A Conceptual Framework for AI-based Decision Systems in Critical Infrastructures

Milad Leyli-abadi, Ricardo J. Bessa, Jan Viebahn, Daniel Boos, Clark Borst, Alberto Castagna, Ricardo Chavarriaga, Mohamed Hassouna, Bruno Lemetayer, Giulia Leto, Antoine Marot, Maroua Meddeb, Manuel Meyer, Viola Schiaffonati, Manuel Schneider, Toni Waefler · 2025

Read A Conceptual Framework for AI-based Decision Systems in Critical Infrastructures by Milad Leyli-abadi, Ricardo J. Bessa, Jan Viebahn, Daniel Boos, Clark Borst, Alberto Castagna, Ricardo Chavarriaga, Mohamed Hassouna, Bruno Lemetayer, Giulia Leto, Antoine Marot, Maroua Meddeb, Manuel Meyer, Viola Schiaffonati, Manuel Schneider, Toni Waefler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-16133.txt.

Introduction

Leyli-abadi and co-authors draft a framework for AI decision tools in critical infrastructure, where human judgment and machine advice must mesh safely. Power grids, transport, and aviation demand tools that stay transparent, trusted, and explainable while deciding fast. Existing guides cover only parts of that puzzle.

Their 2025 framework pulls together math, decision theory, computing, philosophy, psychology, and cognitive engineering, plus lessons from energy, mobility, and flight. It treats design, deployment, and upkeep as one arc rather than separate chores. A power grid management case study shows the framework bending to a real setting. The authors aim it at builders and operators of high-stakes systems. They argue holism is the missing piece.

Catalog record

CREATORMilad Leyli-abadi, Ricardo J. Bessa, Jan Viebahn, Daniel Boos, Clark Borst, Alberto Castagna, Ricardo Chavarriaga, Mohamed Hassouna, Bruno Lemetayer, Giulia Leto, Antoine Marot, Maroua Meddeb, Manuel Meyer, Viola Schiaffonati, Manuel Schneider, Toni Waefler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-16133

