Cayley’s First Hyperdeterminant is an Entanglement Measure

Isaac Dobes, Naihuan Jing · 2025

Read Cayley’s First Hyperdeterminant is an Entanglement Measure by Isaac Dobes, Naihuan Jing (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15511.txt.

Introduction

Isaac Dobes and Naihuan Jing prove that a classic algebra object measures quantum entanglement in a 2025 paper. Cayley first hyperdeterminant already encodes two known entanglement scores for even qubit counts. The pair ask whether a power of it counts as a true measure under physics rules. A true measure must vanish on separable states and never grow under local work.

Their proof covers both pure and mixed states in full. The quantity stays fixed under local unitary moves. It also fails to rise on average under local operations with messages. Worked examples show it detects genuine many party GHZ type links. The result widens entanglement scoring to higher level systems.

Catalog record

CREATORIsaac Dobes, Naihuan Jing
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15511

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cayley’s First Hyperdeterminant is an Entanglement Measure Isaac Dobes, Naihuan Jing Abstract Previously, it was shown that both the concurrence and n n -tangle on 2 ​ n 2n -qubit pure quantum states can be expressed in terms of Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant [ 1 ] , indicating that Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant, denoted hdet \mathrm{hdet} , captures some aspects of a state’s 2 ​ n 2n -way entanglement. In this paper, we rigorously prove that on both pure and mixed states, | hdet | 2 / d |\mathrm{hdet}|^{2/d} is identically zero on separable states, is an LU invariant, and is non-increasing on average under LOCC, thus demonstrating that | hdet | d / 2 |\mathrm{hdet}|^{d/2} is a physically meaningful and legitimate entanglement measure. Moreover, we discuss a few key examples to illustrate the particular type of entanglement Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant is detecting: genuine full d d -level GHZ-type entanglement across all 2 ​ n 2n parties. Combined, this establishes Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant (or | hdet | 2 / d |\mathrm{hdet}|^{2/d} to be precise), as a physically significant generalization of the G G -concurrence and the n n -tangle to 2 ​ n 2n -qudit states. 1 Introduction To compare classes of entangled quantum states, as well as states within the same entanglement class, it would be ideal to derive a function that continuously quantifies all possible levels of the entanglement for any arbitrary state. For pure states in bipartite quantum systems, it is widely agreed that their precise level of entanglement is derived from their Schmidt coefficients [ 2 , 3 ] . However, for states of multipartite quantum states, the situation is more complicated and ambiguous. Indeed, at the time of writing, there is currently no universally agreed upon mathematical structure which completely determines an arbitrary multipartite state’s entanglement, or a complete set of criteria that unambiguously determines whether or not a function defined on arbitrary multipartite quantum states is a valid entanglement measure. Furthermore, this current status is unlikely to change [ 4 ] due to the fact that multipartite quantum states can be entangled in different, inequivalent ways [ 5 ] . Nonetheless, there are a few key properties that most researcher’s agree any legitimate measure of entanglement ought to satisfy. In the late 1990’s numerous landmark papers were published on quantifying entanglement, and in these papers a variety of physically significant properties were listed as axioms that any proposed entanglement measure E ought to satisfy; e.g, [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] (see also [ 10 , 11 ] for more recent summaries and analysis of aforementioned papers). While the properties listed varies depending on the paper, three properties that show up in nearly all such papers are the following: 1. E is nonnegative and 0 on separable states 2. E is invariant under local unitary (LU) operations 3. E is non-increasing on average under local operations and classical communications (LOCC) Property 1. is due to the fact that by definition separable states posses no entanglement, hence any entanglement measure E should be minimized on such states. Property 2. is salient because LU operations are reversible local change of reference frames independently applied to each