The Fields of Values of the Isaacs’ Head Characters
Gabriel Navarro · 2025
Read The Fields of Values of the Isaacs’ Head Characters by Gabriel Navarro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17301.txt.
Introduction
Gabriel Navarro determines the value fields of the head characters of a finite solvable group in a 2025 paper. Head characters, introduced by Isaacs, are a canonical set of irreducible characters. They match the linear characters of a Carter subgroup, one of the group's self-normalizing nilpotent parts. Navarro settles exactly which number fields their values generate. The result extends his earlier construction of canonical character sets tied to formations of groups. A corollary in the background bounds the abelian size of a Carter subgroup by the group's class count.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gabriel Navarro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17301
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Fields of Values of the Isaacs’ Head Characters Thanks: This research is supported by Grant PID2022-137612NB-I00 funded by MCIN/AEI/ 10.13039/501100011033 and ERDF “A way of making Europe”. I thank N. Rizo and L. Sanus for a careful reading of this manuscript. Gabriel Navarro Abstract . We determine the fields of values of the Isaacs’ head characters of a finite solvable group. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 20D20; Secondary 20C15 1. Introduction In one of his final major papers ( [ Is22 ] ), I. M. Isaacs introduced a canonical subset {\rm H}(G)\subseteq{\rm Irr}(G) of the irreducible characters of a finite solvable group G , in bijection with the linear characters {\rm Lin}(C) of a Carter subgroup C of G . (Discovered by R. W. Carter in [ C61 ] , recall that C is any self-normalizing nilpotent subgroup of G and that any two of them are G -conjugate [ C61 ] .) Isaacs named them the head characters of G . As a corollary, he proved that |C/C^{\prime}|\leq k(G) , where C^{\prime}=[C,C] is the derived subgroup of C and k(G) is the number of conjugacy classes of G . A direct proof of this result is not immediately apparent. Subsequently, I constructed a canonical subset {\rm Irr}_{\mathfrak{F}^{\prime}}(G) of the complex characters of a finite solvable group G , associated with every formation \mathfrak{F} , and in bijection with {\rm Irr}({\bf N}_{G}(H)/H^{\prime}) , where H is an \mathfrak{F} -projector of G ( [ N22 ] ). When \mathfrak{F} is the class of p -groups, then {\rm Irr}_{\mathfrak{F}^{\prime}}(G) is the set of irreducible characters of G of degree not divisible by p and H is a Sylow p -subgroup of G ; when \mathfrak{F} is the class of nilpotent groups, then H=C is a Carter subgroup of G and {\rm Irr}_{\mathfrak{F}^{\prime}}(G)={\rm H}(G) . Thus, Isaacs’ result can be seen as the McKay conjecture for the formation of nilpotent groups. There are many open questions about this intriguing set {\rm H}(G) . For instance, whether these characters can be detected from the character table remains an open question. It is also unknown whether {\rm H}(G) consists of the irreducible characters of G that do not have any zero value on the Carter subgroup C . Isaacs did prove that if \eta\in{\rm H}(G) , then \eta_{K}\in{\rm Irr}(K) whenever K\trianglelefteq\,G and G/K is nilpotent, and that \eta(1) divides |G:C| , but these properties certainly do not characterize the set {\rm H}(G) . On a slightly different subject, it is not even known if the character table of a solvable group G determines the size |C| of the Carter subgroup C , the number of linear caracters |C/C^{\prime}| of C , or even the primes dividing |C| . Hence, a determination of {\rm H}(G) in the character table sounds difficult. In this note, we offer a new property of the Isaacs head characters and present two consequences beyond their world. Recall that if \chi is a character, then the field of values of \chi , {\mathbb{Q}}(\chi) , is the smallest subfield of the complex numbers containing the values of \chi . Although |{\rm H}(G)|=|C/C^{\prime}| , no canonical bijection {\rm Lin}(C)\rightarrow{\rm H}(G) is known and therefore, a priori, no connection between the field of values of these characters can be made. Nevertheless, we establish the following global/local result. THEOREM A . Let G be a finite solvable group, and let C be a Carter subgroup of G . Then the fields of values of the head characters are exactly the n –th cyclotomic fields {\mathbb{Q}}_{n} corresponding to the orders n of the linear characters of C . We see Theorem A as the Galois-McKay theorem for the formation of nilpotent groups. We remind the reader that the analog of Theorem A for the formation of p -groups (that is, the McKay original case) does not in general hold, as shown, for instance, by G={\rm GL}_{2}(3) and p=3 . (Here {\bf N}_{G}(P)/P^{\prime} is a rational group, and G has irreducible characters of degree 2 and field of values {\mathbb{Q}}(i\sqrt{2}) .) It is interesting to notice that the Galois–McKay conjecture ( [ N04 ] ) requires to consider field of values of characters over the p -adics, while the analog for formations containing the nilpotent groups seems to work well over the rationals. (The corresponding head characters associated to those, together with some other properties of the head characters have been recently considered in [ FGS25 ] .) As a consequence of Theorem A, we prove the following. COROLLARY B . Suppose that G is a solvable group, and let C be a Carter subgroup of G . Then G has at least m rational-valued irreducible characters, where m=|P/\Phi(P)| , P\in{\rm Syl}_{2}(C) and \Phi(P) is the Frattini subgroup of P . We can also use Theorem A to reprove a fact on rational groups, which is not too well-known (and which does not seem to have a direct group theoretical proof). Recall that a rational group is a group whose irreducible characters are all rational-valued. COROLLARY C . Suppose that G is a solvable rational group. Then the Carter subgroups of G are the Sylow 2-subgroups of G . At the end of this note, we discuss to what extent these corollaries can be extended to general finite groups. 2. The key result For characters, we use the notation from [ Is ] and [ N18 ] . Recall that a Carter subgroup C of a solvable group is a self-normalizing nilpotent subgroup of G . Also, any two of them are G -conjugate, and if N\trianglelefteq\,G , then CN/N is a Carter subgroup of G/N ( [ C61 ] ). We begin with a known result, which may not be familiar to every character theorist. It concerns formations (see [ DH92 ] IV.5.18) and, if conveniently applied, could have simplified some of the results in [ Is22 ] . We present the following elementary proof in the case of interest, including it here for the reader’s convenience. Lemma 2.1 . Let G be a finite solvable group. Let K be the smallest normal subgroup of G such that G/K is nilpotent. If K is abelian, then K is complemented in G , and its complements are the Carter subgroups of G . Proof. Since G/K is nilpotent, then G=KC . We show that K\cap C=1 . We argue by induction on |G| . Suppose that |K| is not a a prime power. Let p be any prime dividing |K| . Let 1<K_{p^{\prime}} be the Hall p -complement of K . By induction, we have that CK_{p^{\prime}}\cap K=K_{p^{\prime}} . Therefore, if K_{p} is a Sylow p -subgroup of K , we have that C\cap K_{p}\subseteq CK_{p^{\prime}}\cap K\cap K_{p}=1 . Now if 1\neq c\in C\cap K and p is any prime dividing o(c) , we have that c_{p}\in C\cap K_{p} (because K has a normal Sylow p -subgroup K_{p} ), and this is a contradiction. Therefore, we may assume that K is a p -group for some prime p . Since G/K is nilpotent, then G has a normal Sylow p -subgroup. Write C=C_{p}\times H , where C_{p}\in{\rm Syl}_{p}(C) . Notice that H is a p -complement of