A Note on the Stability of the Dark Energy Model from Time Crystals

Laura Mersini-Houghton · 2025

Read A Note on the Stability of the Dark Energy Model from Time Crystals by Laura Mersini-Houghton (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16764.txt.

Introduction

Laura Mersini-Houghton writes a short 2025 note on a model that casts dark energy as a kind of time crystal, a system that ticks in a steady rhythm. A past critique had questioned whether the model stays stable. The note argues that two facts change the verdict. The field at the model's heart is coupled to gravity. The crystals also sit in a universe that expands. In that frame, a drag term grows with time. With those facts in place, the author holds, the worry about stability eases.

Catalog record

CREATORLaura Mersini-Houghton
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16764

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Note on the Stability of the Dark Energy Model from Time Crystals Laura Mersini-Houghton Abstract In this note, we investigate the stability of the dark energy model from time crystals proposed in laura1 . We emphasize two ingredients, the coupling of the scalar field to gravity, and the fact that these times crystals are on an expanding FRW background, which play a crucial role in the field’s dynamics. The Hubble parameter, which contributes a drag term to the equations of motion, grows with time until the scale factor diverges. When taken into account, these factors also alleviate the stability concerns of cline . Time crystals spontaneously break time translation symmetry. They have been the subject of intense interest, since their discovery in Shapere2012 ; Wilczek2012 . Various mechanisms that produce time crystals have been proposed, ranging from non canonical scalar field models, to periodically driven Floquet quantum systems, disorder driven Anderson type localized waves, or two level systems, timecrystalreview . An attractive feature they share is their stability against perturbations. In laura1 the author observed that the original proposed model of time crystals has an equation of state reminiscent of phantom dark energy due to its non canonical nature. However, in contrast to k-essence models where the phantom field can explore large regions of space, in the time crystals model the field is confined to a small region of field space within the boundaries of the crystal. Non-canonical scalar field models have been extensively studied in cosmology due to their rich dynamics and potential to explain dark energy and inflationary phenomena ArmendarizPicon2000 ; Chiba2000 ; ArmendarizPicon2001 ; Melchiorri_2003 . A common concern has been the possibility of ghost or gradient instabilities (see nima and reference therein) in those models. As is well known, the coupling of the scalar fields to gravity in the expanding background of a Friedmann-Roberston-Walker (FRW) universe changes the stability requirements and often drives the field to an attractor point, nima ; ArmendarizPicon2001 ; Chiba2000 . Here we explore the stability of the model introduced in laura1 in the background of an FRW universe. The model presented in laura1 is described by the Lagrangian density \mathcal{L}=g(X)-V(\phi), (1) where \phi(t,x)=\phi_{0}(t)+\delta\phi(t,x) is a scalar field with a homogeneous background field \phi_{0} , (as is typical of inflationary fields), and perturbations around the background that depend on space and time. Here, X=\frac{1}{2}\nabla^{\mu}\phi\nabla_{\mu}\phi which for the homogeneous field simply becomes X=\frac{1}{2}\dot{\phi_{0}}^{2}>0 where the dot denotes a time derivative. V(\phi) is a positive semi-definite function of \phi ; g(X) is a non trivial function of X which for this model takes the form g(X)=-\kappa X+\lambda X^{2} (2) where \kappa,\lambda are positive constants. From now on, we will drop the index 0 on the background field \phi_{0} . For an ideal cosmic fluid, the field’s Lagrangian and its Hamiltonian become, respectively, the pressure p(X,\phi) , and the energy density \rho(X,\phi) of the fluid. In cline the author raised stability concerns about laura1 , while setting the Hubble parameter H=0 ignoring the coupling of the field to gravity and its propagation on an expanding background. (Furthermore, the author approximated <\frac{\partial\rho}{\partial X}>=<\rho_{X}>\simeq\kappa\ >0 while, in fact, inside the crystal <\rho_{X}>\simeq-\kappa/2<0 , required by the positivity of the speed of sound squared for the phantom field. Their latter assumption on a positive <\rho_{X}> changed the overall sign of the total energy of perturbations, even for H=0 .) The model of laura1 was constrained by three requirements: a phantom equation of state w<-1 that led to g^{\prime}(X)<0 therefore p_{X}<0 ; a