Toward a Principled Workflow for Prevalence Mapping Using Household Survey Data

Qianyu Dong, Yunhan Wu, Zehang Richard Li, Jon Wakefield · 2025

Read Toward a Principled Workflow for Prevalence Mapping Using Household Survey Data by Qianyu Dong, Yunhan Wu, Zehang Richard Li, Jon Wakefield (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16435.txt.

Introduction

Qianyu Dong and three co-authors present a study from twenty twenty-five on how to map health rates for small areas from household surveys. In poor and middle income lands, such surveys are the main source of health facts. Fine maps are now made in bulk, yet plain guidance on how to make them has lagged. Model picks and how to read the maps are weak spots, above all when data is thin.

The team sets out a full workflow, from raw data to map. They stress model choice, checks, and clear reading of results at each stage. A case study maps clinic visits in pregnancy across Kenya. Shared code lets others rerun and extend the flow to many other health signs.

Catalog record

CREATORQianyu Dong, Yunhan Wu, Zehang Richard Li, Jon Wakefield
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16435

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Toward a Principled Workflow for Prevalence Mapping Using Household Survey Data Qianyu Dong, Yunhan Wu, Zehang Richard Li, Jon Wakefield Abstract Understanding the prevalence of key demographic and health indicators in small geographic areas and domains is of global interest, especially in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), where vital registration data is sparse and household surveys are the primary source of information. Recent advances in computation and the increasing availability of spatially detailed datasets have led to much progress in sophisticated statistical modeling of prevalence. As a result, high-resolution prevalence maps for many indicators are routinely produced in the literature. However, statistical and practical guidance for producing prevalence maps in LMICs has been largely lacking. In particular, advice in choosing and evaluating models and interpreting results is needed, especially when data is limited. Software and analysis tools are also usually inaccessible to researchers in low-resource settings to conduct their own analysis or reproduce findings in the literature. In this paper, we propose a general workflow for prevalence mapping using household survey data. We consider all stages of the analysis pipeline, with particular emphasis on model choice and interpretation. We illustrate the proposed workflow using a case study mapping the proportion of pregnant women who had at least four antenatal care visits in Kenya. Reproducible code is provided in the Supplementary Materials and can be readily extended to a broad collection of indicators. Statement of Significance We propose a principled workflow for estimating and mapping the prevalence of demographic and health indicators in small administrative areas using household survey data in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The workflow considers all stages of the data analysis pipeline and can be robustly adopted for a wide range of binary indicators. The aim of the workflow is to enable researchers and analysts in LMICs to carry out their own prevalence analysis according to their local needs and priorities. The workflow is illustrated through a case study mapping the proportion of pregnant women who had at least four antenatal care visits in Kenya, with reproducible code in the Supplementary Materials. 1 Introduction Accurate estimation and tracking of key demographic and health indicators is critical for assessing health progress and disparities. National statistical institutions and global organizations have long recognized the need to produce disaggregated estimates at fine resolutions. For example, the United Nations General Assembly’s 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development ( United Nations 2015 ) established targets “to increase significantly the availability of high-quality, timely and reliable data disaggregated by income, gender, age, race, ethnicity, migratory status, disability, geographic location and other characteristics relevant in national contexts.” The problem of estimating quantities of interest for small subpopulations based on limited data is known as small area estimation (SAE). SAE has a long history in the survey sampling literature. Traditional SAE approaches have been largely developed in the high-income country context and often utilize auxiliary administrative data to improve inference ( Rao and Molina 2015 ) . Recent applications of SAE approaches in LMICs include work on mapping poverty ( Molina et al. 2019 ; Chi et al. 2022 ) , child mortality ( Mercer et al. 2015 ; Li et al. 2019 ; Wakefield et al. 2019 ; Wu et al. 2021 ) , fertility ( Saha et al. 2023 ) , HIV prevalence ( Wakefield et al. 2020 ) , vaccination coverage ( Dong and Wakefield 2021 ) . More recently, another line of research using geostatistical models has been adopted by major research organizations to map the prevalence of a number of important health indicators ( Diggle and Giorgi 2016 ; Diggle and Giorgi 2019 ; Osgood-Zimmerman et al. 2018 ; Burstein et al. 2018 ; Utazi et al. 2018 ; Mayala et al. 2019 , see e.g.,) . Geostatistical models theoretically enable prevalence estimation at a fine spatial resolution, e.g., 100 m grids, and they leverage the growing availability of spatially referenced covariates such as population density ( Tatem 2017 ) and night time light ( Gaughan et al. 2019 ) . A recent review and comparison of the two types of approaches is provided in Wakefield et al. 2025 . While rapid progress has been made in methodological developments of mapping prevalence in small areas, the existing literature often focuses on improving specific steps of the full SAE workflow. Guidance on conducting prevalence mapping from the beginning to the end has been largely lacking, especially for practitioners. Two recent papers, Tzavidis et al. 2018 and Giorgi et al. 2021 , discuss the significance of having a coherent process across different stages of analysis when producing small area official statistics. However, scenarios where data is scarce remain challenging under both frameworks. Tzavidis et al. 2018 examined the production of official statistics from the perspective of national statistical institutes. Their framework follows a traditional SAE approach and focuses on continuous outcomes, e.g., average income. The models for continuous outcomes are usually inappropriate for estimating the prevalence of categorical indicators, which is the focus of this paper. In addition, their framework emphasizes using covariates from census or administrative microdata in order to construct synthetic estimates at fine geographic scale. In LMICs, the issues with data availability are quite different from those faced in high-income countries. Auxiliary datasets from census are usually unavailable, or of poor quality and are often not updated in a timely fashion. Thus, it is important to exploit the spatial dependence in the response variable that cannot be explained by the covariates that are available to the analyst. This aspect is largely ignored in Tzavidis et al. 2018 . On the other hand, Giorgi et al. 2021 provided a parallel set of guidance on developing prevalence models using geostatistical models, focusing on using high-quality spatially referenced covariates for point-level spatial prediction. In contrast with Tzavidis et al. 2018 , some key considerations in the traditional SAE methods, e.g., accounting for the sampling design of a survey, are mostly ignored. Notably, both Tzavidis et al. 2018 and Giorgi et al. 2021 were primarily written for statisticians capable of building and comparing sophisticated models. Translating the ideas to routine analytic procedures involving large numbers of indicators can be difficult for practitioners. In this paper, we aim to fill this gap by developing a principled and accessible workflow for common types of prevalence mapping tasks in data-limited contexts with fully worked-out examples. Specifically, we focus on estimating the prevalence of binary indicators, i.e., the proportion of individuals affected by certain conditions. We develop a ‘default’ analysis pipeline with a series of models for prevalence mapping that can be adopted robustly for a wide range of indicators. Our proposed procedures acknowledge the sampling design explicitly and account for spatial dependence in the prevalence. The models are computationally scalable, making them feasible to implement in low-resource settings. Altogether, the workflow generates a robust set of prevalence estimates and insights that can form the basis for further extensions when bespoke analyses are needed. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 discusses the common types of household survey data in LMICs. Section 3 describes the steps in the workflow. Section 4 concludes with a discussion of the proposed workflow, active research areas, and open

Read the complete text