Scalar Backreaction from Gravitational Waves in a Degenerate f ⁡ ( R , G ) f(R,G) Sector

Farzad Milani · 2025

Read Scalar Backreaction from Gravitational Waves in a Degenerate f ⁡ ( R , G ) f(R,G) Sector by Farzad Milani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15709.txt.

Introduction

Farzad Milani computes how gravitational waves backreact in a modified gravity sector in a 2025 paper. The theory family blends two curvature invariants degenerately. That degeneracy collapses the description to one scalar degree. A known scalar-tensor subclass receives the resulting map.

Tensor wave action coefficients are derived in modified form. A cubic interaction then sources a scalar channel. A rolling wave background generically induces that scalar response. Surprisingly, it persists even when wave speed equals light speed. An exact expanding solution confirms both speeds at unity. The scalar source stays nonzero at leading order there. Finite-wavelength response scales inversely with the scalar frequency squared. The author cautions against reading this as a universal expansion shift. Ghost freedom is explicitly not proven globally. The paper is careful theory with stated limits.

Catalog record

CREATORFarzad Milani
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15709

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scalar Backreaction from Gravitational Waves in a Degenerate f ⁡ ( R , G ) f(R,G) Sector Farzad Milani Abstract We investigate the high-frequency backreaction of gravitational waves in the Hessian-degenerate sector of four-dimensional f ⁡ ( R , G ) f(R,G) gravity defined by f ⁡ ( R , G ) = F ⁡ ( R + G / M 2 ) f(R,G)=F(R+G/M^{2}) . The degeneracy of the Hessian reduces the Legendre representation to a single scalar degree of freedom and maps the theory into a scalar–Gauss–Bonnet subclass of Horndeski gravity. We derive the tensor quadratic action and obtain the modified kinetic and gradient coefficients Q T = ϕ + 4 ​ H ​ ϕ ˙ / M 2 Q_{T}=\phi+4H\dot{\phi}/M^{2} and F T = ϕ + 4 ​ ϕ ¨ / M 2 F_{T}=\phi+4\ddot{\phi}/M^{2} in units where the overall factor M Pl 2 M_{\rm Pl}^{2} is extracted. We then use the general Horndeski scalar–tensor–tensor cubic action to identify the induced scalar channel generated by a stochastic transverse-traceless gravitational-wave background. The scalar source is generically nonzero and, importantly, it is not determined solely by the tensor-speed deviation: it can remain nonzero even on a rolling de Sitter background for which c T 2 = 1 c_{T}^{2}=1 . For an exact analytic rolling de Sitter solution, we find c T 2 = c S 2 = 1 c_{T}^{2}=c_{S}^{2}=1 and obtain a nonzero leading scalar source, 𝒮 ℛ GW = ⟨ h ˙ i ​ j ​ h ˙ i ​ j ⟩ / 8 + O ⁡ ( H / ω ) \mathcal{S}_{\mathcal{R}}^{\rm GW}=\langle\dot{h}_{ij}\dot{h}_{ij}\rangle/8+O(H/\omega) . The finite-wavenumber scalar response scales as ℛ 𝐤 ( 2 ) ∼ 𝒮 ℛ , 𝐤 GW / ω S 2 \mathcal{R}_{\bf k}^{(2)}\sim\mathcal{S}_{\mathcal{R},\bf k}^{\rm GW}/\omega_{S}^{2} in the geometric-optics regime. We do not identify this finite- k k response with a universal homogeneous Hubble shift; such a conversion requires an explicit zero-mode projection and averaging prescription. We emphasize that the result does not constitute a proof of global ghost freedom or a complete nonlinear treatment of the theory. I Introduction Gravitational waves (GWs) carry energy and momentum and, once averaged over scales long compared with their wavelength, act as an effective source for the background geometry. In general relativity this idea is captured by the Isaacson high-frequency expansion, in which the quadratic part of the metric perturbation is interpreted as an effective stress tensor [ 4 , 5 ] . The same separation between rapidly varying wave degrees of freedom and slowly varying background fields is useful in modified gravity, but the averaging problem becomes more subtle because the gravitational action can contain additional propagating degrees of freedom and time-dependent effective gravitational couplings [ 9 ] . The class of f(R,G) theories is particularly interesting because it combines the Ricci scalar with the four-dimensional Gauss–Bonnet invariant. For a generic nonlinear function of R and G , the scalar sector can be richer than that of f(R) gravity, and perturbative stability can depend sensitively on the background and on the rank of the Hessian of f [ 2 , 1 ] . Consequently, a generic statement about “the” gravitational-wave backreaction of f(R,G) gravity is not appropriate without specifying a dynamically controlled subclass. Here we restrict attention to the Hessian-degenerate family 1 1 1 This manuscript substantially revises and extends the earlier preprint arXiv:2504.15709[v4], “Gravitational Wave Backreaction in f(R,G) Gravity.” The present version supersedes that earlier formulation. In particular, the model, scalar–tensor representation, background dynamics, and backreaction analysis have been reformulated. The earlier formulation based on f(R,G)=R+\alpha R^{2}+\beta G and a two-field representation