Magnetorotational instability in a solar near-surface mean-field dynamo
Axel Brandenburg, Gustav Larsson, Fabio Del Sordo, Petri J. Käpylä · 2025
Read Magnetorotational instability in a solar near-surface mean-field dynamo by Axel Brandenburg, Gustav Larsson, Fabio Del Sordo, Petri J. Käpylä (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16849.txt.
Introduction
Axel Brandenburg and co-authors ask whether a rotation-driven instability can run inside the Sun's near-surface shear layer. Their 2025 paper simulates mean-field dynamos in rotating, shearing boxes. The magnetorotational instability needs the field strong enough and the shear of the right sign.
Above a threshold shear the instability did switch on for negative shear. Like the classic omega effect, it wound up toroidal field. Oddly, the work flowed from field to motion: magnetic energy paid for strong kinetic churning. For the real Sun, the authors judge the turbulent diffusion too strong. The instability likely stays off, leaving the standard effect in charge.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Axel Brandenburg, Gustav Larsson, Fabio Del Sordo, Petri J. Käpylä |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16849
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Magnetorotational instability in a solar near-surface mean-field dynamo Axel Brandenburg, Gustav Larsson, Fabio Del Sordo, Petri J. Käpylä Abstract We address the question whether the magnetorotational instability (MRI) can operate in the near-surface shear layer (NSSL) of the Sun and how it affects the interaction with the dynamo process. Using hydromagnetic mean-field simulations of α Ω \alpha\Omega -type dynamos in rotating shearing-periodic boxes, we show that for negative shear, the MRI can operate above a certain critical shear parameter. This parameter scales inversely with the equipartition magnetic field strength above which α \alpha quenching set in. Like the usual Ω \Omega effect, the MRI produces toroidal magnetic field when the field is sufficiently strong. The work done by the Lorentz force is positive, so the magnetic field drives kinetic energy and not the other way around, as in a turbulent dynamo. This results in strong kinetic energy production and dissipation, which occurs at the expense of the magnetic energy. In view of the application to the solar NSSL, we conclude that the turbulent magnetic diffusivity may be too large for the MRI to be excited and that therefore only the standard Ω \Omega effect is expected to operate. I Introduction The magnetorotational instability (MRI) provides a source of turbulence in accretion discs, where it feeds on Keplerian shear to turn potential energy into kinetic and magnetic energies; see [ 5 ] for a review. For the MRI to be excited, the angular velocity \Omega must decrease with increasing distance \varpi from the rotation axis, i.e., \partial\Omega/\partial\varpi<0 . There must also be a moderately strong magnetic field. This condition is obeyed not only in accretion discs, but also in stars like the Sun, where both requirements may be satisfied in the near-surface shear layer (NSSL), the outer 4% of the solar radius [ 74 ] . This motivated [ 85 ] to study the excitation properties of the MRI in the NSSL of the Sun using spherical global modes. The possible relevance of the MRI for stellar radiative zones has been discussed for a long time [ 4 , 83 , 56 ] . [ 59 ] proposed that small-scale magnetorotational turbulence prevents coherent magnetic dynamo action in the tachocline at higher latitudes. They argued that this could explain the latitudinal restriction of solar active regions to the vicinity of the equator. [ 53 ] suggested that the MRI could play a role in maintaining thermal wind balance in the Sun. [ 38 ] found that nonaxisymmetric MRI modes tend to grow faster in the Sun than the corresponding axisymmetric modes. [ 88 ] found the MRI to play a role in the later stages of massive star evolution. Unlike the recent work by [ 85 ] , these papers only considered local analyses. In addition to the Sun and other stars, proto-neutron stars represent a particularly important application [ 65 ] . In the Sun’s outer 30% by radius there is convection converting part of the Sun’s thermal energy into kinetic energy. The nonuniform rotation of the Sun is explained by the fact that the convection is anisotropic such that solid-body rotation is no longer a solution to a rotating fluid even in the absence of external torques [ 49 , 87 , 42 , 46 , 68 , 21 ] . This causes also the emergence of the aforementioned NSSL [ 70 , 43 , 44 ] . In addition, small-scale [ 55 , 58 , 12 , 24 ] and large-scale [ 40 , 36 , 54 , 23 ] magnetic fields exist as a result of the convective turbulence. The presence of radial stratification in density and/or turbulent intensity, together with global rotation, causes the occurrence of large-scale magnetic fields [ 57 , 60 , 47 , 91 ] . Thus, in the Sun, the two ingredients of the MRI—differential rotation and magnetic fields—are ultimately caused by the underlying convection. [ 85 ] argue that an initial poloidal magnetic field is only present at the start of the cycle to get the MRI excited. Furthermore, they argue that the MRI itself is important in driving the dynamo process. However, the magnetic field required to sustain the MRI to work must come from a dynamo process and cannot rely on the initial field. To address the question of whether or not the MRI is excited and whether it contributes to shaping the Sun’s magnetic field to display equatorward migration of a global large-scale magnetic field, we need to separate the MRI-driven flows from the convection. One approach is to ignore convection but to retain some of its secondary effects, i.e., the NSSL with \partial\Omega/\partial\varpi<0 and magnetic fields; see the discussion by [ 85 ] and an appraisal by [ 92 ] . Another approach, the one taken here, is to average over the convection. By employing azimuthal averages, one is left with a stationary, nonturbulent background. Furthermore, correlations among different components of the fluctuating parts of the turbulent velocity and magnetic fields emerge that are parameterized in terms of (i) diffusive contributions, such as turbulent viscosity and turbulent magnetic diffusion, and (ii) nondiffusive contributions such as \Lambda and \alpha effects. There is no universal agreement about the relevance of these effects [ 77 , 35 , e.g.,] . In the mean-field description of the Sun, they are crucial effects able to explain the production of differential rotation and large-scale magnetic fields [ 69 ] . These effects can explain the NSSL and the large-scale magnetic field by solving the averaged form of the underlying equations [ 62 ] ; see [ 11 ] for a review. Apart from the \alpha effect, there are also several other mean-field effects that can produce large-scale magnetic fields: turbulent pumping with a time delay, negative turbulent magnetic diffusivity, the Rädler effect, the shear–current effect, and the incoherent \alpha –shear effect; see Table 2 of [ 17 ] . In addition, in phenomenological studies of solar magnetism, the decay of active regions is sometimes associated with a dynamo effect [ 50 ] . In its simplest form, however, it is just an \alpha effect [ 78 ] . In a more advanced formulation, it can be written as a nonlocal \alpha effect; see [ 26 ] for an example implementation in a mean-field model and [ 13 ] for results regarding the effect on magnetic helicity conservation in the Sun. In any case, it would not be possible to adopt such an effect here due to the top–bottom symmetry of our model. In principle, it is possible to study the interaction between the MRI and the dynamo in fully three-dimensional turbulence simulations. However, the essentials of these processes may well be captured in a mean-field approach. Using direct numerical simulations with forced turbulence, [ 84 ] demonstrated that the onset of the MRI is consistent with what is expected from mean-field estimates. In particular, the onset requires larger magnetic Reynolds numbers than in the ideal case due to the action of turbulent diffusion. Averaging over the convective motions of the Sun has been done previously in the context of mean-field hydrodynamics with the \Lambda effect. When including compressibility and thermodynamics, it was