Review of the experimental and theoretical landscape of electron transport in noble liquids

G. J. Boyle 1,∗ , N. A. Garland 2,3,∗ , D. L. Muccignat 1 , I. Simonović 4 , D. Bošnjaković 4 , S. Dujko 4 and R. D. White 1 · 2025

Read Review of the experimental and theoretical landscape of electron transport in noble liquids by G. J. Boyle 1,∗ , N. A. Garland 2,3,∗ , D. L. Muccignat 1 , I. Simonović 4 , D. Bošnjaković 4 , S. Dujko 4 and R. D. White 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16338.txt.

Introduction

Boyle and co-authors review what is known about how electrons move through noble liquids such as xenon and argon. Interest has surged with large detectors that use these liquids to catch rare particle events. The review covers both experiments and theory. The authors add an open database of mobility and diffusion measures. That resource lets modelers check their work against old and new data on equal terms.

Modern detectors drift electrons over long distances and demand pure liquids and even fields. Theory work now tries to build in liquid-specific effects from first principles. Coherent scattering and polarization screening are among those effects. The review maps where simple models still serve and where deeper ones are needed.

Catalog record

CREATORG. J. Boyle 1,∗ , N. A. Garland 2,3,∗ , D. L. Muccignat 1 , I. Simonović 4 , D. Bošnjaković 4 , S. Dujko 4 and R. D. White 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE90 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16338

