Small genus, small index critical points of the systole function.

Ni An, Ferdinand Ihringer, Ingrid Irmer · 2025

Read Small genus, small index critical points of the systole function. by Ni An, Ferdinand Ihringer, Ingrid Irmer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17316.txt.

Introduction

Ni An, Ferdinand Ihringer, and Ingrid Irmer compute the index of a family of critical points of the systole function. Their paper from twenty twenty-five works on Teichmüller space, the moduli of marked surfaces. Systoles are the shortest closed geodesics on a surface. At these points, the systoles fail to span the surface's homology, an odd trait. Past examples needed huge genus, which blocked index work.

The new family lives at small genus, so the index can at last be computed. Minimal filling subsets of systoles get a study of their own. They set the local dimension of the Thurston spine near the point. One genus-five case holds a small filling set, presumably of systoles. Integer programming with symmetry cuts sorts the least and most sizes for polygon-tiled surfaces.

Catalog record

CREATORNi An, Ferdinand Ihringer, Ingrid Irmer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17316

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Small genus, small index critical points of the systole function. Ni An, Ferdinand Ihringer, Ingrid Irmer Abstract . In this paper the index of a family of critical points of the systole function on Teichmüller space is calculated. The members of this family are interesting in that their existence implies the existence of strata in the Thurston spine for which the systoles do not determine a basis for the homology of the surface. Previously, index calculations of critical points with this pathological feature were impossible, because the only known examples were in surfaces with huge genus. A related concept is that of a “minimal filling subset” of the systoles at the critical point. Such minimal filling sets are studied, as they relate to the dimension of the Thurston spine near the critical point. We find an example of a minimal filling set of simple closed geodesics in genus 5 with cardinality 8, that are presumably realised as systoles. More generally, we determine the smallest and largest cardinality of a minimal filling set related to a tessellation of a hyperbolic surface by regular, right-angled m m -gons for m ∈ { 5 , 6 , 7 } m\in\{5,6,7\} . For this, we use integer linear programming together with a hand-tailored symmetry breaking technique. 1 Introduction The purpose of this paper is to study a family obtained from covering spaces of the examples studied in Example 36 of [ 24 ] . The members of this family, like those from [ 24 ] , are critical points of any mapping class group-equivariant Morse function on the Teichmüller space \mathcal{T}_{g} of closed, compact, connected genus g surfaces with g\geq 2 . Calculating the index of these critical points is a problem related to the topology of the moduli space of closed surfaces, as will now be outlined. The systoles on a hyperbolic surface S_{g} of genus g are the shortest closed geodesics. Every hyperbolic surface has at least one systole. The systole function f_{\mathrm{sys}}:\mathcal{T}_{g}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}_{+} is the function that maps x\in\mathcal{T}_{g} to the length of the systoles at x . It was shown in [ 1 ] that f_{\mathrm{sys}} is a topological Morse function. Topological Morse functions are defined in [ 17 ] , and can be used in the category of topological manifolds in much the same way as Morse functions on differentiable manifolds; a reference for this is Section 3 of Essay III of [ 13 ] . Many examples of critical points of f_{\mathrm{sys}} are now known, for example [ 8 , 22 , 23 ] . The most famous examples are the Bolza surface in genus 2, [ 3 ] , and the Klein Quartic, [ 14 ] . An estimate of the number of critical points of the systole function on \mathcal{T}_{g} was given in [ 7 ] . The Thurston spine, \mathcal{P}_{g} , is a CW complex embedded in the Teichmüller space, \mathcal{T}_{g} , of a genus g surface, with g\geq 2 . It consists of all the points at which the systoles cut the surface into polygons, i.e. the systoles fill the surface. As explained in [ 26 ] , it follows from a theorem first proven by Bers [ 2 ] , that \mathcal{P}_{g} contains all the critical points of f_{\mathrm{sys}} . Moreover, \mathcal{P}_{g} is the image of a mapping class group-equivariant deformation retraction of \mathcal{T}_{g} , [ 10 , 26 ] . In [ 24 ] , Schmutz Schaller posed the question of whether there exist critical points of f_{\mathrm{sys}} of co-index larger than the virtual cohomological dimension 4g-5 of the mapping class group. This question is tied up with the question of whether the dimension of \mathcal{P}_{g} is larger than the lower bound given by 4g-5 . As explained in Section 5 of [ 12 ] , it is a consequence of the work of Akrout that a critical point p of f_{\mathrm{sys}} of index j determines a cell of \mathcal{P}_{g} of codimension j , and that the cardinality of a minimal filling set contained in the set of systoles at p gives an upper bound on the dimension of \mathcal{P}_{g} on a neighbourhood of p . m genus number of systoles smallest cardinality largest cardinality rank index 5 5 20 8 10 10 12 6 17 48 24 31 31 39 7 49 112 64 80 84 102 8 129 256 \geq 155 , \leq 160 \geq 190 , \leq 192 210 245 Table 1. The results of our computations. Here “smallest/largest cardinality” refers to the smallest/largest cardinality of a minimal filling set. The “rank” is the dimension of the homological span of the systoles in H_{1}(S_{g};\mathbb{Q}) . While it is now known from a number of sources, [ 4 , 9 ] , that the answer to Schmutz Schaller’s question is yes, the examples in this paper are the first such examples for which the index could actually be calculated. The results are given in Table 1 1 1 1 Computational data files associated with Table 1 are available on the arXiv version of this article. . Enough examples were calculated to guess the formula m2^{m-3}-(m+3) for the index. The parameter m=5,6,7,\ldots will be explained in Section 2 . The first in our family of examples has genus 5. This is likely the smallest genus surface for which the dimension of the Thurston spine is larger than the virtual cohomological dimension of the mapping class group and for which there is a filling set of systoles that do not span H_{1}(S_{g};\mathbb{Q}) . It is known that neither of these things happens in genus 2, [ 11 ] and it appears unlikely in genus 3 as a result of preliminary results due to Schmutz Schaller, [ 22 ] . The second example in the family was mentioned in [ 15 ] and has genus 17. Previously, only comparatively large genus examples of this phenomenon were known, making it difficult to study and obtain intuition. Following Thurston, a stratum labelled by C is the set of points in \mathcal{T}_{g} at which C is the set of systoles. A minimal filling set C^{\prime} of closed geodesics on S_{g} is a filling set that does not contain any proper subsets that fill. It was shown in [ 12 ] that for a minimal filling set C^{\prime} , the codimension in \mathcal{T}_{g} of a stratum of \mathcal{P}_{g} on which the set of systoles is C^{\prime} is given by |C^{\prime}|-1 . Our examples have an unusual property that the set C of systoles contains minimal filling subsets of different cardinalities. We computed enough examples of minimal filling subsets of smallest cardinality to guess the formula (m-3)2^{m-3} , as well as studying orbits of minimal filling subsets. Another property satisfied by all of our minimal filling sets is that the number of complementary regions is equal to one. The cardinality of such filling sets was bounded from above by 2g in [ 18 ] . There is a property of systoles known as local finiteness , explained in Section 2 . As a consequence of local finiteness, one expects that there is a minimal filling set C^{\prime}\subset C such that C^{\prime} is the set of systoles on a locally

Read the complete text