Skills Beget Skills: Evidence from Historical School Reforms Targeting Health and Further Education
Volha Lazuka Peter Sandholt Jensen University of Southern Denmark, Linnaeus University Lund University, and IZA · 2025
Read Skills Beget Skills: Evidence from Historical School Reforms Targeting Health and Further Education by Volha Lazuka Peter Sandholt Jensen University of Southern Denmark, Linnaeus University Lund University, and IZA (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17318.txt.
Introduction
Volha Lazuka and Peter Jensen study two school reforms in Denmark from the mid-twentieth century. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five. One reform put doctors in schools, and the other widened access to secondary schooling. The reforms rolled out at varied times across the country, which lets the authors compare places fairly.
They tracked people into their late fifties and early sixties. Each reform on its own cut deaths and hospital stays and raised schooling. When both reforms landed in the same place, each one's effect roughly doubled. Earnings rose by about nine percent in those doubly treated places. The lesson is that health and schooling investments at school can multiply each other over a lifetime.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Volha Lazuka Peter Sandholt Jensen University of Southern Denmark, Linnaeus University Lund University, and IZA |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17318
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Skills Beget Skills: Evidence from Historical School Reforms Targeting Health and Further Education † † thanks: Lazuka: [email protected], Jensen: [email protected]. We thank Meltem Daysal, Mircea Trandafir, and Miriam Wüst for their comments. Lazuka gratefully acknowledges funding from European Union HORIZON-2020, Marie Skłodowska-Curie Individual Fellowship (grant No 101025481). The authors bear sole responsibility for the content of this paper. Volha Lazuka Peter Sandholt Jensen University of Southern Denmark, Linnaeus University Lund University, and IZA Abstract This paper investigates the dynamic complementarity between school health and education reforms implemented in Denmark between 1940 and 1965: the introduction of school doctors and the expansion of secondary education. Using a staggered difference-in-differences approach for multiple treatments, we study the reform effects on individuals’ outcomes in the ages 55–64. We find that each reform leads to significant improvements in health and education outcomes, including reduced mortality, fewer hospitalizations, and higher educational attainment. The singular impact of each reform is doubled when both reforms are implemented together, resulting in a 9 percent increase in earnings. These findings underscore high societal returns to complementary school investments in the long term. Keywords: School reform, dynamic complementarity, multiple treatments, difference-in-differences, long-term returns JEL Classifications: H51, H52, H75, I18, I21, I26, I28 \AtEveryBibitem \clearlist language \AtEveryBibitem \clearfield month \AtEveryCitekey \clearfield month \DeclareCiteCommand \citeyear \bibhyperref \printfield year \bibhyperref \printfield extrayear \multicitedelim \subcaptionsetup [figure]format=fig \DeclareDelayedFloatFlavor sidewaysfigurefigure \DeclareDelayedFloatFlavor sidewaystabletable \DeclareDelayedFloatFlavour longtabletable \addbibresource References.bib 1 Introduction School spending is not only the largest government expenditure but also a key social investment, as historical school expansion reforms have been found to yield some of the highest rates of return in long run \citep Hendren.2020. Additionally, children’s health has become an important target of school spending, with similarly large long-term benefits found from the nationwide school nutrition reforms ( \cite Lundborg.2022; \cite Butikofer.2018). A natural question that arises is how both educational and health policies in schools impact children’s long-term outcomes—do they create additional value when implemented together? Theoretically, this question relates to the hypothesis in economics that children who benefit from early investments are more likely to benefit from later investments because "skills beget skills" \citep Cunha.2007. To date, this hypothesis has not been tested with respect to the interaction between school health and education. From a policy perspective, reforms’ interactions more accurately reflect real-world conditions, as most school reforms do not occur in isolation but often overlap with one another or with other social reforms. This paper examines whether the introduction of primary school doctors, who provide regular check-ups, health advice, and treatments, is particularly beneficial for children also exposed to the secondary school reform that expanded and liberalized access to further education, in terms of long-term outcomes. A small body of studies has addressed this interaction hypothesis using quasi-experimental strategies: \cite Fischer.2021, \cite Johnson.2019, and \cite Gilraine.2017 explore the effects of