Formal Manifold Structures on Positive Characteristic Varieties
Runjie Hu, Siqing Zhang · 2025
Read Formal Manifold Structures on Positive Characteristic Varieties by Runjie Hu, Siqing Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17221.txt.
Introduction
Runjie Hu and Siqing Zhang carry out a classic program in algebraic geometry in a 2025 paper. In 1970, Sullivan proposed that smooth varieties in positive characteristic should carry a formal manifold structure. He also predicted a Galois symmetry on those structures. The claims stayed open for many cases.
The paper establishes the claims for certain varieties. It links the predicted symmetry to the Galois symmetry of the varieties themselves. A second result ties simple connectedness to a lifting test. A variety matches a finite complex in the stated sense exactly when a lifting exists. The work joins homotopy theory with arithmetic geometry. Formal methods let manifold ideas enter a purely algebraic world. The authors frame the results as progress on a fifty-year-old vision. Specialists in etale homotopy are the main audience.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Runjie Hu, Siqing Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 137 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17221
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Formal Manifold Structures on Positive Characteristic Varieties Runjie Hu, Siqing Zhang Abstract . In his 1970 ICM report [ 36 ] , Sullivan proposes the program of l l -adic formalization of the concept of manifolds. In this program, he claims that smooth positive characteristic varieties should carry l l -adic formal manifold structures. He also claims the existence of an abelianized Galois symmetry on l l -adic formal manifold structures. This paper carries out this program, establishes the claims for certain varieties, and relates the abelianized Galois symmetry on l l -adic formal manifold structures to the Galois symmetry of varieties. Meanwhile, we prove that a simply-connected variety is l l -adic homotopic equivalent to a simply-connected finite CW complex if and only if the l l -profinite completion of its étale homotopy type admits an l l -local lifting. Introduction The Galois symmetry of \overline{\mathbb{Q}} or finite fields is used to prove the Adams conjecture by Sullivan in [ 37 ] and Quillen-Friedlander in [ 30 ] [ 14 ] . With this idea and the surgery theory, we l -adically complete the concept of manifolds to obtain the so-called l -adic formal manifold structures, and construct an abelianized Galois symmetry on them. Within this framework, we prove that the Frobenius action on positive characteristic varieties, the Galois symmetry on characteristic zero varieties and the abelianized Galois symmetry on l -adic formal manifolds can be unified. This paper is divided into three parts: firstly we prove that simply-connected varieties are homotopically finite CW complexes in the l -adic sense with l away from the characteristic when certain topological conditions hold; then we develop the theory of l -adic formal manifolds for simply-connected finite CW complexes and include smooth projective varieties as examples; lastly we unify the Galois symmetry on varieties and that on l -adic normal structure sets (intuitively, they are a generalized version of the set of all l -adic formal manifolds in an l -adic homotopy type). Finiteness results. In his letter to Larry Breen, Grothendieck explains his vision on representing the ‘‘homotopy types’’ of good schemes by finite polyhedra. 1 1 1 In [ 17 ] *p. 45, Appendix §17, he writes: “… In the case of a scheme of finite type on an algebraically closed field k say, the strongest cohomological and homotopical finiteness theorem would be expressed precisely in terms of a fine homotopy type, and would say that the ordinary homotopy types which are their constituents are essentially “finite polyhedra” - and even compact manifolds with boundary - or in more precise fashion, their profinite completions (in the sense of Artin-Mazur) prime to the characteristic p of k are those of such polyhedra. One sees clearly how to begin on such programme in characteristic 0 , but one foresees supplementary amusement, or even mystery, in the case p>0 , for the varieties which, even birationally, resist being lifted to