The λ \lambda - 𝖯𝖲𝖯 \mathsf{PSP} at λ \lambda - Π 1 1 \Pi^{1}_{1} sets

Fernando Barrera, Vincenzo Dimonte, Sandra Müller · 2025

Read The λ \lambda - 𝖯𝖲𝖯 \mathsf{PSP} at λ \lambda - Π 1 1 \Pi^{1}_{1} sets by Fernando Barrera, Vincenzo Dimonte, Sandra Müller (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15675.txt.

Introduction

Set theorists study how orderly very large collections of sets can be. Fernando Barrera, Vincenzo Dimonte, and Sandra Müller wrote this 2025 paper on one order property, called the PSP, at a special size known as a strong limit cardinal. They look at sets that can be defined by a certain kind of formula in a widened version of the Cantor space.

The team proves two results about how strong the wider world of sets must be if every such set has the property. In one case, a sharp object known as zero dagger must exist. In the other, some inner model must hold a measurable cardinal. The paper spells out the inner model steps in full detail. That care is meant to give other set theorists tools they can reuse.

Catalog record

CREATORFernando Barrera, Vincenzo Dimonte, Sandra Müller
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15675

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The λ \lambda - 𝖯𝖲𝖯 \mathsf{PSP} at λ \lambda - Π 1 1 \Pi^{1}_{1} sets Fernando Barrera, Vincenzo Dimonte, Sandra Müller Abstract . Given a strong limit cardinal λ \lambda of countable cofinality, we show that if every (boldface) λ ​ - ​ 𝚷 1 1 \lambda{\hbox{-}}\boldsymbol{\Pi}^{1}_{1} subset of the generalised Cantor space 2 λ {}^{\lambda}2 has the λ \lambda - 𝖯𝖲𝖯 \mathsf{PSP} , then 0 † 0^{\dagger} exists. We show too that if every (lightface) λ ​ - ​ Π 1 1 \lambda{\hbox{-}}\Pi^{1}_{1} subset of 2 λ {}^{\lambda}2 has the λ ​ - ​ 𝖯𝖲𝖯 \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} , then there is an inner model with a measurable cardinal. The paper, a contribution to the ongoing research on generalised regularity properties in generalised descriptive set theory at singular cardinals of countable cofinality, is aimed at descriptive set theorists, and so it presents its results in as much detail as possible, particularly regarding the inner model-theoretic aspects. In doing so, we intend to provide the community with the tools needed to handle consistency strength arguments at the corresponding levels. 1. Introduction In recent years, the study of higher Baire and Cantor spaces has been subject of growing interest, although most of the literature has focused on versions of those spaces in which, roughly speaking, the role of \omega is played by an uncountable regular cardinal. In this paper, however, singular cardinals of countable cofinality take on that role. Mainly motivated by the work of Cramer, Shi and Woodin on the set-theoretic descriptive properties of L(V_{\lambda+1}) under the very large cardinal assumption I0(\lambda) , properties similar to those that L(\mathbb{R}) exhibits under \mathsf{AD}^{L(\mathbb{R})} , the systematic study of generalised descriptive set theory ( \mathsf{GDST} , from now on) at singular cardinals of countable cofinality has been initially carried out by Dimonte and Motto Ros ( [ 5 ] ), and has been lately enriched by works of Dimonte, Lücke, Iannella, Poveda and Thei ( [ 4 ] , [ 6 ] ). As in classical descriptive set theory, one of the major themes in \mathsf{GDST} is the study of the so-called (generalised) regularity properties, to which this paper contributes by providing a consistency strength lower bound to the satisfaction of the \lambda -Perfect Set Property at the lowest level in the \lambda -analytical and \lambda -projective hierarchies at which it consistently fails. Recall that a subset A of a Polish space X has the \mathsf{PSP} if it is either countable or {}^{\omega}2 embeds into A . Its generalised variant asserts that a subset A of a \lambda -Polish space X has the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} if either it is of size less than or equal to \lambda or {}^{\lambda}2 embeds into A as a closed-in- X set. It is a well known result of Souslin that all analytic sets have the \mathsf{PSP} . In the generalised setting at singular cardinals of countable cofinality, Dimonte and Motto Ros have proved that all \lambda -analytic sets have the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} as well. Extending the \mathsf{PSP} and the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} further in the projective hierarchy involves, in both cases, large cardinals. In the classical case, the consistency