A relation between Turaev coaction, Goncharov–Brown coaction and the reduced coaction Lie algebra

Muze Ren · 2025

Read A relation between Turaev coaction, Goncharov–Brown coaction and the reduced coaction Lie algebra by Muze Ren (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17416.txt.

Introduction

Muze Ren presents a formula that relates two coaction maps in algebra, the Turaev coaction and the Goncharov-Brown coaction. The short paper from 2025 is a pure mathematics note. Driven by that relation, Ren introduces a new form called the reduced coaction equation. Skew symmetric solutions to the equation are shown to form a Lie algebra under the Ihara bracket. The note is brief and dense, aimed at readers who already work with coactions and brackets.

Catalog record

CREATORMuze Ren
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17416

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A relation between Turaev coaction, Goncharov–Brown coaction and the reduced coaction Lie algebra Muze Ren Abstract We present a formula that relates the Turaev coaction and the Goncharov–Brown coaction. Motivated by this relation, we introduce the reduced coaction equation. The skew-symmetric solutions to this equation form a Lie algebra under Ihara bracket. 1 Introduction and main results Let k be a field of characteristic 0 . We are interested in the following two different Hopf algebras of formal noncommutative power series: A=(k\langle\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle\rangle,\rm{conc},\Delta_{\shuffle},\varepsilon,S)\quad\rm{and}\quad\widehat{A}=(k\langle\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle\rangle,\shuffle,\Delta_{\rm{dec}},\varepsilon). Here, ” \rm{conc} ” denotes the concatenation product, and \shuffle is the shuffle product. The counit is defined by \varepsilon(x_{0})=\varepsilon(x_{1})=0 . The coproducts are given by \displaystyle\Delta_{\shuffle}(x_{i})=x_{i}\otimes 1+1\otimes x_{i},\quad i=0,1. \displaystyle\Delta_{\rm{dec}}(w)=\sum_{uv=w}u\otimes v. The Hopf algebra A is dual to (k\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle,\shuffle,\Delta_{\rm{dec}}) with respect to the pairing k\langle\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle\rangle\otimes k\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle;\varphi\otimes w\mapsto c_{w}(\varphi), where c_{w}(\varphi) denotes the coefficient of the word w in the series \varphi . For any x\in A , we can decompose it as x=\varepsilon(x)+\sum^{1}_{i=0}x_{i}d^{R}_{i}(x)=\varepsilon(x)+\sum^{1}_{i=0}d^{L}_{i}(x)x_{i} We denote the free Lie algebra in A by \mathfrak{fr}_{k}(x_{0},x_{1}) , the indecomposable \ker\varepsilon/(\ker\varepsilon)^{2} of \widehat{A} by \mathcal{L} . There are two algebraic operations on A and \widehat{A} that are dual to each other, namely the Ihara action and the Goncharov-Brown coaction. These operations play a fundamental role in the study of multiple zeta values, mixed Tate motives and polylogarithms. • Ihara action I:\mathfrak{fr}_{k}(x_{0},x_{1})\times A\to A;\psi\times a\mapsto d_{\psi}(a) , where d_{\psi} is the derivation given by d_{\psi}(x_{0})=0 and d_{\psi}(x_{1})=[x_{1},\psi] . This action induces the Ihara Lie bracket on \mathfrak{fr}_{k}(x_{0},x_{1}) given by \{\psi_{1},\psi_{2}\}=d_{\psi_{2}}(\psi_{1})-d_{\psi_{1}}(\psi_{2})-[\psi_{1},\psi_{2}] (1) For the arithmetic motivations, see [ 18 ] and [ 6 ] . • Goncharov-Brown coaction D:\widehat{A}\to\mathcal{L}\otimes\widehat{A} . \displaystyle