SimFLEX: a methodology for comparative analysis of urban areas for implementing new on-demand feeder bus services. Journal: Transportation Research Part A
Hanna Vasiutina, Olha Shulika, Michał Bujak, Farnoud Ghasemi, Rafał Kucharski · 2025
Read SimFLEX: a methodology for comparative analysis of urban areas for implementing new on-demand feeder bus services. Journal: Transportation Research Part A by Hanna Vasiutina, Olha Shulika, Michał Bujak, Farnoud Ghasemi, Rafał Kucharski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17538.txt.
Introduction
Hanna Vasiutina and four co-authors present SimFLEX, a framework for judging where on-demand feeder buses could work. Their 2025 study addresses a planning gap: cities lack a shared way to test feeder areas before launch. Feeder buses carry riders to main transit lines on request. SimFLEX runs small-scale simulations on map, population, and transport data.
The framework repeats each scenario many times and links a trip planner with a shared-ride tool. It scores service attractiveness, waiting time cuts, and added value for each area. The team compared two outlying areas of Krakow, Poland. One area scored higher on attractiveness and added value. The other promised much larger cuts in waiting time, near seventy-seven percent. The method helps cities pick launch areas with evidence in hand.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hanna Vasiutina, Olha Shulika, Michał Bujak, Farnoud Ghasemi, Rafał Kucharski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17538
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
SimFLEX: a methodology for comparative analysis of urban areas for implementing new on-demand feeder bus services. Journal: Transportation Research Part A Hanna Vasiutina, Olha Shulika, Michał Bujak, Farnoud Ghasemi, Rafał Kucharski Abstract On-demand feeder bus services present an innovative solution to urban mobility challenges, yet their success depends on thorough assessment and strategic planning. Despite their potential, a comprehensive framework for evaluating feasibility and identifying suitable service areas remains underdeveloped. Sim ulation Framework for F eeder L ocation E valuation (SimFLEX) utilizes spatial, demographic, and transportation-specific data to run microsimulations and compute various key performance indicators (KPIs), including service attractiveness, waiting time reduction, and added value. Given the novelty of these services and the limited understanding of traveler behavior and preferences, SimFLEX employs multiple replications to estimate demand and mode choices and integrates OpenTripPlanner (OTP) for public transport routing and ExMAS (Exact Matching of Attractive Shared Rides) framework for calculating shared trip attributes and related KPIs. For each demand scenario, we simulate the traveler learning process using the method of successive averages (MSA) to stabilize the system. Following stabilization, we calculate the KPIs for subsequent comparative and sensitivity analyzes. We applied SimFLEX to compare two remote urban districts in Krakow, Poland - Bronowice and Skotniki - designated as candidates for the service launch. Despite similar urban characteristics, our analysis revealed notable differences in main indicators between analyzed areas: Skotniki exhibited higher service attractiveness (approximately by 30%) and added value (up to 7%), whereas Bronowice showed greater potential for reducing waiting times (by nearly 77%). To assess the stability and reliability of our model output, we conducted a sensitivity analysis across a range of alternative-specific constants (ASC), assumed to be unknown. The results consistently confirmed that Skotniki is the superior candidate for feeder service implementation. SimFLEX framework can be instrumental for policymakers to estimate new service performance in the considered area, publicly available and applicable to various use-cases. It can integrate alternative models and approaches, making it a versatile tool for policymakers and urban planners to enhance urban mobility. 1 Introduction Thriving cities rely on efficient urban transport systems that ensure high accessibility, environmental sustainability, socio-economic progress, and public health ( Nieuwenhuijsen 2020 ) . The continuous expansion and growth of modern cities is driving the development of remote regions that offer residents access to affordable and high-quality living options. However, public transportation in these neighborhoods often suffers from low frequency and unreliability, resulting in poor accessibility for residents ( Ingvardson and Nielsen 2018 , Truden et al. 2022 ). Consequently, residents of remote areas are often forced to depend on private vehicles due to the absence of viable alternatives, leading to increased traffic congestion, environmental pollution, and a decline in overall livability for both, drivers and non-drivers ( Carroll et al. 2021 ) . Shared mobility, a rapidly evolving sector, presents an opportunity to enhance the effectiveness and sustainability of urban transportation by reducing the reliance on private cars and complementing traditional public transit ( Nikitas 2024 , Becker et al. 2020 , Guyader et al. 2021 ) . Feeder bus services, a type of shared mobility, usually operate in less accessible or peripheral urban areas, providing first- and last-mile connections. These services connect residents of such sparsely populated regions with major public transportation hubs, such as train or metro stations, bus and tram terminals, etc. Depending on various factors, including population density, demand levels, and the availability of other transportation options, different types of feeder services can be implemented. Demand-responsive feeder services are preferable when demand originates primarily at the transit station and disperses to multiple destinations, while fixed-route fixed-schedule services are preferred when demand is homogeneously distributed between the station and surrounding areas ( Calabrò et al. 2022 ) . More flexible than fixed-route buses, on-demand feeders offer a more convenient, time- and cost-effective travel experience by dynamically adjusting their routes and schedules in response to real-time passenger demand ( Capodici et al. 2024 , Zhen and Gu 2024 , Liyanage et al. 2024 ) . The advancement of technologies, combined with the widespread availability of user-friendly mobile applications, contributes significantly to the successful implementation and positive public perception of on-demand feeder bus services. However, despite their potential benefits, effectively implementing these services remains challenging due to various unknown determinants affecting performance and adoption. These include demand variability, user behavior and preferences, network integration, service reliability, and socioeconomic factors. Addressing these uncertainties requires continuous monitoring, adaptive adjustments, and iterative optimization to enhance efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and user satisfaction. Beyond operational complexities, integrating these services successfully is also hindered by regulatory and policy constraints ( Shaheen and Cohen 2020 ) . City administrations often struggle to accommodate flexible, technology-driven mobility solutions within existing urban environments, while ensuring equitable access remains a pressing concern. Rigid transportation policies, outdated regulations, and conflicts with existing transit services can delay or limit the deployment of on-demand feeders. Furthermore, without targeted policies and inclusive planning, disparities in mobility options may persist, restricting the benefits of on-demand transit for diverse population groups, particularly those in underserved or lower-income areas. Overcoming these challenges requires municipalities to develop customized solutions that balance innovation with accessibility, fostering integration with existing public transport networks. One of the key difficulties in deploying these services is predicting travel behavior and mode choice when the user perception is unknown. In such cases, indirect and predictive methods must be used to estimate mode choice and assess service effectiveness. Utility-based models in transportation analysis evaluate travel mode choices by incorporating factors such as travel time, detours, operational schemes, and transfers. These models account for adaptive travel behavior, learning processes, and multimodal route combinations, enabling a more dynamic and realistic representation of user decision-making ( Leffler et al. 2024 , Krauss et al. 2022 ) . Agent-based and micro-simulation models replicate individual traveler movements within a transport network, providing insights into service demand and performance. Discrete choice models predict how users select between travel modes based on observed travel behavior and socio-demographic factors. Additionally, machine learning approaches use mobile phone data, GPS tracking, and transport system analytics to analyze movement patterns and predict demand. A combination of these models typically yields a more comprehensive and accurate assessment of travel behavior and service feasibility ( Alonso-González et al. 2021 , Narayanan and Antoniou 2023 , Nahmias-Biran et al. 2021 , Schweizer et al. 2021 ) . In 2024, nearly 400 new on-demand transit projects were launched worldwide, marking a record high ( Foljanty 2024 ) . However, most of these initiatives remain in the pilot phase, underscoring the difficulties of transforming conceptual models into sustainable businesses. Many on-demand transit systems have faced challenges such as low user adoption, operational inefficiencies, and financial failure due to the lack of a robust methodology for evaluating feeder service performance based on area-specific characteristics. Without a comprehensive evaluation framework designed for feeder services planning, deployments risk inefficiency, low user satisfaction, and financial losses. This highlights the necessity of evaluating the feasibility of novel mobility solutions before deployment, considering the specific characteristics of the areas where they are intended to operate, and predicting user perceptions in situations where the service is still in the planning stage and actual demand remains unknown. 1.1