party, hence no information is transferred between parties and their correlations are unaffected, in which case E should remain unchanged [ 12 ] . Property 3. is also crucial because while local measurements can in some instances increase the amount of entanglement in a partially entangled state [ 13 ] , entanglement is a non-local resource, so its expected value over all measurement outcomes cannot be increased by local operations and classical communication alone. Note also that in Property 3. , when we say ”on average,” we precisely mean that if \rho (which may represent a pure or mixed state) is transformed via a LOCC protocol into the mixture of states \sum\limits_{j}p_{j}\rho_{j} , then \sum\limits_{j}p_{j}E(\rho_{j})\leq E(\rho). If E satisfies Properties 2. and 3. , then E is referred to as an ”entanglement monotone” [ 8 ] , and if E satisfies all three properties above, then it is reasonable to refer to it as an ”entanglement measure”; for the sake of convenience, we refer to the above three properties as the ”entanglement measure axioms”. Note that the entanglement measure axioms are by no means the only properties one might desire an entanglement measure to satisfy. For instance, convexity and additivity (or at least sub-additivity) are other properties typically desired in an entanglement measure, however it is the above three that are of the most fundamental importance and found throughout virtually all of the relevant literature [ 10 , 14 ] . Note also that Property 1. is sometimes strengthened to: E(\rho)=0 if and only if \rho is separable, however this is a very strong condition and there are numerous well-established entanglement measures which do not satisfy this, e.g. the negativity, the entanglement of purification (which does not even satisfy Property 1. [ 11 ] ), and the concurrence/ n -tangle on 2n -qubit pure quantum states. Property 3. is also often modified to: E is non-increasing on average under stochastic local operations and classical communications (SLOCC) [ 10 , 11 ] , whereby SLOCC we mean that \rho can be transformed into the state \sigma via a LOCC protocol with nonzero probability. Two popular entanglement measures are the concurrence and the n -tangle. The concurrence was originally formulated to define the entanglement of formation [ 15 , 16 ] , and on pure states of 2n -qubits it is given by C(\ket{\psi}):=|\innerproduct{\widetilde{\psi}}{\psi}|, where \ket{\widetilde{\psi}}:=\sigma_{y}^{\otimes 2n}\ket{\psi^*} with \sigma_{y} denoting the Pauli matrix \left[\begin{array}[]{cc}0&-i\\ i&0\end{array}\right] . The 3 -tangle was originally formulated to detect GHZ-type entanglement of 3 -qubit states [ 5 ] , and then soon afterwards it was extended to pure states of 2n -qubits [ 17 ] . In addition to demonstrating the detection of 2n -qubit GHZ-type entanglement in pure states of 2n -qubits, it was also shown in [ 17 ] that in fact the n -tangle is the square of the concurrence on pure states of 2n -qubits; that is, \tau_{n}(\ket{\psi})=C(\ket{\psi})^{2}=|\innerproduct{\widetilde{\psi}}{\psi}|^{2}. About 20 years later, it was shown in [ 1 ] that the concurrence, and hence the n -tangle, may be expressed in terms of Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant when viewed as a quadratic form in the coefficients of a pure 2n -qubit state \ket{\psi} . In particular, I. Dobes and N. Jing prove using elementary combinatorics that \widehat{\mathrm{Ent}}_{n}=\frac{(-1)^{n}}{2}\sigma_{y}^{\otimes 2n}, (1) with \widehat{\mathrm{Ent}}_{n} denoting the matrix of the quadratic form given by Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant. Denoting Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant as \mathrm{hdet} , from equation ( 1 ) it is then easy to show that C(\ket{\psi})=2|\mathrm{hdet}(\widehat{\psi})| and hence \tau_{n}(\ket{\psi})=4|\mathrm{hdet}(\widehat{\psi})|^{2}, where \widehat{\psi} denotes the tensor representation of \ket{\psi} (further discussed in the next section). These results, in addition to the known fact that the hyperdeterminant is invariant under (special) unitary operations [ 18 ] , indicate that Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant captures at least some aspects of a quantum state’s entanglement. Unlike the concurrence and the n -tangle, however, Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant is also defined and non-trivial on pure state of 2n -qudits for any d\geq 2 . This suggests that Cayley’s first hyperdeterminant may in fact be

Read the complete text