D(\varepsilon_{1}\ldots\varepsilon_{n})=\sum_{0\leq p<q\leq n}[I(\varepsilon_{p};\varepsilon_{p+1}\dots\varepsilon_{q};\varepsilon_{q+1})]\otimes\varepsilon_{1}\dots\varepsilon_{p}\varepsilon_{q+1}\dots\varepsilon_{n} (2) (The notation will be clarified in next section.) This coaction induces a Lie cobracket on \mathcal{L} . For the definition of coproduct, see [ 8 ] . For the important application of the coaction, [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . In the study of intersections of curves on surfaces, the Goldman–Turaev Lie bialgebra [ 14 ] and its noncommutative analogue, the necklace Lie bialgebras [ 16 ] play an important role. Those two brackets also arise from another pair of action and coaction. The Kirillov-Kostant-Souriau double bracket \{\!\!\{-,-\}\!\!\}_{\rm{KKS}} induces the following action. • KKS action : p:A\times A\to A which descends to A/[A,A]\times A\to A and induces the necklace Lie bracket \{-,-\}_{\rm{necklace}} on A/[A,A] , it induces the KKS poisson bracket on representation space. See section 2.6 in [ 17 ] and section 3 in [ 2 ] for further details. • Turaev coaction : The reduced coaction \mu:A\to A . It is equivalent to the coaction map p_{\mu}:A\to A/[A,A]\otimes A and the coaction induces a Lie cobracket \delta_{\rm{necklace}} on A/[A,A] . We discuss only the reduced coaction in this paper. For further details of the coaction, see the linear term of the Turaev coproduct in [ 14 ] , ” \mu ” in [ 11 ] and ”quasi derivations” in [ 13 ] . For the equivalence to reduced one, see section 3 of [ 2 ] . The relation between Ihara action and KKS action was first studied by Drinfeld in the context of Hamiltonian interpretation of Ihara Lie algebra (section 6 in [ 7 ] ). And Kontsevich [ 12 ] using noncommutative geoemtry, see also Goncharov Proposition 5.1 in [ 9 ] etc. It is then very natural to compare the coactions. The reduced coaction \mu is a linear map from k\langle\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle\rangle to k\langle\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle\rangle which is defined to be \displaystyle\mu(x_{0})=\mu(x_{1})=0,\quad(x_{i}\odot x_{j}):=\delta_{x_{i},x_{j}}x_{i},\quad x_{i},x_{j}\in\{x_{0},x_{1}\} \displaystyle\mu(k_{1}k_{2},\dots,k_{n}):=\sum^{n-1}_{i=1}k_{1},\dots,k_{i-1}(k_{i}\odot k_{i+1})k_{i+2}\dots k_{n},\quad k_{1},\dots,k_{n}\in\{x_{0},x_{1}\} We denote \widehat{\mu} to be the dual of \mu . Our first result relating the coaction D and \widehat{\mu} is the following simple explicit formula, see next section for notation. Theorem 1.1 . For \varepsilon_{1},\dots,\varepsilon_{n}\in\{x_{0},x_{1}\} , we have D\circ\widehat{\mu}-(1\otimes\widehat{\mu})\circ D(\varepsilon_{1}\ldots\varepsilon_{n})\\ =\sum_{0\leq p<q\leq n}[I^{\mu}(\varepsilon_{p};\varepsilon_{p+1}\dots\varepsilon_{q};\varepsilon_{q+1})]\otimes\varepsilon_{1}\dots\varepsilon_{p}\varepsilon_{q+1}\dots\varepsilon_{n} (3) The formula is interesting because we could denote the RHS of ( 3 ) by D^{\mu} . The definition of D^{\mu} looks similar to the definition of D with the help of the notations I^{\mu} . This formula also allow us to further compare the two co-products. And inspired by the notation I^{\mu} , we introduce the following form of reduced coaction equations and a Lie algebra defined with Ihara bracket. Let \eta be a Lie series in k\langle\langle x_{0},x_{1}\rangle\rangle , with c_{x_{0}}(\eta)=c_{x_{1}}(\eta)=0 , the function r_{\eta} associated to \eta is defined to be r_{\eta}(x)=\sum_{l\geq 