nonnegative energy density \rho\geq 0 ; and a positive speed of sound squared c_{s}^{2}=\frac{p_{X}}{\rho_{X}}=\frac{g^{\prime}(X)}{g^{\prime}(X)+2Xg^{\prime\prime}(X)}\geq 0 , where prime in g^{\prime}(X) and p_{X},\rho_{X} denote derivatives of the respective quantities with X . Given that the phantom field requires w<-1 , therefore g^{\prime}(X),p_{X}<0 then a positive speed of sound further required \rho_{X}<0 . As shown in laura1 all of these conditions are satisfied inside the crystal region X\leq X_{t}=\frac{\kappa}{6\lambda} Here we investigate the possibility of ghost and gradient instabilities in the field’s perturbations in the context of an expanding background. We derive the equations of the scalar field and its perturbations and show that they are different from the ones presented in cline due to the fact that the field is coupled to gravity and it is propagating on an accelerated expanding background, factors that were not included in cline . First some preliminaries: The energy-momentum tensor for a scalar field in a flat Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) universe with metric ds^{2}=-dt^{2}+a(t)^{2}dx_{(3)}^{2} is given by: T_{\mu\nu}=\partial_{\mu}\phi\dfrac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial(\partial^{\nu}\phi)}-g_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{L}. (3) For a homogeneous scalar field \phi=\phi(t) , the corresponding energy density \rho and pressure p of the ideal fluid are: \displaystyle\rho \displaystyle=T^{0}_{\ 0}=\dot{\phi}\dfrac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\dot{\phi}}-\mathcal{L}, (4) \displaystyle p \displaystyle=-\dfrac{1}{3}T^{i}_{\ i}=\mathcal{L}, (5) where i runs over spatial indices. The relevant Einstein equations that are sufficient for describing the ideal fluid are the Friedmann equation and the Bianchi identity. The Friedman equation is (\frac{\dot{a}}{a})^{2}=H^{2}=\frac{8\pi G}{3}(\rho+\rho_{m}) (6) where a(t) is the scale factor of the FRW metric and H the Hubble parameter, \rho_{m}, some matter energy density ingredient, and \dot{}=d/dt . The matter component which at present time t_{0} accounts for less than 30\% soon dilutes away and the future cosmic evolution is solely governed by the phantom field. The Bianchi identity of the phantom fluid is \dot{\rho}+3\frac{\dot{a}}{a}(\rho+p)=0 (7) The non canonical conjugate momenta \Pi , obtained as a derivative of \mathcal{L} with respect to \dot{\phi} , is different from the kinetic momentum \dot{\phi} \Pi=\dfrac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\dot{\phi}}=g^{\prime}(X)\dfrac{\partial X}{\partial\dot{\phi}}=g^{\prime}(X)\dot{\phi}=\dot{\phi}[-\kappa+\lambda\dot{\phi}^{2}], (8) where g^{\prime}(X)=\dfrac{dg}{dX} and \dot{\phi}=\pm\sqrt{2X} . The Lagrangian equation of motion for the homogeneous solution is \frac{1}{a^{3}}\frac{da^{3}\Pi(X)}{dt}=\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\phi} (9) which gives, \displaystyle\rho_{X}\ddot{\phi}+3Hp_{X}\dot{\phi}+\frac{\partial V}{\partial\phi} \displaystyle=0, (10) \displaystyle\ddot{\phi}+3Hc_{s}^{2}\dot{\phi}+\frac{1}{\rho_{X}}\frac{\partial V}{\partial\phi} \displaystyle=0. (11) where c_{s}^{2} is the speed of sound squared which is positive within the crystal region. In the last line, Eqn. ( 11 ), we factored out \rho_{X} and used the definition of the speed of sound squared. Comparing the above field equation, Eqn. ( 11 ), with Eqn.2 of cline , reveals that coupling to gravity, therefore the Hubble drag term, where missing from cline . There is a general misconception that \rho_{X}<0 produces instabilities. This could be true and present a problem if this term produced a negative speed of sound squared, i.e. only for p_{X}>0 . However, as can be seen from Eqn. ( 11 ), in the present case the only influence a negative \rho_{X} term, (given that c_{s}^{2}>0 ), has in the field equation of motion is in inverting the potential energy term in the homogeneous mode and perturbations equations (below). Hence, the speed of sound squared multiplying the Hubble term plays a crucial role as this term dominates the equation. The potential term is insignificant compared to the Hubble drag term, therefore it doesn’t control the dynamics of the field. In short, stability of the model depends on the ratio of p_{X} and \rho_{X} . For as long as their ratio equal to the speed of sound squared c_{s}^{2}=p_{X}/\rho_{X}>0 remains positive, the system is stable. Note that for a phantom field, the Hubble parameter grows with time, therefore the Hubble drag term quickly dominates over the potential term V(\phi) making it irrelevant even faster in the dynamics of the field. The growth of H,a(t),\rho can be found by solving the Friedmann equation and the Bianchi identity for a

Read the complete text