Scalable Permutation-Aware Modeling for Temporal Set Prediction
Ashish Ranjan, Ayush Agarwal, Shalin Barot, Sushant Kumar · 2025
Read Scalable Permutation-Aware Modeling for Temporal Set Prediction by Ashish Ranjan, Ayush Agarwal, Shalin Barot, Sushant Kumar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17140.txt.
Introduction
Ashish Ranjan, Ayush Agarwal, Shalin Barot, and Sushant Kumar present a faster method for predicting sets over time, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. The task is to guess which items will appear in the next set, given a history of sets whose members arrive in no fixed order. Past methods used heavy designs that train and run slowly.
Their design respects the fact that order inside a set does not matter, using transforms built for that trait. This cuts both training and run time by a large margin. On several public benchmarks, accuracy matched or beat the best prior methods across standard scores. The authors offer the design as a practical base for large-scale set forecasting.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ashish Ranjan, Ayush Agarwal, Shalin Barot, Sushant Kumar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17140
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scalable Permutation-Aware Modeling for Temporal Set Prediction Ashish Ranjan, Ayush Agarwal, Shalin Barot, Sushant Kumar Abstract . Temporal set prediction involves forecasting the elements that will appear in the next set, given a sequence of prior sets, each containing a variable number of elements. Existing methods often rely on intricate architectures with substantial computational overhead, which hampers their scalability. In this work, we introduce a novel and scalable framework that leverages permutation-equivariant and permutation-invariant transformations to efficiently model set dynamics. Our approach significantly reduces both training and inference time while maintaining competitive performance. Extensive experiments on multiple public benchmarks show that our method achieves results on par with or superior to state-of-the-art models across several evaluation metrics. These results underscore the effectiveness of our model in enabling efficient and scalable temporal set prediction. CCS: Information systems Temporal and sequential data 1. Introduction Temporal Set Prediction addresses the problem of predicting which elements belong to the next set, given a sequence of sets. The problem involves identifying patterns in how sets evolve over time—tracking which elements enter, exit, or remain—and using these patterns to make accurate membership predictions. This approach enables precise, element-level forecasting for applications ranging from optimizing supply chains to anticipating traffic congestion points, where knowing exactly "which ones" provides more actionable insights than aggregate predictions. However, despite the importance of accurate element-level predictions, existing methods face significant computational challenges with large temporal sets. Attention-based mechanisms typically scale quadratically with sequence length, while many graph-based approaches have quadratic or worse complexity relative to the number of elements. These computational constraints limit applicability to real-world scenarios where both the universe of elements and the sequence length can be substantial. For dynamic environments requiring frequent updates, such as real-time recommendation systems or network monitoring, these performance limitations become particularly problematic. In this paper, we propose an architecture called PIETSP for temporal set prediction that reduces computational complexity to \mathcal{O}(N(KD+D^{2})+|E|D) , where N is the number of distinct elements in a sequence of sets, K is the maximum sequence length, D is the embedding dimension, and |E| is the domain of all possible elements (vocabulary size). This represents a significant improvement over conventional attention or graph based approaches which typically incur quadratic complexities in N or K . The proposed architecture offers both scalability and accuracy in predicting set membership at future time points. Our contributions include: • A mathematically principled formulation of temporal set prediction that integrates element features and their temporal dynamics in a joint representation, allowing for more accurate and efficient predictions. • A novel algorithm that achieves linear scaling with respect to both sequence length and number of distinct elements independently, thus enabling the processing of large-scale datasets in a computationally efficient manner. • Comprehensive empirical evaluation on publicly available datasets, demonstrating that our approach offers comparable or superior performance to existing state-of-the-art methods while significantly reducing computational requirements. 