Outer regions of galaxy clusters as a new probe to test modifications to gravity
Minahil Adil Butt, Sandeep Haridasu, Antonaldo Diaferio, Francesco Benetti, Yacer Boumechta, Carlo Baccigalupi, Andrea Lapi · 2025
Read Outer regions of galaxy clusters as a new probe to test modifications to gravity by Minahil Adil Butt, Sandeep Haridasu, Antonaldo Diaferio, Francesco Benetti, Yacer Boumechta, Carlo Baccigalupi, Andrea Lapi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16685.txt.
Introduction
Minahil Adil Butt and co-authors use the outer zones of galaxy clusters to test tweaks to gravity, in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. A method based on the edge of falling galaxies can weigh a cluster far from its core. The team stacked over a hundred clusters into four mass groups.
Mass reads from the edge method matched standard values within ten percent. The stacked profiles also fit the expected density shape for the standard cosmos model. That fit let the team set a tight cap on one gravity tweak, a chameleon-style model. The method opens the weak-gravity fringe of clusters as a testing ground.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Minahil Adil Butt, Sandeep Haridasu, Antonaldo Diaferio, Francesco Benetti, Yacer Boumechta, Carlo Baccigalupi, Andrea Lapi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16685
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Outer regions of galaxy clusters as a new probe to test modifications to gravity Minahil Adil Butt, Sandeep Haridasu, Antonaldo Diaferio, Francesco Benetti, Yacer Boumechta, Carlo Baccigalupi, Andrea Lapi Abstract We apply the caustic technique to samples of galaxy clusters stacked in redshift space to estimate the gravitational potential in the cluster’s outer region and test modifications to the standard theory of gravity. We separate 122 galaxy clusters from the HeCS-SZ, HeCS-redMapper, and HeCS samples into four samples with increasing mass; we estimate four robust, highly constraining caustic profiles for these samples. The caustic masses of the four stacked clusters agree within 10 % 10\% with the corresponding median values of each cluster sample. By adopting the NFW density profile to model the gravitational potential, we recover the caustic profile 𝒜 ( r ) \mathcal{A}(r) up to radius r p ∼ 4.0 Mpc r_{\rm p}\sim 4.0\,{\rm Mpc} . This comparison is a first-order validation of the mass-concentration relation for galaxy clusters expected in the Λ \Lambda CDM model. We thus impose this correlation as a prior in our analysis. Based on our stacked clusters, we estimate the value of the filling factor, which enters the caustic technique, ℱ β = 0.59 ± 0.05 \mathcal{F}_{\beta}=0.59\pm 0.05 ; we derive this value using real data alone and find it consistent with the value usually adopted in the literature. We then use the caustic profiles 𝒜 ( r ) \mathcal{A}(r) of the stacked clusters to constrain the chameleon gravity model. We find that the caustic profiles provide a stringent upper limit of | f R0 | ≲ 4 × 10 − 6 |f_{\rm R0}|\lesssim 4\times 10^{-6} at 95% C.L. limits in the f ( ℛ ) f(\mathcal{R}) scenario. The formalism developed here shall be further refined to test modifications to gravity in the extended outer weak gravitational regions of galaxy clusters. show][email protected] show][email protected] show][email protected] ][email protected] ] show] [email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction The accurate measurement of galaxy cluster masses plays a pivotal role in our pursuit of precision cosmological measurements ( E. J. Hallman et al. 2006 ; M. Pierre et al. 2011 ; D. S. Reed et al. 2013 ; M. M. Crone et al. 1997 ) . Several ongoing efforts are aimed at understanding and managing both statistical ( D. Cromer et al. 2022 ; C. Tchernin et al. 2020 ; J.-B. Melin & J. G. Bartlett 2015 ; F. Köhlinger et al. 2015 ) and systematic uncertainties ( F. Köhlinger et al. 2015 ; E. Rasia et al. 2006 ) in the techniques used for cluster mass inference through direct measurements of gravitational potential ( C. Tchernin et al. 2020 ; T. Tamura et al. 2000 ; H. Liang et al. 2000 ) . Accurately measuring cluster potentials typically requires highly constraining data, whether it involves the number of background galaxies for weak lensing shear profiles ( K.