overlapping education reforms and find sizable complementary effects on long-run economic outcomes. In contrast, \cite RossinSlater.2020 find that infant health care and preschool programs act as substitutes—early education primarily benefits children who had not previously received health care. \cite Adhvaryu.2024 also find substitution effects, studying exposure to a rainfall in early life and an education reform. The reason for the contrasting findings may arise from the fact that health-to-education studies, due to imperfect compliance with single reforms, estimate reduced-form interaction effects from a small and, plausibly, specific population. In total, not only has the interaction between school health and education reforms not been thoroughly studied, but there is also currently no evidence that childhood investments in health and education are complementary. To test for dynamic complementarity between health and other skills, we examine two overlapping yet independent school reforms implemented in Denmark between 1940 and 1965. The first reform targeted students’ health by introducing licensed doctors in schools. The second reform aimed at expanding students’ access to secondary and further education through the opening of new, exam-free secondary schools. The Danish historical context offers three advantages to our identification strategy: The reduced-form effects of school-based reforms come from perfect compliance, due to primary school education being compulsory. Additionally, the secondary education reform serves as a follow-up to the school doctors’ reform, aligning with the hypothesis that later investments should proceed early investments to create complementarities. Finally, both reforms were implemented widely, but not nationwide, and overlapped in timing, though not fully. This allows us to apply a state-of-the-art empirical design to estimate the average treatment effects on the treated municipalities ( {ATTs} ) using staggered difference-in-differences (DiD) estimators from \cite Callaway.2021 and their extension for the case of multiple treatments in \cite Callaway.2024. These new estimators address contamination bias in designs with heterogeneous treatment effects, which generally worsens when interaction effects are included in two-way fixed-effects specifications to study the interaction of reforms \citep Chaisemartin.2023. To our knowledge, our study is the first to explore interaction effects using the latest methodological advancements. This paper makes four contributions to the existing literature. First, we establish complementary effects of school health and education reforms, supporting the complementarity hypothesis for health and cognitive skills. This evidence broadens the literature on the complementary effects of education programs ( \cite Johnson.2019; \cite Hinrichs.2010), including health reforms that are highly effective when combined with education reforms. Second, we contribute to the literature on the long-term effects of school health reforms. While a handful of studies have examined the impact of school meals ( \cite Lundborg.2022; \cite Butikofer.2018), the impact of school doctors—a historically widespread policy—has been explored in only one prior study \citep Spika.2023. Third, we examine the effects of a secondary education reform that has received less attention compared to the broader literature on long-term impacts of primary education reforms ( \cite Dominguez.2023; \cite Heinesen.2022; \cite Fischer.2022; \cite Mazumder.2021; \cite Fischer.2020; \cite Hyman.2017; \cite Jackson.2016). Finally, we show that investments in skills in school ages yield long-term benefits similar to preschool investments, often considered especially effective ( \cite Lazuka.2023; \cite Wust.2022; \cite Almond.2018). We also propose that our study will encourage the use of DiD estimators robust to heterogeneous treatments within a multiple-treatment framework to estimate interaction effects. 2 Background 2.1 School System in Denmark We begin the background section by giving a brief overview of the school system at the time of the introduction of school doctors and the school reform. Figure 1 shows that there were seven years of compulsory schooling at the time of the policies considered \citep Appel.2014. Most children attended school between the ages of 7 and 14. There were differences between rural and urban areas. In rural areas, children would attend school every second day, and classes were not separated by gender. In urban areas, by contrast, children attended school every day, and classes were separated by gender. After the fifth grade, some students qualified for the so-called middle school (introduced in 1903). The middle school ( mellemskolen in Danish) lasted four years, and students would qualify for either one year of intermediate school or three years of high school. In international terms, middle school is better described as low secondary schooling, so we will use the term "secondary school" instead. The low secondary school was abolished by a school reform in 1958; see \cite arendt2005does. 2.2 Introduction of School Doctors