2. Related Work Temporal Set Prediction. Temporal Set Prediction (TSP) represents a well-established generalization of sequence prediction that models the evolution of sequences of unordered sets rather than sequences of individual elements. This formulation naturally arises in domains such as next-basket recommendation, electronic health record (EHR) modeling and course enrollment prediction, where each interaction is better represented as a set of elements rather than a single element. One of the earliest works, Sets2Sets by Hu and He (2019) , laid foundational ideas for TSP by treating the problem as a sequential sets-to-sets learning task using an RNN encoder-decoder structure. It introduces a set-attention mechanism and a repeated elements module to model intra and inter-set dependencies. While effective, the reliance on recurrent structures limits parallelism and leads to slower training and inference times, especially as the sequence length increases. DNNTSP ( Yu et al., 2020 ) extends this framework by incorporating dynamic co-occurrence graphs and using graph convolutional networks (GCNs) to enhance inter-item relations. A temporal attention layer helps capture sequential dynamics, and a gated fusion unit combines static and dynamic embeddings. While DNNTSP improves expressiveness, it introduces nontrivial space complexity due to the graph construction and GCN operations, making it less scalable for large datasets with high-cardinality item spaces. More recently, SFCNTSP ( Yu et al., 2023 ) proposes a lightweight linear architecture based on Simplified Fully Connected Networks (SFCNs), avoiding nonlinearities and recurrence. By designing permutation invariant and equivariant modules, it achieves significant reductions in parameter count and inference time, making it more suitable for industrial applications. However, despite these efficiency improvements, its computational requirements remain substantial when scaling to large datasets. Next Basket and Set Prediction. TSP is closely aligned with next-basket recommendation, where the goal is to predict the next set of items a user will interact with. Early models such as FPMC ( Rendle et al., 2010 ) combine matrix factorization with Markov Chains to model user preferences and item transitions. While efficient, FPMC lacks the ability to model inter-item dependencies within a basket and does not generalize well to cold or rare items. Additionally, models such as SHAN ( Ying et al., 2018 ) and SASRec ( Kang and McAuley, 2018 ) introduced self-attention mechanisms to this task, but their adaptation to set sequences is limited, as attention is inherently order-sensitive and does not handle set permutation-invariance without explicit modification. Multiset Modeling and Repetition. A defining feature of TSP, and a gap in traditional sequential models, is the ability to handle repeated elements—important in domains like healthcare (e.g., recurring diagnoses, lab tests) and e-commerce (e.g., repeated purchases). Sets2Sets and DNNTSP directly model repetition via frequency-aware loss functions or modules that attend to past occurrences. However, these often assume hard duplication counts rather than modeling repetition as a stochastic process. Sequence-to-Sequence and Set Modeling. TSP extends the classic sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) framework popularized in NLP ( Sutskever et al., 2014 ; Bahdanau et al., 2014 ) , but demands adaptations for sets due to their unordered and variable-length nature. Key inspirations come from DeepSets ( Zaheer et al., 2017 ) , which introduced permutation-invariant functions for effective set representation. Building on this foundation, Set Transformers ( Lee et al., 2019 ) leverage attention mechanisms specifically designed for set inputs and outputs. SetVAE ( Kim et al., 2021 ) further advances this line of research by enabling generative modeling of unordered outputs with improved computational efficiency. While standard Transformer-based approaches often suffer from quadratic complexity in set size, SetVAE employs architectural innovations to mitigate this limitation. However, challenges remain in capturing sequential dependencies when these models are applied to problems requiring both set-level operations and order-sensitive processing. 3. Problem Formulation Figure 1. Architecture of the proposed model. The input sets and element sequence features are combined using the Sequence Feature Integration (SFI) layer and passed through permutation-equivariant (PE) and permutation-invariant (PI) blocks, followed by both element-wise (EE) and global evaluators(GE) producing the final prediction. Let S(t_{i})\subseteq E represent the set of all elements present at time t_{i} , where E is the domain of possible elements. Let \mathcal{S}=\left[S(t_{1}),S(t_{2}),\ldots,S(t_{T})\right] be the sequence of sets across T time steps, where 1\leq T\leq K and K=\max\{|\mathcal{S}_{j}|:\mathcal{S}_{j}\in\mathcal{D}\} is the maximum set sequence length across the dataset \mathcal{D} . Let U=\bigcup_{i=1}^{T}S(t_{i}) be the universe of all distinct elements that appear in any