Model Choice Matters for Age Inference on the Red Giant Branch
Leslie M. Morales, Jamie Tayar, Zachary R. Claytor · 2025
Read Model Choice Matters for Age Inference on the Red Giant Branch by Leslie M. Morales, Jamie Tayar, Zachary R. Claytor (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17600.txt.
Introduction
Leslie Morales, Jamie Tayar, and Zachary Claytor show that model choice matters when dating red giant stars in work from 2025. Galactic history work needs accurate star ages, and data quality has improved faster than the models used to infer age.
The team compared four widely used evolution grids on the same observations. Without a known star mass, age estimates grew unreliable, with gaps sometimes over eighty percent. Models also disagreed strongly at non-solar composition. The authors present a method to fold model uncertainty into age estimates, aiming to improve accuracy for galactic archaeology.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Leslie M. Morales, Jamie Tayar, Zachary R. Claytor |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17600
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Model Choice Matters for Age Inference on the Red Giant Branch Leslie M. Morales, Jamie Tayar, Zachary R. Claytor Abstract Galactic archaeology relies on accurate stellar parameters to reconstruct the galaxy’s history, including information on stellar ages. While the precision of data has improved significantly in recent years, stellar models used for age inference have not improved at a similar rate. In fact, different models yield notably different age predictions for the same observational data. In this paper, we assess the difference in age predictions of various widely used model grids for stars along the red giant branch. Using open source software, we conduct a comparison of four different evolution grids and we find that age estimations become less reliable if stellar mass is not known, with differences occasionally exceeding 80 % 80\% . Additionally, we note significant disagreements in the models’ age estimations at non-solar metallicity. Finally, we present a method for including theoretical uncertainties from stellar evolutionary tracks in age inferences of red giants, aimed at improving the accuracy of age estimation techniques used in the galactic archaeology community. I Introduction Stellar ages provide valuable insight into a multitude of studies beyond stellar evolution, such as galactic evolution and planet formation. The ages of galactic globular clusters (GCs), for instance, have been used to constrain the formation and early evolution of the Milky Way. The very oldest clusters offer clues to the earliest phases of star formation, while the ages of old, but non-primordial GCs have been linked to past accretion events ( Sarajedini 134 ; VandenBerg et al. 162 ; Lucertini et al. 94 ; Valenzuela et al. 153 ). Galactic astronomers use stellar ages to infer physical properties of galaxies as they evolve ( Bland-Hawthorn & Gerhard 16 ; Thomas et al. 150 ; van de Sande et al. 160 ). More recently, exoplanet research has begun correlating the ages of host stars with Hot Jupiter formation ( Schlaufman & Winn 137 ; Hamer & Schlaufman 72 ; Chen et al. 28 ). In particular, Galactic Archaeology, the study of our galaxy’s structure and history, heavily relies on stellar ages to provide accurate timelines on the evolution of our Universe ( Soderblom 143 ; Sahlholdt 124 ). Ages cannot be measured directly. Instead, we infer them from theory or by comparing to established results using standard age indicators. Various methods for age inference are continuously being developed, including: inferring age from [C/N] abundances ( Salaris et al. 131 ; Lagarde et al. 89 ; Casali et al. 21 ), using the relation between stellar rotation and time due to magnetic braking (known as gyrochronology) ( Skumanich 142 ; Barnes 12 ; Barnes 13 ; Casal et al. 20 ), and determining kinematic ages based on the motion of stars through space ( Nordström et al. 106 ; Aumer & Binney 11 ; Yu & Liu 171 ; Ting & Rix 151 ; Lu et al. 93 ). While diverse in approach, these methods are still inherently reliant on calibrations using stellar models, and therefore remain model-dependent. Most techniques make use of common theoretical frameworks, particularly isochrones and evolutionary tracks. Isochrones model the evolution of stars as a population for a singular age, while evolutionary tracks model the evolution of a single star of a particular mass. Isochrone fitting, a method of estimating stellar ages by comparing observable properties of stars to theoretical models, has been shown to work well when using a star cluster’s Hertzsprung-Russel (HR) or color-magnitude diagram ( Dotter et al. 51 ; Chen et al. 30 ; Gontcharov et al. 65 ; Reyes et al. 119 ). However, this method presents challenges for individual stars on the red giant branch, where closely spaced isochrones make precise age determinations difficult if metallicity is not precisely known. Stars with different masses and metallicities can populate the same narrow region of the red giant branch ( Salaris et al. 129 ; Gallart et al. 59 ; Valle et al. 159 ; Sahlholdt & Lindegren 125 ). In practice, age estimation methods often make use of stars along the subgiant and red giant branch (SGB, RGB) because they are visible over large distances and in great numbers. As stars move off the main sequence to the subgiant phase, age can be directly inferred from the luminosity ( Godoy-Rivera et al. 63 ; Xiang & Rix 169 ). This is because luminosity of the SGB is strongly dependent on the mass of the stellar core, which scales with the total mass and as a result, tightly correlated with age ( Salaris & Cassisi 126 ; Cassisi & Salaris 22 ; Kippenhahn et al. 86 ; Nataf et al. 102 ). While these stars are useful, they are visible only in limited regions of the galaxy and at shorter distances. In contrast, red giants, being significantly brighter, can be observed at greater distances. For red giants, we can infer an age from the metallicity and mass of the star. However, along with the importance of accurate metallicity measurements mentioned previously, mass is not always available and the ability to infer mass from the effective temperature is difficult, although occasionally possible with a combinations of spectroscopic, photometric, or asteroseismic data ( Feuillet et al. 56 ; Ness et al. 104 ). Asteroseismology, the study of oscillations in stars, directly constrains the masses of giants. With the increased availability of asteroseismic data, red giants are now more indispensable than ever for stellar age determination, further solidifying their role in understanding the evolution of our universe. Given the importance of precise age estimations, many tools have been developed to model the correlation between a star’s age and its observable characteristics. The astronomy community has produced several variations of models (e.g. MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks, MIST, Choi et al. 31 ; PAdova and tRieste Stellar Evolutionary Code, PARSEC v1.2S/v2.0, Chen et al. 29 , Nguyen et al. 105 ; Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Program, DSEP, Dotter et al. 49 ; Yonsei-Yale, Y 2 /YaPSI Spada et al. 144 ; A Bag of Stellar Tracks and Isochrones, BaSTI-IAC, Hidalgo et al. 75 , Pietrinferni et al. 115 , Salaris et al. 127 , Pietrinferni et al. 114 ; Geneva 1 1 1 https://www.unige.ch/sciences/astro/evolution/recherche/geneva-grids-stellar-evolution-models , Ekström et al. 54 , Georgy et al. 61 , Georgy et al. 62 , Groh et al. 71 , Murphy et al. 101 , Eggenberger et al. 52 Yusof et al. 172 , Sibony et al. 140 , see footnote for complete list of references; Pisa, Tognelli et al. 152 , Dell’Omodarme et al. 47 , Valle et al. 154 , Valle et al. 155 , Valle et al. 156 , Valle et al. 157 ), all of which have their own numerical methods for solving the equations of stellar structure. Researchers then create model grids by applying specific physical assumptions and calibration choices, which can lead to shifts in the correlation between observables and age. Many of these assumptions are about physics that is truly uncertain, including convective overshoot ( Roxburgh 123 ; Saslaw & Schwarzschild 135 ; Claret 35 ; Claret & Torres 36 ), opacities ( Iglesias & Rogers 79 ; Seaton 138 ; Colgan et