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Review of the experimental and theoretical landscape of electron transport in noble liquids G. J. Boyle 1,∗ , N. A. Garland 2,3,∗ , D. L. Muccignat 1 , I. Simonović 4 , D. Bošnjaković 4 , S. Dujko 4 and R. D. White 1 Abstract We present a review of the current experimental and theoretical understanding of electron transport in noble liquids. Special attention is given to recent measurements that coincide with the development of time projection chambers (TPCs) using liquid xenon and argon as detector media. To enable transparent benchmarking of simulations and to facilitate the comparison between early studies and modern TPC data, we introduce a new open-access database of electron mobility and diffusion measurements. In particular, we emphasize the transition to large-scale detector designs which incorporate extended drift distances alongside improved purity control and field uniformity. On the theoretical side, we contrast empirical transport models with ab initio approaches, highlighting our recent efforts to incorporate low-energy, liquid-specific scattering phenomena, including coherent scattering, polarization screening, and bulk potential modifications. While elastic transport has seen substantial theoretical progress, inelastic processes in liquids, including ionization, exciton formation and interband transitions, remain poorly understood due to the lack of experimental cross sections and validated models. We also discuss the applications and challenges of modeling scintillation, doped and mixture-liquid targets, and gas–liquid interface behavior, all of which are critical for the design and optimization of next-generation detectors. \helveticabold 1 Keywords: electron transport, noble liquids, swarm experiments, time projection chambers, liquid xenon, liquid argon \correspondance \extraAuth † † firstpage: 1 2 Introduction The transport of free electrons in dense fluids, particularly in liquefied noble gases such as argon and xenon, plays a central role in both fundamental physics and detector technology. These systems lie at the intersection of condensed matter, atomic physics, and high-energy physics, and underpin some of the most sensitive experimental searches for rare processes, including neutrino interactions and dark matter detection. Liquid-phase noble gas detectors, especially those employing time projection chamber (TPC) designs, have become indispensable in astroparticle and neutrino physics. Simultaneous measurements of scintillation light and ionization charge signals allows precise event reconstruction. Recent large-scale experiments, including XENONnT ( Aprile et al. 2019 ) , LZ ( Aalbers et al. 2023 ) , PandaX ( Liu 2022 ) , ProtoDUNE ( Abi et al. 2020 ) , MicroBooNE ( Abratenko et al. 2021b ) , and ICARUS ( The ICARUS Collaboration 2004 ) , demonstrate this approach’s maturity, with tonne- to hundred-tonne-scale active masses now routine ( Colaleo et al. 2021 ) . For example, TPCs that use a LXe target have set world-leading limits on WIMP-nucleus cross-sections in the GeV/c 2 to TeV/c 2 mass range ( Schumann 2019 ) . In such detectors, particle interactions within the liquid target medium produce excited and ionized atoms. Scintillation photons offer a prompt time reference, while free electrons liberated by ionization are drifted under electric fields across the liquid-gas interface and are subsequently extracted. The fidelity of the signal reconstruction and hence the detector’s sensitivity depends critically on our understanding of how electrons move through the liquid. Properties such as drift velocity, diffusion, and recombination all influence the shape and timing of the charge signal. To probe these transport properties, dedicated electron swarm experiments have been employed since the mid-20th century, many using time-of-flight (TOF) techniques. In these studies, a short electron pulse is produced (typically from a photocathode) and tracked as it drifts and diffuses under the influence of an electric field. Some setups incorporate transverse magnetic fields to probe combined electric–magnetic field effects ( Lamp and Buschhorn 1994 ) . Careful control of the thermodynamic state of the liquid, typically achieved by regulating temperature, pressure, and density, allows measurements over a broad range of physical conditions. Transport properties, such as mobility, characteristic energy, diffusion coefficients and the ionization rate, are then extracted from the evolution of the electron cloud. These properties feed directly into models for detector simulation and plasma behavior ( Makabe and Petrovic 2006 ; Petrović et al. 2009 ; Robson et al. 2017 ) , or can be used to extract underlying electron-atom scattering cross-sections via inverse swarm analysis ( Engelhardt and Phelps 1963 ; Engelhardt et al. 1964 ; Morgan 1991 ; Stokes et al. 2020 ; Muccignat et al. 2024 ) . Despite the widespread availability of gas-phase transport data, consolidated in databases like LXCat ( Pitchford et al. 2017 ; Carbone et al. 2021 ) and NIST ( Lemmon 2025 ) , corresponding liquid-phase data remain fragmented and incomplete. In particular, few comprehensive datasets exist for liquids, especially in conditions relevant to modern TPCs. Furthermore, while simplified scaling laws often attempt to bridge gas and liquid regimes, this approach is generally insufficient due largely to the increased density effects that become important for electrons scattering in liquids compared to gases (see Section 4.2 ). In 1965, Schnyders and collaborators questioned the applicability of gas-phase cross-sections in dense media ( Schnyders et al. 1965 ) . Their subsequent work proposed that a more accurate description could be achieved by including interference effects via the liquid structure factor ( Schnyders et al. 1966 ) . These insights, together with theoretical advancements by Cohen and Lekner ( Lekner 1967 ; Cohen and Lekner 1967 ) , laid the foundation for the modern understanding of electron transport in dense atomic fluids. The increased density introduces short-range order and coherent scattering effects, fundamentally altering the electron’s potential landscape. Early theoretical treatments addressed these issues by modifying the effective interaction potential to account for for the medium interparticle correlations ( Lekner 1967 ; Cohen and Lekner 1967 ; Schmidt 1984 ; Sakai et al. 1982 ; Sakai et al. 1985 ; Sakai 2007 ; Atrazhev and Iakubov 1981 ; Atrazhev and Timoshkin 1996 ; Atrazhev and Timoshkin 1998 ) . Atrazhev and collaborators further demonstrated that, at low energies, cross-sections become nearly energy-independent and scale primarily with density ( Atrazhev and Iakubov 1981 ; Atrazhev and Timoshkin 1996 ; Atrazhev and Timoshkin 1998 ) . In a later refinement, Atrazhev et al. 1995 introduced a variable-phase-function method and muffin-tin potentials to incorporate liquid structure more realistically. From an empirical perspective, Sakai and co-workers ( Sakai et al. 1985 ; Sakai 2007 ) used a fitting procedure to adjust the momentum transfer cross-sections to match swarm data. Borghesani and co-workers ( Borghesani and Santini 1994 ; Borghesani 2006 ; Borghesani 2014 ) developed a heuristic for constructing an effective momentum transfer cross-section from modified gas phase cross-sections, thereby accurately predicting enhancements (or reductions) in the zero-field mobility. Sophisticated treatments that use a Green’s function method were employed by Braglia and Dallacasa 1982 to explore electron self-energy corrections, though such models are often limited by assumptions like linear response and near-equilibrium conditions. Our recent work aims to develop a unified ab initio model for electron transport in noble liquids and dense gases, leveraging highly accurate electron-atom potentials benchmarked in the gas phase ( Boyle et al. 2015 ; Boyle et al. 2016 ; White et al. 2018 ) . This framework avoids oversimplified potentials, e.g. the Buckingham potential, which neglect exchange interactions. The use of accurate potentials yields excellent agreement

Read the complete text