is not retained. The present work instead studies the rank-one sector f(R,G)=F(R+G/M^{2}) , admits a one-field Legendre representation, and derives the corresponding tensor and scalar responses consistently. The background equations have also been corrected, and the present analysis distinguishes the finite-wavenumber scalar response from the direct homogeneous background backreaction. f(R,G)=F(X),\qquad X=R+\frac{G}{M^{2}}, (I.1) where M is a constant mass scale. Its Hessian has rank one, f_{RR}=F_{XX},\qquad f_{RG}=\frac{F_{XX}}{M^{2}},\qquad f_{GG}=\frac{F_{XX}}{M^{4}}, (I.2) so that \Delta_{f}\equiv f_{RR}f_{GG}-f_{RG}^{2}=0. (I.3) The theory consequently admits a one-field Legendre representation rather than the two-field representation appropriate to a nondegenerate Hessian. The central purpose of this paper is not to claim generic ghost freedom for all f(R,G) models. Instead, we derive the tensor backreaction and the induced scalar channel in this controlled degenerate sector. The main results are: 1. the locked theory is equivalent to a scalar–Gauss–Bonnet Horndeski theory with one scalar degree of freedom on the cosmological background; 2. the tensor kinetic and gradient coefficients are \mathcal{G}_{T}=M_{\rm Pl}^{2}\left(\phi+\frac{4H\dot{\phi}}{M^{2}}\right),\qquad\mathcal{F}_{T}=M_{\rm Pl}^{2}\left(\phi+\frac{4\ddot{\phi}}{M^{2}}\right); (I.4) 3. the leading high-frequency tensor stress has \rho_{\rm GW}=\frac{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}{4}\left(\phi+\frac{4H\dot{\phi}}{M^{2}}\right)\langle\dot{h}_{ij}\dot{h}_{ij}\rangle,\qquad p_{\rm GW}=\frac{1}{3}\rho_{\rm GW}; (I.5) 4. the cubic scalar–tensor–tensor interaction generates a nonzero scalar source even when c_{T}=1 ; 5. on an exact rolling de Sitter solution the scalar propagation is luminal, c_{S}^{2}=1 , while the leading scalar source remains nonzero, \mathcal{S}_{\mathcal{R}}^{\rm GW}=\langle\dot{h}_{ij}\dot{h}_{ij}\rangle/8+O(H/\omega) ; the finite- k response scales as \mathcal{R}_{\bf k}^{(2)}\sim\mathcal{S}_{\mathcal{R},\bf k}^{\rm GW}/\omega_{S}^{2} . The analysis uses the general Horndeski perturbation formalism of Kobayashi, Yamaguchi and Yokoyama [ 6 ] and the general cubic scalar–tensor–tensor action of Gao et al. [ 3 ] . These formulas are valid for the general Horndeski class and do not require a canonical X term in G_{2} ; the kinetic term X=-\nabla_{\mu}\phi\nabla^{\mu}\phi/2 is simply the variable on which the Horndeski functions may depend. The scalar kinetic structure in the present model arises from the nonminimal curvature mixing. The paper is organized as follows. Section II introduces the degenerate sector and its Legendre form. Section III gives the Horndeski mapping and the cosmological background. Section IV derives the tensor sector and its effective stress tensor. Section V treats the cubic scalar–tensor–tensor interaction. Section VI derives the scalar response and its comparison with the direct tensor backreaction. Sections VII and VIII discuss the physical interpretation and limitations. Technical derivations are collected in the appendices. II The model and its degenerate sector We begin from S=\frac{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}{2}\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\,f(R,G). (II.1) For the locked family ( I.1 ), define \phi\equiv F_{X}. (II.2) Assuming local invertibility of F_{X}(X) , let X=X(\phi) and define the Legendre potential V(\phi)=\phi X(\phi)-F[X(\phi)]. (II.3) The action becomes S=\frac{M_{\rm Pl}^{2}}{2}\int d^{4}x\sqrt{-g}\left[\phi R+\frac{\phi}{M^{2}}G-V(\phi)\right]. (II.4) Variation with respect to \phi gives the constraint R+\frac{G}{M^{2}}-V_{,\phi}=0. (II.5) The full metric field equations obtained by varying ( II.4 ) are given in Appendix A . The degeneracy is structural rather than accidental. Since f_{R}=\phi,\qquad f_{G}=\frac{\phi}{M^{2}}, (II.6) there is only one independent auxiliary scalar. This avoids introducing a spurious second scalar in a rank-one Hessian system. The distinction between Hessian degeneracy and global ghost freedom is important: \Delta_{f}=0 is a necessary structural property of the present reduction, not by itself a no-ghost theorem. Generic f(R,G) theories can possess ghost modes on anisotropic backgrounds, while the number of scalar modes changes on FLRW backgrounds [ 2 ] . The Gauss–Bonnet coupling in ( II.4 ) is a standard scalar–Gauss–Bonnet interaction. In four dimensions a constant coefficient multiplying G is topological [ 7 , 8 ] , but the present coefficient \phi/M^{2} is dynamical and therefore contributes to the field equations. III Horndeski mapping and background III.1 Horndeski representation We use the standard generalized Horndeski convention \displaystyle{\cal L}_{2} \displaystyle=G_{2}(\phi,X), (III.1) \displaystyle{\cal L}_{3} \displaystyle=-G_{3}(\phi,X)\Box\phi, (III.2) \displaystyle{\cal L}_{4} \displaystyle=G_{4}(\phi,X)R+G_{4X}\left[(\Box\phi)^{2}-(\nabla_{\mu}\nabla_{\nu}\phi)^{2}\right], (III.3) \displaystyle{\cal

Read the complete text