characteristic 0 !” In the first part of this paper, we investigate the simply connected case of this vision. Recall that the l -profinite completion of a group is the inverse limit of all finite quotients of G with l -primary order. This procedure can be generalized to any space. The fundamental group of the l -adic completion Y^{\wedge}_{l} of a space Y is the l -adic completion of \pi_{1}(Y) . If Y is a simply-connected finite CW complex, each homotopy group of Y^{\wedge}_{l} is the l -adic completion of the corresponding homotopy group of Y . The concept of l -adic complete spaces can be used to study algebraic varieties. Concretely, for any variety X , the étale fundamental group and étale cohomology can be upgraded to a (pro) homotopy type X_{\et} by Artin-Mazur ( [ 2 ] ). If X is a complex variety, then the l -adic completion X_{\et,l}^{\wedge} of X_{\et} is homotopy equivalent to that of the analytification of X . The first result of this paper is the following. Theorem 0.1 ( Homotopical Finiteness , Theorem 1.2 and Corollaries 1.4 , 1.5 ) . Let X be a pointed, connected variety over a separably closed field k of characteristic p\geq 0 . Let l be a prime number. Assume that either l\neq p or X is complete. Further assume that the l -adic completion of the étale fundamental group \pi_{1}^{\et}(X)^{\wedge}_{l}=0 . Then (1) each homotopy group \pi_{i}(X^{\wedge}_{\et,l}) of the l -profinite completion X^{\wedge}_{\et,l} of the étale homotopy type X_{\et} is a finitely generated \widehat{\mathbb{Z}}_{l} -module; (2) X_{\et} is l -adic homotopy equivalent to a simply-connected finite polyhedron, if and only if it is l -adic homotopy equivalent to a simply-connected complex variety, if and only if X^{\wedge}_{\et,l} admits an l -local lifting (see Definition 1.9 ). The same results of item (1) also hold for many other cases, such as the étale homotopy types of suitable topoi. It can also be deduced from [ 23 , Theorem 3.4.12] , which is proved using the \mathbb{E}_{\infty} -algebra structure on the singular cochains. Our proof is more elementary, based on inductive arguments using Postnikov tower and Leray-Serre spectral sequence. One technical difficulty arises when we try to apply topological results of CW complexes to pro-spaces: homotopy inverse limits do not commute with the homology functor H_{*}(-;A) even for a finite coefficient A in general ( [ 16 ] ). Another difficulty is that Serre’s mod- \mathcal{C} Hurewicz theorem does not apply since the class of finitely generated \widehat{\mathbb{Z}}_{l} -modules does not satisfy Serre’s axioms ( \text{II}_{A} ) and (III) as in [ 32 ] . In item (2), the notion “ l -local lifting” for a simply-connected, l -complete space Y means that it is the l -profinite completion of some simply-connected, l -local space. An algebraic chain model description for this might be interesting. The item (2) provides a necessary condition for lifting an l -adic-simply-connected positive characteristic variety to a complex variety with finite fundamental group (see Corollary 1.6 ). l -adic Formal Manifolds In the surgery theory, a simply-connected topological manifold is a homotopy type equipped with a Poincaré duality and a geometric bundle structure on the canonical spherical fibration induced by the Poincaré duality (the so-called Spivak normal spherical fibration). An l -adic formal manifold is the l -adic completion of the above data for a manifold. More concretely, we first prove the following theorem, which is the l -adic version of existence and uniqueness of a homotopy tangent bundle on a Poincaré duality space. Theorem 0.2 (Theorems 2.33 and 2.36 ) . Any simply-connected finite CW complex with \mathbb{Z}/l -coefficient Poincaré duality admits a mod- l Spivak normal spherical fibration as in Definition 2.31 , unique up to the equivalences as in Definition 2.35 . For the uniqueness part, we need the l -adic version of Spanier-Whitehead duality theory, which is developed in Section 2.1 . l -adic formal manifolds are defined as follows. This concept is vaguely suggested by Sullivan in [ 36 ] . Definition 0.3 (Definition 3.3 ) . An l -adic formal manifold structure on a \mathbb{Z}/l -coefficient Poincaré duality space Z is a lifting of its mod- l Spivak normal spherical fibration \nu_{Z} to a topological bundle of Eulidean spaces