the electricity system. Consequential emissions The change in emissions caused by a specific intervention, action, or change in supply or demand. However, it is unlikely that either average or short-run marginal emissions rates reflect the true consequential emissions impact of large-scale adoption of electric vehicles. Average emissions rates reflect the total generation mix of a given region and thus primarily reflect historical capacity decisions while disregarding how that mix will evolve in specific response to changes in demand. Likewise, short-run marginal emissions rates estimate marginal changes in power system emissions in response to small (marginal) changes in electricity demand, accounting only for operational changes in dispatch while holding the structure of the power system constant. Crucially, both metrics neglect how large-scale changes in electricity demand and/or supply affect the structural evolution of the power system, including deployment and retirement of electricity generation, storage, or network capacity. Prior work has demonstrated that omitting these potential structural changes can significantly impact estimates of consequential GHG emissions. Hawkes (2014) found that analyses based on short-run marginal emissions significantly overestimated the emissions impacts of heat pump deployment in the UK Hawkes 2014 . Gagnon and Cole (2022) estimated consequential GHG emissions for a set of 31 different electricity load (demand) shapes and likewise found that long-run marginal emissions accounting for structural changes were substantially lower than short-run marginal emissions rates, while using average emissions rate could both over- and under-estimate total consequential emissions in different cases Gagnon & Cole 2022 . Holland et al. (2022) also conclude that long-run emissions “differ in surprising ways from their short-run analogs.” Holland et al. 2022 Finally, recent work assessing the consequential emissions impact of various clean electricity procurement strategies to meet the demand of new hydrogen electrolysers Ricks et al. 2023 ; Giovanniello et al. 2024 and corporate & industrial demand Xu et al. 2024 ; Riepin & Brown 2024 found substantial differences between expected impacts of short-run marginal emissions-based procurement strategies and the actual consequential impacts when accounting for structural changes. Estimating the consequential emissions impacts of EV adoption is also complicated by the fact that the timing of EV charging may be highly flexible. For example, prior work finds that controlled charging that redistributes charging demand throughout the night during periods of lower average emissions may result in higher short-run marginal emissions in some U.S. regions, as coal-fired generators are often on the operating margin at night Jochem et al. 2015 ; Tamayao et al. 2015 ; McLaren et al. 2016 . Other work finds that shifting demand to day-time hours when solar PV production is curtailed reduces short-run emissions Arvesen et al. 2021 ; Powell et al. 2022 ; Lauvergne et al. 2022 . Furthermore, many studies have recommended rescheduling EV charging based specifically on short-run marginal emission rates, rather than prices, to maximize emission reductions Dixon et al. 2020 ; Tu et al. 2020 ; Huber et al. 2021 ; Pepiciello et al. 2022 ; Chen et al. 2022 ; Wang et al. 2022 ; Kang et al. 2023 ; Li et al. 2023 . One recent study attempts to incorporate some structural change in the grid by optimizing EV charging based on planned investments over a 5-year horizon, using what they term a ”medium-run marginal emissions factor” Powell et al. 2024 . However, this approach still assumes that there is no dynamic interaction between

Read the complete text