Cybernetic Governance in a Coliving House

Daniel Kronovet, Seth Frey, Joseph DeSimone · 2025

Read Cybernetic Governance in a Coliving House by Daniel Kronovet, Seth Frey, Joseph DeSimone (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17113.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Kronovet and co-authors report an eighteen-month experiment in running a shared house without bosses. The nine-bedroom Los Angeles coliving house kept 98 percent occupancy and below-market rents. Drawing on Elinor Ostrom's commons theory, the team built three digital tools to replace managers.

A chore market gives each resident a monthly duty of one hundred points, claimed from tasks whose value rises the longer they sit undone. A pairwise voting layer lets residents quietly reshuffle task priorities. A hearts ledger tracks rule keeping through light challenges and peer karma. Logs of hundreds of chore claims, heart events, and group purchases suggest the tooling can hold a commons together without steady leadership.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Kronovet, Seth Frey, Joseph DeSimone
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17113

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cybernetic Governance in a Coliving House Daniel Kronovet, Seth Frey, Joseph DeSimone Abstract We report an 18-month field experiment in distributed digital institutions : a nine-bedroom Los Angeles coliving house that runs without managers, while sustaining 98% occupancy and below-market rents. Drawing on Elinor Ostrom’s commons theory, we outline design principles and three digital mechanisms that form the institutional core: 1) A continuous-auction chore scheduler turns regenerative labor into a time-indexed points market; residents meet a 100-point monthly obligation by claiming tasks whose value rises linearly with neglect. 2) A pairwise-preference layer lets participants asynchronously reprioritize tasks, translating meta-governance into low-cognition spot inputs. 3) A symbolic “hearts” ledger tracks norm compliance through automated enforcement, lightweight challenges, and peer-awarded karma. Together, these mechanisms operationalize cybernetic principles—human sensing, machine bookkeeping, real-time feedback—while minimizing dependence on privileged roles. Our exploratory data (567 chore claims, 255 heart events, and 551 group purchases) show that such tooling can sustain reliable commons governance without continuous leadership, offering a transferable design palette for online communities, coliving houses, and other digitally mediated collectives. 1 Introduction There is an aphorism attributed to Dorothy Day of the Catholic Workers Movement: “Everybody wants a revolution, but nobody wants to do the dishes.” All too often coliving communities form full of enthusiasm, only to crumble when confronted with the boring but essential regenerative labor of daily life. Individuals shirk responsibilities, leaders burn out, and people leave feeling cynical and defeated. Can we do better? This paper will present a case study of Sage House, a non-hierarchical coliving house which self-regulates using computational tools. Sage is a 9-bedroom house in Highland Park, Los Angeles, continuously operating since September 2022. Sixteen people have lived in the house since opening, with an average tenure of 11 months and an overall occupancy rate of 98%. Sage is ‘‘naturally affordable’’ in that it offers low-market rents without reliance on external support -- achieved largely through the operational innovations presented here. 1 1 1 While not the focus of this paper, our discussion has significant implications for housing affordability. High-touch management can add 10% or more to housing costs. The house is co-owned by one of the authors, Daniel Kronovet, who also led the renovation, lived in the house in its first year of operation, and continues to play a limited administrative role. Much of the ethnographic perspective on Sage is drawn from Daniel’s experience. The computational suite, known as Chore Wheel ( Kronovet et al. 2020 , Kronovet et al. 2020 ), was designed in close reference to Elinor Ostrom’s theory of institutional design. With the aid of this suite, the regenerative labor burden is fairly and transparently distributed among the residents, with minimal need for unsustainable individual leadership or intensive deliberative processes. This low contribution requirement, approximately 2-4 hours of chores and one 90-minute meeting per month, has made Sage resilient to turnover and interpersonal conflict and allows the house to operate continuously at low cost. To frame our case study, we will explore two motivating themes : that of the institutional role of leadership, and of the regulatory potential of cybernetic systems driven endogenously by time. Regarding leadership , Ostrom 1990 ( Ostrom 1990 ) discusses the theoretical challenge associated with institutional production. Defining institutions as “prescriptions [used] to organize … repetitive and structured interactions," Ostrom reasons that while agents can be incentivized within institutions, they cannot be incentivized to produce them. Institutional production, Ostrom concludes, comes from hard-to-theorize personal motivation, such as the drive for status or for creative expression. Another term for institutional production, for going beyond incentives, is leadership. In the context of this case study, we will characterize leadership as the performance and communication of high-order cognition (multi-step reasoning) on behalf of a group. In contrast, non-leadership is characterized as low-order cognition (one- or two-step reasoning) in response to environmental stimuli, including communications by leadership. Leadership is framed as an act of institutional production enabling non-leaders to perform coordinated activities through low-order responses to evolving informational contexts. Approaching the question of leadership from the perspective of game design, Koster 2018 ( Koster 2018 ) describes how certain game mechanics allow for low-trust “parallel play” (e.g. soccer) while others require high-trust coordinated action (e.g. trapeze). One of Koster’s conclusions is that parallel-play designs do not preclude the emergence of high-trust coordinated action, only that such games can be enjoyed without it. Compared to high-trust games, parallel-play games are more accessible, and thus more robust as institutions, without being limited in their potential for enabling deep experience. We suggest that over-reliance on leadership represents a type of institutional fragility. Good leaders are rare, and communities which rely on consistent leadership are vulnerable to disruption. One can pay for leadership, but it is expensive, and financial incentives can introduce alignment problems. Further, explicit assignment of leadership implicitly assigns others to non-leadership. The more that all participants can temporarily assume leadership roles, the greater the total leadership resources the organization can draw upon ( Laloux 2014 , Laloux 2014 ). A resilient institution is one which can benefit from periodic expressions of leadership without being dependent on them. Regarding cybernetics , Beer (1973) advocates for computers as essential tools in a technologically advanced society. For Beer, the computer is a machine which can make the static dynamic , and thus more concisely representative of an evolving world. By making complex information legible, and by incorporating ongoing human feedback, the computer takes on a meaningful coordinating role. In his work, Beer draws on the influence of pioneering cyberneticist W. Ross Ashby, who as Lewis and Aligica 2024 ( Lewis and Aligica 2024 ) noted, exerted significant influence on the Ostroms themselves. Ashby is known for his “Law of Requisite Variety,” which states that the number of possible states (variety) in the system must be matched by the number of possible states in the regulator. Succintly, a regulator must be as expressive as that which it regulates . For Beer, the use of computers as dynamic tools allows them to more fully capture the variety inherent in a complex society, turning them into indispensable aids for navigating an ever-changing world. In conventional organizations, resources are at rest until energy is spent putting them into motion: we “go to mangement” to beg funding for our projects. In contrast, through the use of computers, resources can be kept in perpetual motion over time , enabling new and more expressive classes of asynchronous interactions ( Rea et al. 2018 , Rea et al. 2018 , Tan et al. 2023 , Tan et al. 2023 ). As Beer writes, the static quarterly report can be replaced by real-time representations of value flows, enabling organizational members to respond proactively and autonomously to new information and opportunities. At the intersection of these thematic lines is the idea that computational systems can be developed which preserve and integrate continual but intermittent contributions of leadership , while providing useful structure continuously to non-leaders . A defining feature of these systems is the use of time and feedback loops to turn the computer into an active and enabling force in organizational life. Through the application of these design techniques, the leadership burden can be both reduced

Read the complete text