-F. Chen et al. 2020 ; P. Schneider et al. 2000 ; L. King & P. Schneider 2001 ; K. Umetsu et al. 2016 ) , X-ray temperature or SZ-pressure for gas mass profiles ( T. Tamura et al. 2000 ; S. Ettori et al. 2019 ; S. Ettori et al. 2013 ; S. Ettori et al. 2010 ; B. J. Maughan et al. 2016 ; L. Perotto et al. 2024 ) , or spectroscopic redshifts of galaxies for phase-space analyses to obtain the caustic profile ( A. Diaferio & M. J. Geller 1997 ; A. Diaferio 1999 ; B. J. Maughan et al. 2016 ; M. J. Geller et al. 2013 ) . The caustic method has proven to be an extremely successful technique for estimating the total mass of galaxy clusters, completely independent of the dynamical state. It relies on the estimation of the escape velocities based on the projected galaxy phase space. The caustic surface, which traces the amplitude of the phase space of the galaxies, facilitates the reconstruction of the total enclosed mass of the cluster, which extends far beyond the virial radius ( A. Diaferio 1999 ; A. L. Serra et al. 2010 ; D. Gifford et al. 2013 ; C. H. A. Logan et al. 2022 ) . In turn, it is this ability to assess the mass profile beyond the virial radius that provides us with a unique observable to test galaxy cluster dynamics, estimate the extended gravitational potential and subsequently perform tests of gravity. In this context, an earlier proof-of-concept analysis was performed in M. A. Butt et al. 2024a , who assessed the mass bias present between the hydrostatic technique, based on data from S. Ettori et al. 2019 ; D. Eckert et al. 2019 , and the caustic technique, for two well-observed galaxy clusters, A2029 and A2142 ( J. Sohn et al. 2017 ; A. Liu et al. 2018 ) . The caustic technique is a robust method for estimating the masses of galaxy clusters, as it is independent of the dynamical state of the cluster ( A. Diaferio & M. J. Geller 1997 ; B. J. Maughan et al. 2016 ) . This is particularly important because the dynamical state of the cluster can significantly affect the mass estimates obtained from hydrostatic methods ( V. Biffi et al. 2016 ) . The caustic technique also does not require any assumption for the density profile of the cluster, once the clusters from by hierarchical clustering, making it a powerful tool to estimate galaxy cluster masses in an almost model-independent way. Indeed, utilizing the caustic method requires a calibration constant, the filling factor \mathcal{F}_{\beta}(r) , which is usually estimated with N-body simulations ( A. Diaferio et al. 2005 ; D. Gifford et al. 2013 ) . In our previous work ( M. A. Butt et al. 2024a ) , we implement the complete expression of \mathcal{F}_{\beta}(r) assuming the NFW density/potential profile, and obtain competitive constraints on the parameters of modified gravity models. Unlike in M. A. Butt et al. 2024a , where we performed a joint analysis of the caustic and hydrostatic mass, here we aim to obtain a more robust caustic surface(s) by stacking galaxy clusters, allowing us to obtain better constraints of the gravitational potential, independent of other mass estimation techniques. In estimating the caustic surface accurately, the quality and quantity of data can negatively impact the mass estimates when considering large samples of faint or small clusters with very few well-observed galaxies ( D. Gifford et al. 2013 ) . To address this issue, we use stacking to enhance the signal-to-noise ratio for an ensemble of galaxy clusters complied in the HeCS-omnibus sample ( J. Sohn et al. 2020 ) , providing strongly constrained mass estimates. HeCS-omnibus combines and extends three surveys: HeCS-SZ ( K. J. Rines et al. 2016 ) , HeCS-redmapper ( K. J. Rines et al. 2018 ) and HeCS ( K. Rines et al. 2013 ) . Stacking also standardizes the projected shapes of the clusters, thereby also minimizing biases that arise from fitting spherical profiles to non-spherical systems ( D. Gifford et al. 2017 ) . In the present work, we start by building stacked galaxy clusters for which the galaxy phase space has been well-observed ( K. J. Rines et al. 2016