Mixing Data-Driven and Physics-Based Constitutive Models using Uncertainty-Driven Phase Fields

J. Storm, W. Sun, I. B. C. M. Rocha, F. P. van der Meer · 2025

Read Mixing Data-Driven and Physics-Based Constitutive Models using Uncertainty-Driven Phase Fields by J. Storm, W. Sun, I. B. C. M. Rocha, F. P. van der Meer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16713.txt.

Introduction

Storm, Sun, Rocha, and Van der Meer present a paper from twenty twenty-five on mixing data-driven and physics-based material models by uncertainty. Multiscale simulations need training data for fast surrogate models. Covering all load cases in training data is costly, though. Their mix uses a fast probabilistic surrogate where it is confident. Where doubt grows, it swaps back to the true high-fidelity model. A phase-field method governs the swap zones and keeps them smooth. Doubt from the surrogate drives the phase changes directly.

A purely local swap rule is compared against the smooth phase approach. Tests use a Gaussian process surrogate for an elastic-plastic material. The mix speeds multiscale runs while holding accuracy where it counts. The authors detail conditions for stable, exact results.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. Storm, W. Sun, I. B. C. M. Rocha, F. P. van der Meer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16713

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mixing Data-Driven and Physics-Based Constitutive Models using Uncertainty-Driven Phase Fields J. Storm, W. Sun, I. B. C. M. Rocha, F. P. van der Meer Abstract There is a high interest in accelerating multiscale models using data-driven surrogate modeling techniques. Creating a large training dataset encompassing all relevant load scenarios is essential for a good surrogate, yet the computational cost of producing this data quickly becomes a limiting factor. Commonly, a pre-trained surrogate is used throughout the computational domain. Here, we introduce an alternative adaptive mixture approach that uses a fast probabilistic surrogate model as constitutive model when possible, but resorts back to the true high-fidelity model when necessary. The surrogate is thus not required to be accurate for every possible load condition, enabling a significant reduction in the data collection time. We achieve this by creating phases in the computational domain corresponding to the different models. These phases evolve using a phase-field model driven by the surrogate uncertainty. When the surrogate uncertainty becomes large, the phase-field model causes a local transition from the surrogate to the high-fidelity model, maintaining a highly accurate simulation. We discuss the requirements of this approach to achieve accurate and numerically stable results and compare the phase-field model to a purely local approach that does not enforce spatial smoothness for the phase mixing. Using a Gaussian Process surrogate for an elasto-plastic material, we demonstrate the potential of this mixture of models to accelerate multiscale simulations. 1 Introduction Advanced manufacturing techniques allow for the creation of materials with properties tailored to their use. Multiscale modeling can accurately capture the behavior of these materials, yet its use is limited by the high computational cost of simulation. The need for more computationally efficient models, combined with the progress in machine learning, has resulted in numerous data-driven models [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Given sufficient data, these models often show an impressive ability to capture the behavior of complex history-dependent load paths. They can therefore be used as surrogates for the representative volume element (micromodel) in a multiscale analysis. However, obtaining the necessary training data from microscale simulations is very costly. Because purely data-driven methods might perform poorly in extrapolation, data requirements necessary to ensure fidelity tend to be high. In addition, it is often challenging to predict which loading scenarios will be relevant. The surrogate therefore needs to be trained across a broad range of inputs to generalize for unseen data, many of which may never be relevant during the target simulation. We can broadly categorize two (non-exclusive) approaches to dealing with this problem. The first is to embed a prior in the surrogate design, allowing the model to extrapolate constitutive responses from small datasets. Examples of these priors are leveraging the geometry or embedding physics into the model acting as an inductive bias [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . These models often have intermediate quantities or additional outputs with a physical meaning that can be leveraged during the training and inference process. The second approach is to use an active learning strategy instead of only using a pre-trained surrogate. In active learning, the surrogate is continuously retrained whenever it makes a poor prediction, avoiding the need for an all-encompassing dataset. Authors in [ 11 ] propose to use the uncertainty of a Gaussian Process (GP) surrogate to inform on-the-fly adaptivity. There, several fully-solved anchor models are used throughout the simulation to update the GP, triggered by the GP uncertainty. A similar adaptive approach, FE^{ANN} , stores all deformation gradients in a dataset, and by comparing the difference between the invariants of each new deformation to this dataset they can detect when an unseen deformation is encountered [ 12 ] . When this is the case, they perform new simulations, enrich the dataset, and retrain the neural network. Adaptively updating the surrogate during the simulation avoids the necessity for all scenarios to be covered in an extensive pre-training dataset. However, active learning does require the surrogate to be suitable for retraining. Furthermore, updating the surrogate can cause instabilities or slower convergence of the macroscopic solver. Instead of using the high-fidelity model just to update the surrogate, a mixture of several models can be applied. A common strategy is the use of clustering, where elements get clustered based on their response after an initial solve of the system, by classifying the inputs into predetermined clusters [ 13 ] . Alternatively, a mixture of a pre-trained neural network (NN) and a reduced order model (ROM) can be used throughout the domain [ 14 ] . After solving an FE 2 simulation with the NN surrogate at every point, a second run is performed where all points that reached values outside the NN training region during the first run are replaced with the ROM. To minimize unnecessary evaluations, the second run can also start with the NN at all points, and switch to the ROM only when strain values outside the NN training region occur. One of the challenges of these methods is avoiding instability of the finite element method (FEM) caused by stress jumps on boundaries between two models. One option to avoid these jumps between models is to introduce a transition zone in front of a crack based on the thick level set method [ 15 ] . From a machine learning perspective, these hybrid approaches are analogous to a mixture-of-experts model [ 16 ] , where we use domain-specific information to choose the expert. Alternatively, this also bears a resemblance to data assimilation methods, such as using a weighted least-squares finite element method to assimilate experimental data with numerical models [ 17 ] . In this work, we allow for adaptively using multiple constitutive models when and where necessary. Specifically, a probabilistic surrogate and the original model it was trained to replace are aggregated to make predictions. The main idea is to use the uncertainty in surrogate predictions to guide whether the surrogate or the original model should be used. For our motivation of accelerating multiscale simulations, the fast surrogate should be used when it has a low uncertainty, and the original model should be used otherwise. We use the idea of a weighted average transition zone and implement it using a phase field. The phase field promotes numerical stability, as it naturally introduces a spatial transition zone that is used to switch between the models. Phase-field models have been used to simulate the evolution of, among others, solidification [ 18 ] , grain growth [ 19 ] , and fracture [ 20 ] for several decades now. In a phase field, a scalar field variable \phi evolves, symbolizing, for example, the transition from a liquid state to a solid state in the context of a two-phase solidification system, or the shift from a solid area to a crack in crack propagation. Here, we use the phases for the different constitutive models. The uncertainty coming from the probabilistic surrogate drives the phase field evolution. At the diffuse interface between phases, we take a weighted average between model predictions to smoothly transition between the models. Using the phase field brings the cost of solving an additional partial

Read the complete text