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Conceptual Framework for AI-based Decision Systems in Critical Infrastructures Milad Leyli-abadi, Ricardo J. Bessa, Jan Viebahn, Daniel Boos, Clark Borst, Alberto Castagna, Ricardo Chavarriaga, Mohamed Hassouna, Bruno Lemetayer, Giulia Leto, Antoine Marot, Maroua Meddeb, Manuel Meyer, Viola Schiaffonati, Manuel Schneider, Toni Waefler Abstract The interaction between humans and AI in safety-critical systems presents a unique set of challenges that remain partially addressed by existing frameworks. These challenges stem from the complex interplay of requirements for transparency, trust, and explainability, coupled with the necessity for robust and safe decision-making. A framework that holistically integrates human and AI capabilities while addressing these concerns is notably required, bridging the critical gaps in designing, deploying, and maintaining safe and effective systems. This paper proposes a holistic conceptual framework for critical infrastructures by adopting an interdisciplinary approach. It integrates traditionally distinct fields such as mathematics, decision theory, computer science, philosophy, psychology, and cognitive engineering and draws on specialized engineering domains, particularly energy, mobility, and aeronautics. Its flexibility is further demonstrated through a case study on power grid management. I Introduction Artificial Intelligence (AI) is showing high potential to transform the management of critical infrastructures [ 1 ] , tackling pressing challenges like climate change and the rising demand for energy and mobility systems while advancing strategic objectives such as energy transition and digital transformation. On the other hand, integrating AI in critical sectors introduces significant challenges, many of which are already being addressed by emerging regulatory frameworks, such as the European Union AI Act. These frameworks emphasize the importance of safety, transparency, and adherence to ethical standards and principles to mitigate a wide range of risks, including technical, social, and environmental hazards associated with deploying AI in high-risk domains. Another key challenge lies in fostering effective human-AI collaboration. This involves integrating human expertise into AI-based systems and promoting adaptive learning and collaborative decision-making processes. Various approaches can be explored to achieve this, such as co-learning frameworks where both AI and humans evolve their knowledge together or systems in which AI learns independently but is designed to work alongside humans in joint decision-making. In response to these challenges, this paper proposes a conceptual framework for AI-based systems in critical infrastructures. This framework integrates emerging AI algorithms, open-source digital environments optimized for AI, and socio-technical design principles and practices for responsible research and innovation that support human-machine interaction. It aims to improve real-time and predictive operations across key sectors such as power networks, railways, and air traffic management – identified as vital to Europe and prioritized in national AI strategies worldwide. Existing decision-making frameworks provide valuable insights into AI integration but often operate in isolation, focusing on specific sectors or challenges (see Section II for a review). There is a need for a unified approach that balances technical, ethical, and human considerations in critical infrastructures. This paper proposes a novel framework that fosters collaboration between human control and AI, ensuring AI enhances rather than replaces human decision-making. Designed with real-world, safety-critical applications in mind, the proposed framework prioritizes transparency, trust, and accountability, improving both social and technical performance. By directly addressing key challenges such as reliability, security, and response time in complex environments, it supports adaptable, ethically aligned, and context-aware human-AI systems for safer and more effective decision-making. A review of existing frameworks is provided in Section II . The proposed conceptual framework is described in Section III . An example of its instantiation is provided in Section IV , and Section V concludes the paper. II Related Work The decision-making processes within critical infrastructures are increasingly supported by frameworks that integrate AI to enhance reliability, efficiency, and safety. These frameworks aim to address the unique challenges of critical sectors by providing structured approaches to managing complexity and uncertainty. Herein, we review some of the prominent frameworks developed for decision-making in the energy and mobility domains. Decision support systems in power grids Power grid evolution driven by decarbonization increases operational complexity, requiring enhanced control room supervision. When managing technical problems such as congested lines, power system engineers rely on specialized expertise, real-time and forecasted data, and simulation tools for complex decision-making. Yet, they have limited access to automated decision-support tools, requiring manual exploration and experience-driven simulations to implement grid adjustments and remedial actions. Marot et al. [ 2 ] propose an AI-based agent framework to assist power grid operators by ensuring alarms are sent in advance when action confidence is low, preventing human-out-of-the-loop scenarios. It emphasizes credibility through transparency, reliability via consistent performance, and intimacy by explaining incorrect actions to build trust. Greitzer et al. [ 3 ] introduce a naturalistic decision-making framework that models interactions between real-world cues and operator cognition using mental simulations to anticipate control actions. Fan et al. [ 4 ] propose a human-machine hybrid intelligence framework for power grid dispatching, integrating AI, a digital twin, and human operators to enable bidirectional learning and dynamic task reassignment. Hilliard et al. [ 5 ] develop the Work Domain Analysis framework, linking grid assets to high-level objectives through means-ends relationships and cause-effect models. Finally, GridOptions [ 6 ] is the first AI-based decision-support tool deployed in a Transmission System Operator (TSO) control room, applying Evaluative AI [ 7 ] to enhance decision-making through quality-diversity multi-objective optimization. That is, by providing evidence for and against a range of possible options (instead of providing recommendations that can only be accepted or rejected), it leverages human expertise in decision-making and mitigates issues of over and under-reliance. Railway traffic management systems The traffic management in modern railway networks is becoming ever more complex due to dense mixed traffic and increasing passenger and freight demand. Rescheduling and rerouting trains present a significant challenge when deviations from the planned schedule occur, such as delays or infrastructure disruptions. While these tasks are traditionally performed by human operators, they receive support from traffic management systems (TMS) with various degrees of automation, like the Swiss Federal Railway’s (SBB) Rail Control System (RCS) [ 8 ] which provides real-time traffic monitoring and dynamic routing options. While traditional TMS in the railway sector rely heavily on operations research, there is growing interest in leveraging machine learning, particularly multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL), for traffic management. Efforts in this area range from enhancing solution quality and response times for dynamic routing—such as in German Railway’s (DB) automatic dispatching assistant—to exploring novel rescheduling and rerouting approaches using MARL [ 9 ] within simulation environments like Flatland [ 10 ] . Additionally, recent public and private open-source research initiatives in the railway sector continue to drive innovation in TMS [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Air Traffic Management (ATM) systems ATM consists of several entities that all need to work together seamlessly to achieve safe and efficient air traffic operations. Those entities operate at different time scales, ranging from long-term strategic flight planning (years to months prior to operation), pre-tactical operations (days to hours before operation) towards tactical operations in the execution phase of flight. Currently, the ATM system is human-centric, meaning that human operators (ranging from strategic flight planners toward tactical air traffic controllers (ATCOs) bear the ultimate responsibility for operational safety. The steady growth of air traffic, projected at 2% annually, has exposed a gap

Read the complete text