The Impact of Plasma Angular Momentum on Magnetically Arrested Flows and Relativistic Jets in Hot Accretion Flows Around Black Holes

Ho-Sang Chan, Prasun Dhang, Jason Dexter, Mitchell C. Begelman · 2025

Read The Impact of Plasma Angular Momentum on Magnetically Arrested Flows and Relativistic Jets in Hot Accretion Flows Around Black Holes by Ho-Sang Chan, Prasun Dhang, Jason Dexter, Mitchell C. Begelman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2504-15489.txt.

Introduction

Ho-Sang Chan, Prasun Dhang, Jason Dexter, and Mitchell Begelman simulate what happens when gas falling into a black hole carries little spin of its own, in a 2025 paper. In the standard picture, strong magnetic fields can dam the inflow and power a jet, a state called magnetically arrested. The team ran 3D simulations around a fast-spinning black hole, scaling the gas spin from zero upward.

With no spin at all, the arrested state and its jet lasted only briefly before free-falling gas broke through and wrecked the structure, while magnetic bubbles floated away. A tenth of normal spin made the system flicker between states. From about a third upward, behavior settled toward the standard picture.

Catalog record

CREATORHo-Sang Chan, Prasun Dhang, Jason Dexter, Mitchell C. Begelman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504-15489

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Impact of Plasma Angular Momentum on Magnetically Arrested Flows and Relativistic Jets in Hot Accretion Flows Around Black Holes Ho-Sang Chan, Prasun Dhang, Jason Dexter, Mitchell C. Begelman Abstract In certain scenarios, the accreted angular momentum of plasma onto a black hole could be low; however, how the accretion dynamics depend on the angular momentum content of the plasma is still not fully understood. We present three-dimensional, general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of low angular momentum accretion flows around rapidly spinning black holes (with spin a = + 0.9 a=+0.9 ). The initial condition is a Fishbone-Moncrief (FM) torus threaded by a large amount of poloidal magnetic flux, where the angular velocity is a fraction f f of the standard value. For f = 0 f=0 , the accretion flow becomes magnetically arrested and launches relativistic jets but only for a very short duration. After that, free-falling plasma breaks through the magnetic barrier, loading the jet with mass and destroying the jet-disk structure. Meanwhile, magnetic flux is lost via giant, asymmetrical magnetic bubbles that float away from the black hole. The accretion then exits the magnetically arrested state. For f = 0.1 f=0.1 , the dimensionless magnetic flux threading the black hole oscillates quasi-periodically. The jet-disk structure shows concurrent revival and destruction while the gas outflow efficiency at the event horizon changes accordingly. For f ≥ 0.3 f\geq 0.3 , we find that the dynamical behavior of the system starts to approach that of a standard accreting FM torus. Our results thus suggest that the accreted angular momentum is an important parameter that governs the maintenance of a magnetically arrested flow and launching of relativistic jets around black holes. Journal: ApJ I Introduction The difference between radio-loud and radio-quiet galaxies lies in the ability of the former to produce large-scale radio jets, the energy of which is a significant fraction of the total bolometric luminosity [ 32 ] . It is now widely accepted that relativistic jets are produced via the Blandford–Znajek process [ 2 ] , in which poloidal magnetic fields threading the black hole extract angular momentum and spin energy from the hole and help accelerate plasma to relativistic speeds. More importantly, numerical simulations of black hole accretion have found that the accumulation of intense magnetic flux on the black hole can form a magnetically arrested disk (MAD) state [ 29 ] . This provides an ideal scenario for the Blandford-Znajek process to operate and launch bipolar collimated outflows with a jet efficiency greater than 100 \% . The production of relativistic jets thus seems to rely on two critical parameters: 1) the spin of the black hole and 2) the amount of magnetic flux threading its event horizon. The Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration (EHTC) released spatially resolved, polarized images of the supermassive black hole at our (radio-quiet) Galactic Center, Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*). These results suggest that the black hole could be spinning [ 8 ] , and