Risk-minimizing reinsurance with adverse selection

Ka Chun Cheung, Sheung Chi Phillip Yam, Fei Lung Yuen, and Yiying Zhang · 2025

Read Risk-minimizing reinsurance with adverse selection by Ka Chun Cheung, Sheung Chi Phillip Yam, Fei Lung Yuen, and Yiying Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17468.txt.

Introduction

Ka Chun Cheung and co-authors wrote a 2025 paper on how a monopoly reinsurer should design contracts when buyers hide what they know. Insurers seeking reinsurance hold private facts about their loss risks and their risk limits, across several dimensions at once. The reinsurer must offer contracts that sort buyers honestly without knowing those facts. Past models used one dimension or a few fixed types, which is far simpler.

The authors solve the hard screening problem with a new change of variables and a new form for buyer utility. Their optimal utility takes a hinge shape across three classic contract families. A threshold shuts low exposure buyers out of the market. Deductible based contracts sort buyers by type, while share based contracts pool everyone at full coverage. Adding a third contract family brought no extra profit beyond the best deductible design, under mild conditions.

Catalog record

CREATORKa Chun Cheung, Sheung Chi Phillip Yam, Fei Lung Yuen, and Yiying Zhang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17468

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Risk-minimizing reinsurance with adverse selection Ka Chun Cheung, Sheung Chi Phillip Yam, Fei Lung Yuen, and Yiying Zhang Abstract This paper provides a comprehensive characterization of optimal reinsurance mechanisms under adverse selection when a monopolistic reinsurer faces a continuum of insurers with multi-dimensional private information on loss exposures and Value-at-Risk (V @ @ R) preferences. Moving beyond standard single-dimensional or discrete-type models, we resolve an infinite-dimensional, non-convex screening problem by introducing a novel pre-reinsurance V @ @ R reparameterization and an indirect utility representation. This framework converts global incentive constraints into tractable, typewise conditions. Using a Breeden–Litzenberger representation, we show that optimal indirect utility consistently adopts a hinge form across stop-loss, quota-share, and change-loss contract classes, yielding an endogenous market-exclusion threshold. Among participating types, stop-loss contracts screen via type-dependent deductibles, whereas quota-share contracts induce complete pooling at full coverage. Moreover, under mild conditions, expanding the contract space to change-loss policies yields no extra profit beyond optimal stop-loss designs. Numerical examples further illustrate the fundamental economic trade-off between extracting information rents and excluding low-exposure types. Our approach provides deeper insight into the mechanisms of discrimination and exclusion in reinsurance markets characterized by asymmetric information, enriching theoretical and practical perspectives on contract design in the presence of adverse selection. Keywords : optimal reinsurance; contract design; adverse selection; Value-at-Risk; indirect utility; subgradient; Breeden-Litzenberger formula. JEL classification: C60, G22 1 Introduction Reinsurance enables insurers to transfer part of their underwriting risk to reinsurers. The modern theory of optimal reinsurance dates back to the seminal work of Borch (1960) , which established the optimality of stop-loss treaties under the expected-value premium principle. Since then, a large literature has examined optimal insurance and reinsurance design under alternative preferences, premium principles, and economics background; see, for example, Arrow (1963) ; Borch (1969) ; Young (1999) ; Cai and Tan (2007) ; Bernard et al. (2015) ; Zhuang et al. (2016) ; Asimit et al. (2017) ; Xu et al. (2019) ; Chi and Wei (2020) ; Birghila et al. (2023) . Most of the existing literature on optimal (re)insurance design assumes that the relevant characteristics of the contracting parties are commonly observed, including loss distributions, risk preferences, and premium principles. However, in practice, (re)insurance decisions may involve multidimensional private information, including both privately known loss risk and heterogeneity in preferences and other demand-relevant characteristics ( Finkelstein and Poterba, 2004 ; Finkelstein and McGarry, 2006 ; Cohen and Siegelman, 2010 , see, e.g.,) . Such information asymmetries can lead to adverse selection before contracting and moral hazard after contracting, and may call for signaling or screening mechanisms. These issues have long been central to contract theory and principal–agent models ( Talmor, 1981 ; Zhang, 2012 ; Dosis, 2018 ; Zhang et al., 2022 , cf.) . In this paper, we deal with adverse selection on the insurer’s side of the reinsurance market. In particular, an insurer may have private information about its loss exposure, risk