0}c_{x^{l+1}_{0}x_{1}}(\eta)x^{l+1} . Definition 1.2 (The reduced coaction equation) . For \eta in \mathfrak{fr}_{k}(x_{0},x_{1}) with c_{x_{0}}(\eta)=c_{x_{1}}(\eta)=0 . The reduced coaction equation is defined to be d^{R}_{1}(\eta)+\mu(\eta)+d^{L}_{0}(\eta)=-r_{\eta}(x_{1})+r_{\eta}(x_{0}). (4) We denote by \overline{{\mathfrak{rc}}_{0}} the vector space of skew symmetric solutions of the equation, i.e. \eta(x_{0},x_{1})=-\eta(x_{1},x_{0}) . Example 1.3 . For the element f_{3}=[x_{0},[x_{0},x_{1}]]+[x_{1},[x_{0},x_{1}]] , we have that \mu(f_{3})=0 and d^{L}_{0}(f_{3})=-2x_{0}x_{1}+x_{1}x_{0}-x_{1}^{2},\quad d^{R}_{1}(f_{3})=x_{0}^{2}+2x_{0}x_{1}-x_{1}x_{0},\quad r_{f_{3}}(x)=x^{2}. And we can directly verify that f_{3} satisfies the reduced coaction equation d^{L}_{0}(f_{3})+\mu(f_{3})+d^{R}_{1}(f_{3})=-r_{f_{3}}(x_{1})+r_{f_{3}}(x_{0}) (5) Theorem 1.4 . The vector space \overline{{\mathfrak{rc}}_{0}} is a Lie algebra with the Ihara bracket ( 1 ), Remark 1.5 . For \Phi a group-like element in A , the group version of the reduced coaction equation is the following d^{R}_{1}(\Phi)+\mu(\Phi)+d^{L}_{0}(\Phi)=-r_{\phi}(x_{1})\Phi+\Phi r_{\phi}(-x_{0}) (6) the infinitesimal equation is actually d^{R}_{1}(\eta)+\mu(\eta)+d^{L}_{0}(\eta)=-r_{\eta}(x_{1})+r_{\eta}(-x_{0}), (7) The skew symmetric solutions of the ( 7 ) is denoted by \mathfrak{rc} . \mathfrak{rc} contains a 1 dimensional vector space [x_{0},x_{1}] , the subspace \mathfrak{rc}_{\lambda} whose cofficents before the commutator [x_{0},x_{1}] is \lambda . It is proved in [ 1 ] , for \eta\in\mathfrak{rc}_{0} , the functions r_{\eta}(x) is an even function. It is then equivalent to ( 4 ). The Lie algebra \mathfrak{rc}_{0} has a close relation with the double shuffle Lie algebra \mathfrak{dmr}_{0} , Kashiwara-Vergne Lie algebra \mathfrak{krv}_{2} and Grothendieck Teichmuller Lie algebra \mathfrak{grt}_{1} . As a direct consequence of Theorem 1.1 in [ 2 ] , \mathfrak{grt}_{1} satisfies ( 7 ) and r_{\eta} is even function, thus \mathfrak{grt}_{1}\in\overline{{\mathfrak{rc}}_{0}}. The detailed relations are studied in [ 1 ] , and conjecturally we have the isomorphism between the Lie algebras \mathfrak{grt}_{1} , \mathfrak{dmr}_{0} , \mathfrak{krv}_{2} and \mathfrak{rc}_{0} . Similar objects in [ 2 ] are studied from the topological perpective in [ 10 ] 1 1 1 It will be interesting to compare with \mathfrak{grt}^{\rm{em}}_{1} in [ 10 ] or symmetric \mathfrak{krv}_{2} which use krv1 equation. and categorical perspective in [ 15 ] . We hope to investigate the relation to those perspective in the future. Acknowledgements. I would like to thank A. Alekseev, F. Brown and F. Naef, for teaching me those coactions. And thank D. Bar-Natan, H. Furusho, Y. Kuno, G. Massuyeau and P. Severa for inspiring questions and explain some questions in their papers. Part of the work is based on the talk ”From generalized pentagon equations to reduced coaction equations” given at Dijon. I would like to thank M. Fairon and T. Kimura for invitation and hospitality. This work is supported in part by the grants 08235 and 20040, and by the National Center for Competence in Research SwissMAP of the Swiss National Science Foundation. 2 Commuting relation of two coactions We first recall Brown’s formula for the coaction and its proof in Proposition 2.6 in [ 4 ] . Then we use the same idea to have the formula for D\circ\widehat{\mu}-(1\otimes\widehat{\mu})\circ D . For the consideration of the dual operation,

Read the complete text