the magnetic field close to the event horizon is dynamically important [ 10 ] . Thus, the accreting plasma should be strongly magnetized so that the black hole should have entered the MAD state and launched relativistic jets. However, no radio jet has been observed to emanate from Sgr A*. The fact that Sgr A* contains dynamically important magnetic fields but no relativistic jet is observed seems contradictory. In view of this, we are motivated to examine whether some other factor is preventing the formation of a relativistic jet. One such possibility is that the black hole is spinning slowly [ 18 ] ; An alternative, which we focus on here, is that the accreting gas itself lacks angular momentum. Previous studies have shown that accreted angular momentum plays an important role in the subsequent dynamical evolution of the accreting black hole, especially when magnetic effects are included. Igumenshchev & Narayan [13] examined radiatively inefficient spherical accretion onto a black hole, where the plasma is immersed in a weak vertical magnetic field. They found that the presence of a magnetic field significantly alters the accretion dynamics compared to the Bondi solution. Magnetic fields are amplified through flux freezing, reaching equipartition with the gas pressure and initiating reconnection. The reconnection is self-sustained via gas convection and further magnetic reconnection. The resulting dynamics exhibits a highly subsonic inflow velocity and a mass accretion rate well below the value predicted by the Bondi solution. Later, Proga & Begelman [23] studied spherical accretion onto black holes with a modest amount of angular momentum. They showed that threading the initially isotropic and homogeneous plasma with a weak poloidal magnetic field drastically reduces mass accretion rates. The spherical free-fall of the material drags the magnetic field to the horizon, forming a magnetic barrier that prohibits matter from falling onto the black hole. Bipolar outflows are launched, pushing away free-falling material along the pole. The magnetorotational instability redistributes the angular momentum of material with too much angular momentum to be accreted, forming an accretion disk around the black hole. Notably, Pen et al. [21] , Pang et al. [20] discovered a class of magnetically frustrated convection, in which magnetic shear stresses counteract buoyant motions. This leads to an inflow of energy despite the presence of convective motion. Neither steady outflow nor rotationally supported flow has been observed. The accretion of low angular momentum plasma onto spinning black holes, where the frame-dragging effects are self-consistently taken into account, has only recently been examined 1 1 1 See also Kwan et al. [15] . Ressler et al. [26] reported a series of GRMHD simulations of spherical accretion onto spinning black holes, with the large-scale coherent magnetic field making different angles \psi with the black hole’s spin axis. They found that magnetic fields are amplified via flux freezing, reconnect, and drive turbulence. Relativistic jets propagate to a few hundred gravitational radii ( GM/c^{2} ) before dissipating due to kink instability. Except for the ‘sweet spot’ angle \psi=60^{\circ} , none of their models sustain a MAD state, but are otherwise semi-MAD ( \phi_{\rm BH}\gtrsim 20 ) with a gas outflow efficiency as low as 10 %. For \psi\sim 30^{\circ} or 90^{\circ} , an initial bump followed by a significant drop in \Phi_{\rm BH} is observed. In several instances, the infalling gas fills one side of the bipolar jet, but the polar region is quickly evacuated, creating a semi-sustainable outflow. Meanwhile, Lalakos et al. [16] presented a high-resolution GRMHD simulation of spherical accretion threaded by a weak vertical magnetic field. The initially launched relativistic jet propagates to \sim 1500 GM/c^{2} . The accretion has a saturated \phi_{\rm BH}\sim 50 for a long duration ( \sim 34000 GM/c^{3} ). After that, the power of the jet shuts off, with an associated drop in \phi_{\rm BH} to a level of \sim 20 and \eta\sim 10-15 %. In the aftermath, the transient jets are weak and dissipate within the Bondi radius. The accretion attains the MAD state, but only for a finite duration. These results suggest that the angular momentum content is a crucial parameter, in addition to the magnetic flux and the black hole spin, that governs strongly magnetized accretion and the launching of relativistic jets. However, why the angular momentum content is

Read the complete text