Structural roles and gender disparities in corruption networks

Arthur A. B. Pessa, Alvaro F. Martins, Mônica V. Prates, Sebastian Gonçalves, Cristina Masoller, Matjaž Perc, Haroldo V. Ribeiro · 2025

Read Structural roles and gender disparities in corruption networks by Arthur A. B. Pessa, Alvaro F. Martins, Mônica V. Prates, Sebastian Gonçalves, Cristina Masoller, Matjaž Perc, Haroldo V. Ribeiro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-17086.txt.

Introduction

Pessa and co-authors dissect the role of gender inside corruption networks in Brazil and Spain. Crime skews male almost everywhere, yet how women sit inside organized wrongdoing is poorly mapped. The team built networks from political scandal records in both countries, linking everyone named in each case. Women made up about ten percent of agents in Brazil and twenty percent in Spain, shares steady across years and scandal sizes.

By most centrality measures, women and men looked alike once inside. The exception sat at the very top, where the most central figures skewed even more male. Removing either gender hurt the networks equally. Men were likelier to appear in multiple scandals, but a chance-based model explained that gap by numbers alone. Same-gender linking ran high in Spain's male majority beyond chance. The authors read the story as underrepresentation first, structure second.

Catalog record

CREATORArthur A. B. Pessa, Alvaro F. Martins, Mônica V. Prates, Sebastian Gonçalves, Cristina Masoller, Matjaž Perc, Haroldo V. Ribeiro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-17086

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Structural roles and gender disparities in corruption networks Arthur A. B. Pessa, Alvaro F. Martins, Mônica V. Prates, Sebastian Gonçalves, Cristina Masoller, Matjaž Perc, Haroldo V. Ribeiro Abstract Criminal activities are predominantly due to males, with females exhibiting a significantly lower involvement, especially in serious offenses. This pattern extends to organized crime, where females are often perceived as less tolerant to illegal practices. However, the roles of males and females within corruption networks are less understood. Here, we analyze data from political scandals in Brazil and Spain to shed light on gender differences in corruption networks. Our findings reveal that females constitute 10% and 20% of all agents in the Brazilian and Spanish corruption networks, respectively, with these proportions remaining stable over time and across different scandal sizes. Despite this disparity in representation, centrality measures are comparable between genders, except among highly central individuals, for which males are further overrepresented. Additionally, gender has no significant impact on network resilience, whether through random dismantling or targeted attacks on the largest component. Males are more likely to be involved in multiple scandals than females, and scandals predominantly involving females are rare, though these differences are explained by a null network model in which gender is randomly assigned while maintaining gender proportions. Our results further reveal that the underrepresentation of females partially explains gender homophily in network associations, although in the Spanish network, male-to-male connections exceed expectations derived from a null model. Introduction Criminology literature consistently highlights substantial disparities in offending rates between males and females, with males being responsible for the majority of crimes [ 1 , 2 ] . This pattern extends to corruption-related offenses, where experimental research suggests that females typically demonstrate lower tolerance for dishonesty and exhibit more pro-social behavior [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Controlled experiments further indicate that, on average, females offer smaller bribes than males, and interactions exclusively between females tend to exhibit higher levels of honesty compared to those involving at least one male [ 5 , 6 ] . Additionally, studies report positive correlations between female participation in government and reduced perceptions of corruption in democratic countries [ 4 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] , suggesting that increased female representation in public offices and civil service also serves as a potential anti-corruption measure [ 3 , 10 , 11 ] . Research also indicates reductions in procurement-related corruption in French municipalities led by female mayors, although reelected female mayors exhibit no significant difference in corruption levels compared to their male counterparts [ 12 ] . This finding suggests that, over time, females in leadership positions may integrate into existing political networks or establish new ones that are not necessarily less corrupt [ 13 , 12 ] . Despite numerous recent studies on the dynamics and inner workings of political corruption networks [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] , organized crime [ 18 , 19 ] , mafia groups [ 20 , 21 ] , and other offenses committed through associations of individuals [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] , the role of gender in such networked crimes, particularly political corruption, remains relatively underexplored. A notable exception is the work by Smith [ 26 ] , which examined gender disparities in Chicago’s organized crime before and after the alcohol prohibition of 1920, revealing that the prohibition expanded opportunities for males while largely excluding females. This emerging research field holds significant potential for advancing academic understanding and equipping security forces with better tools for decision-making, particularly when enhanced by collaboration between law enforcement and academia. For instance, an empirical investigation into criminal networks assessed the impact of law enforcement interventions on the structure and functioning of a dark web pedophile network [ 22 ] , showing that the resulting dismantling resembled random node removal and was less effective than more optimized removal strategies. Other studies [ 27 , 28 ] showed that leveraging criminal network structures in combination with machine learning approaches yields impressive accuracy in recovering missing criminal partnerships, distinguishing types of criminal associations, predicting money flow among criminals, and even anticipating future partnerships and re-offending behavior. Recent studies analyzing security intelligence data [ 29 , 30 ] proposed a novel protocol for network disruption through key-agent identification, showing its effectiveness in enabling law enforcement to identify and assess criminal activity. Another recent study on a dark web pedophile ring [ 31 ] used network tools to analyze user behavior, revealing crucial insights into temporal engagement patterns, content preferences, and user clusters. Research on networked crime has thus demonstrated that the structure of criminal networks is highly informative about various nuances of criminal activity [ 32 ] . Therefore, it is critical to analyze possible disparities in the roles occupied by males and females within these networks. This issue parallels other gender-based analyses in fields such as education [ 33 , 34 ] , scientific careers [ 35 , 36 ] , representation in literary works [ 37 ] , membership in artistic and scientific academies [ 38 , 39 , 40 ] , and online biographies [ 41 ] , to name just a few, and may offer valuable perspectives on gender differences in networked crime. Here, we analyze data from political corruption scandals in Brazil [ 14 ] and Spain [ 42 ] , spanning from the 1990s to the 2010s, to construct corruption networks in which agents are connected when they collaborate in the same scandal. Gender labels are assigned to each network node based on the identification of individual names, allowing us to examine the structural roles of males and females within these networks. Consistent with the criminology literature, we find that males constitute the vast majority of corrupt agents, with females representing only 10% of nodes in the Brazilian network and 20% of nodes in the Spanish network – fractions that are at least partly explained by very low participation in politics, high-ranking positions in the private sector, and other leadership roles [ 43 , 44 , 45 , 38 ] . Based on this disparity, we adapt a model capable of reproducing several properties of these corruption networks [ 42 ] to simulate networks where gender is randomly assigned to nodes while preserving the observed male-to-female ratios. These in silico networks serve as null models for quantifying the significance of differences in network properties and determining whether these differences can be attributed solely to the disparity in gender representation. We examine the role of gender in centrality measures, network resilience, reoffending rates, and collaboration patterns, finding no significant gender differences overall, or that existing differences are at least partially explained by our null network model. The only exceptions refer to an overrepresentation of males among highly central individuals and a higher degree of gender homophily in collaboration patterns observed in the Spanish network, which cannot be accounted for by the null model. Our findings thus indicate a markedly low prevalence of females in political corruption cases; however, once this disparity is taken into account, the structural roles of these networked criminals appear to be largely invariant with respect to gender. Interestingly, these findings align with existing research on

Read the complete text