Algorithmic Pricing and Algorithmic Collusion
Martin Bichler, Julius Durmann, Matthias Oberlechner · 2025
Read Algorithmic Pricing and Algorithmic Collusion by Martin Bichler, Julius Durmann, Matthias Oberlechner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16592.txt.
Introduction
Martin Bichler, Julius Durmann, and Matthias Oberlechner survey what happens when pricing algorithms face each other in online markets, in a 2025 paper. Software agents now set many retail prices, and repeated play between learning agents can settle on prices above the competitive level without any explicit deal, a pattern called algorithmic collusion.
Most studies model a few firms in repeated price wars where learning agents adjust over time, and some algorithms do learn to hold high prices in simulation. Why and when this happens is still poorly understood in theory. The authors map the meeting point of online learning and game theory, and set out research questions for their field on governing such markets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Martin Bichler, Julius Durmann, Matthias Oberlechner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16592
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Algorithmic Pricing and Algorithmic Collusion Martin Bichler, Julius Durmann, Matthias Oberlechner Abstract The rise of algorithmic pricing in online retail platforms has attracted significant interest in how autonomous software agents interact under competition. This article explores the potential emergence of algorithmic collusion — supra-competitive pricing outcomes that arise without explicit agreements — as a consequence of repeated interactions between learning agents. Most of the literature focuses on oligopoly pricing environments modeled as repeated Bertrand competitions, where firms use online learning algorithms to adapt prices over time. While experimental research has demonstrated that specific reinforcement learning algorithms can learn to maintain prices above competitive equilibrium levels in simulated environments, theoretical understanding of when and why such outcomes occur remains limited. This work highlights the interdisciplinary nature of this challenge, which connects computer science concepts of online learning with game-theoretical literature on equilibrium learning. We examine implications for the Business & Information Systems Engineering (BISE) community and identify specific research opportunities to address challenges of algorithmic competition in digital marketplaces. Keywords algorithmic collusion, online learning, game theory Note This article has been accepted in Business & Information Systems Engineering (BISE) . 1 Introduction Worldwide, companies are increasingly using algorithms and artificial intelligence (AI) in order to power their operations, from product development to manufacturing and marketing, and product pricing is no exception. This new type of information systems based on learning algorithms has drawn considerable attention aiming to understand their societal effects ( Lysyakov and Viswanathan 2023 , Lu and Zhang 2024 , Fügener et al. 2021 ) . An important question in this overall stream is how learning algorithms are used for pricing ( Brackmann et al. 2024 ) . Algorithmic pricing is a practice where software agents automatically determine prices for items for sale, in order to maximize the seller’s profits. This practice is increasingly common in online retail markets. Chen et al. 2016 estimated that by 2015, algorithms were used in setting prices for roughly one-third of the top 1600 products on Amazon. By 2018, the average product price on Amazon reportedly changed every ten minutes and adapts to market conditions. 1 1 1 https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-price-changes-2018-8 Since then, an industry has developed around automated pricing software. The prices determined by the different firms depend on each other’s actions, and the overall environment in which they operate is that of an oligopoly competition. Economic theory has long aimed to predict the outcome of such competitive situations. Models of oligopoly competition assume some knowledge about the demand of customers, such as a readily available demand function, and then they determine a Nash equilibrium price. For example, in the celebrated Bertrand competition model, companies producing identical (homogeneous) products simultaneously choose their pricing strategies based on a given demand function that takes the prices of the competitors into account ( Bertrand 1883 ) . In this model, the competitors play their equilibrium strategy from the start. Usually, sellers entering the market have limited information about competitors’ costs or customer demand at different prices, and they must learn over time which prices optimize profit. Additionally, changes in demand and supply over time require recalculating the equilibrium strategy, which emphasizes the need for an adaptive and learning pricing software agent. From the perspective of an individual seller, algorithmic pricing aims to solve an online learning problem ( Shalev-Shwartz 2011 ) , where the seller’s actions are the prices they set, and the objective is to maximize profit. But what is the outcome of markets with such learning agents? Can we assume that they converge to an equilibrium price? Recent experimental research showed that learning algorithms can lead to prices higher than the Nash equilibrium in the static oligopoly pricing game ( Waltman and Kaymak 2008 , Calvano et al. 2019 , Abada and Lambin 2023 , Klein 2021 , Abada et al. 2024b , Brown and MacKay 2023 ) . This phenomenon is referred to as algorithmic collusion . Explicit collusion refers to anti-competitive conducts that are maintained with explicit agreements. Firms interact directly and agree on the optimal level of price or output ( OECD 2017 ) . In contrast, “tacit collusion refers to forms of anti-competitive co-ordination which can be achieved without any need for an explicit agreement, but which competitors are able to maintain by recognizing their mutual interdependence. In a tacitly collusive context, the non-competitive outcome is achieved by each participant deciding its own profit-maximizing strategy independently of its competitors.” ( OECD 2017 ) Algorithmic collusion is a form of tacit collusion where supra-competitive outcomes different from the Nash equilibrium of the static game-theoretical model of competition are produced by learning algorithms without being programmed to produce those outcomes. Similar definitions are provided by den Boer 2023 and Abada et al. 2024a . There are also cases suggesting that algorithmic collusion happens in real-world markets. For example, Assad et al. 2024 showed that margins increased 28% in local duopoly retail gasoline markets in Germany when both firms adopted algorithmic pricing software, while there was no price change in local monopolies. The paper finds pricing algorithms can learn tacitly collusive pricing strategies which are legal in most jurisdictions without explicit communication. An investigation in the UK revealed that online poster retailers were using simple pricing algorithms in the context of a horizontal cartel among retailers to coordinate their prices on Amazon. 2 2 2 https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/online-sales-of-discretionary-consumer-products The phenomenon raised concerns among regulators as it may reduce consumer welfare. In recent years, several competition authorities, including France and Germany, Denmark, Japan, Norway, and Sweden, have published policy papers considering the relationship between algorithms and competition ( OECD 2024 ) . However, the magnitude of the threat from algorithmic collusion by autonomous self-learning algorithms in other markets is still disputed in the academic literature. Ultimately, algorithmic collusion touches on a deep and non-trivial question, that of learning in games. Under which conditions do learning algorithms converge to an equilibrium in repeated play and when is this not the case? When do we see algorithmic collusion, inefficient price cycling, or even chaotic price dynamics as a result of automated pricing decisions? Currently, there is no comprehensive theory that would provide answers to these questions. Up to now, there are only very few articles in Business & Information Systems Engineering outlets on algorithmic collusion ( Kang et al. 2022 , Douglas et al. 2024 , Deng et al. 2024 , Bichler et al. 2023 ) . The topic is central for the welfare of electronic markets today and it draws on learning algorithms from computer science as well as game-theoretical models as they have been developed in economics. The aim of this catchword article is to discuss algorithmic collusion and make the basic problem and the related questions accessible to a broader community. This will allow us to point to avenues for future research in Business & Information Systems Engineering. 2 Oligopoly Pricing Pricing in online retail markets is an environment that can be modeled as a Bertrand competition ( Bertrand 1883 ) . In this model, firms compete by setting prices for a homogeneous product. The demand for the product depends on the prices set by all firms. The firms’ objective is to maximize their profit, which