preferences, or other characteristics that matter for the value of reinsurance but cannot be directly observed by the reinsurer. In this case, a reinsurer with market power must then offer contracts that induce insurers to reveal this information through their choices. Under the framework of adverse selection through privately known loss probabilities, Rothschild and Stiglitz (1976) study competitive insurance policies, while Stiglitz (1977) considers nonlinear pricing by a monopolistic insurer, both in fixed-loss settings with a common Bernoulli utility function. Chade and Schlee (2012) extend the monopoly problem to a continuum of privately informed risk types, allowing for wealth effects and arbitrary type distributions. Beyond one-dimensional risk heterogeneity, Landsberger and Meilijson (1999) allow two types to differ jointly in their loss distributions and Bernoulli utility functions and show that certainty equivalents can be used to order the types. Crocker and Snow (2011) show, from a different perspective, how multiple coverages, perils, deductibles, and policy limits can be used to screen along several dimensions of private information. More recently, Farinha Luz et al. (2023) study competitive insurance with a continuum of privately informed risk and preference types, with particular attention to risk classification and welfare. The above mentioned work mainly considers the optimal design of (re)insurance menu with adverse selection under the framework of expected utility. From the perspective of risk management, there also exists a small branch of relevant research work. For example, Cheung et al. (2019) consider insurers that evaluate risk using V @ R and show that combining quota-share and stop-loss features can mitigate adverse selection. The optimal menu depends on both the composition of the market and the degree of risk heterogeneity. Cheung et al. (2020) extend this framework to menus of stop-loss contracts under concave distortions and characterize the resulting optimal deductibles. Without restricting indemnities to a parametric family, Liang et al. (2022) derive optimal contract menus when insurers’ distortion risk measures overstate tail risk. Boonen and Zhang (2021) consider a related problem in which the reinsurer is uncertain about the insurer’s distortion risk measure and holds probabilistic beliefs over its possible specifications. These papers provide natural benchmarks for asymmetric-information reinsurance with a focus on two types of private policyholders, but the continuum-type case remains much less understood. Along this line, Gershkov et al. (2023) study heterogeneous loss distributions under a common Yaari’s dual utility for a continuum of agents, whereas Ghossoub et al. (2025) consider privately known risk attitudes under a common loss distribution. More recently, Han et al. (2026) analyze uncertainty about loss distributions and risk attitudes separately in a mean–variance Stackelberg framework. However, less attention has been paid to reinsurance markets in which insurers privately know both dimensions of their loss distributions and preference types ( Rochet and Choné, 1998 ; Olivella and Schroyen, 2014 ; Carroll, 2017 , cf.) . To address this gap, we study a monopolistic reinsurer that offers a menu of type-dependent, loss-contingent indemnity contracts to a continuum of insurers who privately know both their loss exposures and V @ R probability levels. The reinsurer evaluates ceded losses through a potentially nonlinear risk-adjusted valuation functional and chooses the menu to maximize profit. We analyze three common contract classes: stop-loss, quota-share, and change-loss policies. Across all three classes, the reinsurer sets an endogenous cutoff in pre-reinsurance V @ R, excludes insurers below the cutoff, and serves those above it. Although adverse-selection models with participation constraints often generate market exclusion ( Jullien, 2000 ; Guerrieri et al., 2010 , cf.) , our model explicitly links the cutoff to V @ R-based preferences and reinsurance costs. Among participating insurers, stop-loss contracts generate type-dependent deductibles, whereas quota-share contracts pool insurers at full reinsurance. Additionally, under the stated structural condition, allowing the more flexible change-loss class leaves the optimal stop-loss allocation unchanged and does not increase the reinsurer’s profit. The mathematical challenge arises from the infinite-dimensional and generally non-convex nature of the screening problem, together with the presence of global incentive constraints. To overcome this difficulty, we exploit the structure induced by V @ R: across all three contract classes, an insurer’s valuation depends on its private characteristics (\alpha,k) only through its V @ R, i.e., a=\text{V$@$R}_{\alpha}(X_{k}) , which is called the pre-reinsurance V @ R, standing for the insurer’s gross loss before reinsurance. We therefore use

Read the complete text