strength is quite low: “all the coanalytic sets have the \mathsf{PSP} ” is equiconsistent to the existence of an inaccessible cardinal, as it is “all the projective sets have the \mathsf{PSP} ”. Even below that, Gödel proved that in L there is a (lightface) \Pi^{1}_{1} set without the \mathsf{PSP} , therefore “all the \Pi^{1}_{1} sets have the \mathsf{PSP} ” cannot be a theorem of \mathsf{ZFC} , assumed its consistency. The generalised case is still under study: Dimonte and Motto Ros have proved that in L there is a \lambda -coanalytic subset of {}^{\lambda}2 without the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} , and that the lower bound of all \lambda -coanalytic sets of \lambda -reals having the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} is 0^{\sharp} ( [ 5 , Corollary 7.2.11] ), a bound that, as the authors noted, can be easily raised up to a^{\sharp} for every a\in{}^{\lambda}2 ; Lücke and Müller proved that “all the sets that are definable with a \lambda{\hbox{-}}\Sigma^{1}_{2} formula with parameters in H_{\lambda}\cup\{\lambda\} have the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} ” is equiconsistent to the existence of an inner model with \omega -many measurable cardinals ( [ 11 ] ); as an all-encompassing upper bound, recent work by Dimonte, Poveda and Thei shows that, assuming a <\theta -supercompact cardinal \lambda with \lambda<\theta and \theta inaccessible, there exists a model of \mathsf{ZFC} where \lambda is a strong limit cardinal of countable cofinality and every set in \mathcal{P}({}^{\omega}\lambda)\cap L(V_{\lambda+1}) has the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} ( [ 6 , Main Theorem 1] ). In this paper, we improve the stated lower bound in two distinct ways. First, we establish the following result, which is slightly stronger than a formulation that only concerns \lambda -coanalytic sets: Corollary 3.21 . If there is an uncountable strong limit cardinal \lambda of countable cofinality such that all (lightface) \lambda{\hbox{-}}\Pi^{1}_{1} subsets of {}^{\lambda}2 have the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} , then there is an inner model with a measurable cardinal. Moving further up the large cardinal hierarchy requires us to shift from the class of (lightface) \lambda{\hbox{-}}\Pi^{1}_{1} subsets of {}^{\lambda}2 to the broader class of \lambda -coanalytic sets. We prove the following: Corollary 4.8 . If there is an uncountable strong limit cardinal \lambda of countable cofinality such that all \lambda -coanalytic subsets of {}^{\lambda}2 have the \lambda{\hbox{-}}\mathsf{PSP} , then 0^{\dagger} exists. The paper is organised as follows. In Section 2 , we recall the basics of \mathsf{GDST} at singular cardinals of countable cofinality and review all necessary background results. Here, we collect the description of the \lambda -projective and \lambda -analytical hierarchies together with some results on codes for structures of size \lambda . This section also includes a toy example which, although not framed in a descriptive set-theoretic context, illustrates how core models can be used to obtain consistency strength lower bounds. Sections 3 and 4 deal with inner model theoretic notions at the level of the existence of an inner model with a measurable cardinal and 0^{\dagger} . As these topics may be unfamiliar to part of our audience, we try to provide as much detail as possible. In Section 3 , we study codes for Dodd-Jensen premice and mice of size \lambda and obtain their (generalised) descriptive complexity, as well as the descriptive complexity of other sets relevant to our study. Here, Corollary 3.21 is proved. In Section 4 , we extend the previous discussion to L[U] , and prove Corollary 4.8 . Section 5 concludes with some final remarks. Acknowledgments. The first and second authors were partially supported by Progetto PRIN 2022 – Models, Sets and Classifications – Code no. 2022TECZJA CUP G53D23001890006, funded by the European Union – NextGenerationEU – PNRR M4 C2 I1.1 . The first author has also been partially supported by the OeAD Ernst Mach grant - worldwide . The first author would like to thank Omer Ben-Neria for suggesting, at the beginning of this project, the use of the Dodd-Jensen core model. He also wishes to thank Philipp Lücke for valuable discussions during the Determinacy, Inner Models and Forcing Axioms workshop held at the Erwin Schrödinger International Institute for Mathematics and Physics (ESI), Vienna, in June 2024, and several more after. The first and

Read the complete text